On Oct. 1, 2012, my party lost Georgia’s parliamentary election. The next day, President Mikheil Saakashvili went on television and conceded. It was the first time since independence that a Georgian government lost an election and left. In the years since, it has not happened again.Before a single ballot was counted on Nov. 3, both American camps had a stolen-election script ready. As I reported here on Election Day, leaked recordings showed veterans of U.S. democracy promotion planning for a “legitimacy crisis” at home. In July, President Donald Trump used a prime-time address to revive doubts about past elections. Only the villain’s name was left blank.For 18 months, the No Kings movement told Americans they lived under a monarch. Fox News Digital counted about 300 organizations behind its protests, with $2.5 billion in combined annual revenue. In October, the movement switched to early voting. A White House spokeswoman said the switch proved its organizers “should change their name.” On this, I agree with the White House. Try winning an election with such a network in Moscow, Pyongyang, or even Tbilisi. Two days before the vote, a Reuters headline had the White House mapping a path “to govern without Congress” if Democrats won. The path: tariffs, visa rules, grant rules, and, Trump said, vetoes for “a month or two” before compromising. A monarch who budgets two months for compromise.Then the monarch lost the House and the Senate. He congratulated the Democrats on a “good job” and told the New York Times he would accept the result. Days later, he asked the outgoing Senate to confirm 161 nominees, including 25 judges. Kings do not need confirmation hearings.Then came the other script. In one week, the president posted five explanations for one defeat. Texas Gov. Greg Abbott (R-TX), he wrote, lost for becoming a RINO. Then: “I JUST WASN’T ON THE BALLOT.” Then the Senate, for being “pushed around to the point of the Republican Party losing Elections.” Then: “It’s all about the machines, which are far more important than the voter!” Then Alaska: a “Rigged Election.” One post he shared carried a chart titled “The voters who stayed home were Republicans.”Pick one. You cannot have all five. The numbers already picked.In Texas, 9.8 million voted out of a record 19 million registered, a lower share than in 2018 or 2024. By that post’s own figures, Abbott beat his 2022 vote total, and his Democratic opponent topped the 2022 Democrat by about 1.7 million. Republicans did not vanish. Democrats showed up, and voters came early. More than 61.7 million ballots were cast nationwide before Election Day, a midterm record. The president called early votes “dumps.”Nationally, Republicans lost ground from 2024 in 99% of some 2,100 counties counted. Another post the president shared called the swing strange: “Wyoming, Ohio, Illinois, Massachusetts: same 15%.” Even is what a national mood looks like. Fraud is lumpy. It goes where it pays. Nobody wastes fake ballots in Wyoming.”Missing ID cannot explain it either. That post lists six states as flipped: Texas, Kansas, Iowa, Ohio, South Carolina, and North Carolina. All six require ID at the polls. Texans without photo ID must still show another document and sign a sworn declaration. Abbott conceded on election night. The state’s Republican Party chairwoman said: “Tonight, we accept the results.”In Alaska, two Dan Sullivans ran for the Senate: the Republican incumbent Sen. Dan S. Sullivan (R-AK) and a retired teacher, Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. The New York Times reported that Democrat Mary Peltola’s campaign helped recruit him. Peltola denies it; so does he.I have watched this trick before. In St. Petersburg in 2021, opposition lawmaker Boris Vishnevsky found two more Boris Vishnevskys on his ballot.What happened next is the difference. The second Sullivan drew under 2%, fewer votes than a minor Republican candidate, and early data show more of his voters ranked Peltola second than the senator. On Nov. 7, the president declared, “Dan Sullivan WON, BY A LOT!” Six days later, Peltola led by 5,800 first-choice votes, more than Dan J. Sullivan’s entire tally. Trump’s remedy: Give the real Sullivan the votes of both, including the Republican he says the Democrats planted. Alaska’s remedy: Count its voters’ own choices.I spent 12 years in Georgia’s security ministries. Real