Lego and NZ-founded company Zuru's long-running legal fight reaches Supreme Court

Lego and NZ-founded company Zuru's long-running legal fight reaches Supreme Court

A long-running legal fight between toy giant Lego and New Zealand-founded company Zuru has reached the Supreme Court.Lego is appealing a 2025 Court of Appeal decision allowing Zuru to use the Lego trademark on its packaging.The heart of the dispute centres on a simple phrase printed on packaging of Zuru's Max Build More toy brick building kits: "LEGO® BRICK COMPATIBLE".Following objections by Lego, Zuru - owned by Mat and Nick Mowbray - brought a case to the High Court in 2023 to keep referring to the brand in that way on its packaging.The High Court agreed Zuru had infringed Lego's trademark, whereas the Court of Appeal ruled that it hadn't.In the Supreme Court, Lawyer for Lego, Alan Galbraith KC, said if the average consumer saw the wording as associating Zuru with Lego, then that would infringe the trademark."The Court has to put itself in the shoes of the consumer."Galbraith said using an association with Lego on packaging would benefit Zuru, boosting a perception of quality."If you can start putting Lego in this form on 25 other products, you've - in our respectful submission - severely damaged the integrity of the Lego brand."And obviously create confusion in the marketplace."Justice Joe Williams asked Galbraith why that was so pernicious, when fast-food outlets of varying quality were regularly located next to each other."It's leveraging off your goodwill, but is that such a bad thing ... in an open market?"Galbraith replied it was "undermining", and that the point of trademarks were to create protections for a brand's value.He referred to Trade Mark law in New Zealand, including a 2002 Act which has a section outlawing the use of a trademark in sales where that would deceive or confuse people.Justice Stephen Kós asked Lego's lawyers what was wrong with informing busy consumers Zuru's bricks worked with Lego's.Why do you put it behind a "smokescreen" of major brands, Kós asked.Galbraith referred again to the integrity of the brand, and said the wording was outside industry practice. "Nobody before this has tried it in this sort of way."Another of Lego's lawyers, Kevin Glover, said it wasn't "reasonably necessary" for Zuru to refer to Lego on its packaging - the product hadn't been hampered by using the phrase "compatible with major brands".Glover said allowing other brands to use Lego's trademark would soon become a "Sisyphean" task, or a "game of whack-a-mole" for the company to police the use of its trademarks on other toy brands' packaging.In 2025, the Court of Appeal judges had found Zuru's statement to be purely descriptive, telling consumers the bricks work with Lego, not that they were actual Lego bricks.In its written decision, the court said, "When use of Lego is seen in its full context, the consumer would think that Zuru's bricks were Max Build More bricks." "The phrase 'LEGO® BRICK COMPATIBLE' is descriptive, not a badge of origin."The court is due to hear submissions from Zuru's lawyers on Wednesday. The appeal is set down for two days.

Original Source

Read the full article at Rnz →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.