election theft has a sequence. Before the vote, the inconvenient candidate never reaches the ballot, and state television tells voters whom to fear. On voting day, public employees are bused in, and votes are bought. After the vote, numbers change between the precinct and the central commission.America’s weak spots are different. The SAVE America Act, requiring proof of citizenship to register and photo ID to vote, failed a procedural Senate vote in June, 48-50, with four Republicans joining every Democrat. A federal judge called the Trump Justice Department’s demand for 23 million Californians’ unredacted voter records “unprecedented and illegal.” In New Jersey, a software error registered about 6,600 self-declared noncitizens, but fewer than 400 voted. A Democratic governor disclosed it.In my Georgia, no ID means no ballot. America has no national ID card, and more than a dozen states require none at the polls. That is an argument for reform. It is not proof of theft. Every unproven fraud claim makes reform harder to pass.“Does MAGA have a future?” a Christian Science Monitor headline asked the day after the vote. “It may not.”The ink on such obituaries was still wet when the winners began fighting over the will. Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-VT) announced he would not back Sen. Chuck Schumer (D-NY) as Democratic leader: “The time is now for change.” Neither will Sen. Elissa Slotkin (D-MI), a moderate. Then Sen. Chris Van Hollen (D-MD) challenged Schumer outright, the first contested race for Senate Democratic leader since 1994. The Democratic Socialists of America, now eight-strong in Congress, say they will fight to “break” the U.S.-Israel relationship and challenge Schumer. Elections hand a party power. They do not hand it a single will.A midterm is a thermometer, not a verdict. Since 1946, the president’s party has lost House seats in 19 of 21 midterm elections. Reagan lost 26 seats in 1982, then carried 49 states in 1984. Obama lost 63 in 2010, then won again in 2012. A lost Congress is not a lost presidency, as I wrote here on Nov. 6. A won election is not an arrest warrant. Neither is a lost one. Rep. Robert Garcia (D-CA), the likely next chairman of the House oversight committee, posted “LAWYER UP.” The president called Democrats who threaten impeachment “EXTORTIONISTS” and ordered the Justice Department to investigate.The accusations change sides. The problem stays. In 2014, House Speaker John Boehner said Obama claimed not to be a king, “but he’s sure acting like one.” In 2018, after losing in the other Georgia, Stacey Abrams said, “This is not a speech of concession.” In 2019, Hillary Clinton called Trump an “illegitimate president.”In the Russian-language media I monitor, the FBI has already arrested “many people” in Texas and seized every voting machine. The Trump Justice Department did announce charges against 63 people nationwide on Nov. 2, five in Texas. Five. Fact-checkers traced the machine story to a self-described comedian.The test should be the same for everyone. The 2020 lawsuits by Trump and his allies were nearly all dropped or thrown out. None proved fraud. If the government now has evidence, it should show it. If it can prove crimes, it should prosecute. If it cannot, it should stop.A post the president shared ends with a sentence I would sign: “The ballots can answer it.” Then count them.EVANGELICAL VOTERS LEFT THEIR DISCERNMENT IN 2022Is an election legitimate because it was fair, or because our side won?In Georgia, we answered that question once, on Oct. 2, 2012. We are still waiting to answer it again.Emzari Gelashvili is a San Francisco–based geopolitical analyst and columnist who monitors Russian-language media. From 1996 to 2008, he held senior positions in Georgia’s Ministry of State Security, Ministry of Defense, and Ministry of Internal Affairs, with a counterintelligence career focused on Russian and Iranian intelligence operations, and he was a member of the Georgian Parliament from 2008 to 2012. His work appears in Newsweek, the Hill, the Washington Examiner, RealClearDefense, RealClearWorld, RealClearEducation, and RealClearPolicy, and at emzargelashvili.substack.com.
Kings don’t lose elections. Thieves don’t waste votes in Wyoming
Full Article
Original Source
Read the full article at Washingtonexaminer →KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.