Kerala High Court dismisses lawyer’s plea for contempt proceedings against judge

Kerala High Court dismisses lawyer’s plea for contempt proceedings against judge

The court said it was improper for the media to report such conversations between a lawyer and a judge in a manner that might tarnish their image. The Kerala High Court on Tuesday dismissed lawyer T.B. Mini’s petition seeking contempt of court proceedings against District Judge Honey M. Varghese for allegedly making adverse remarks in a case related to the 2017 actor assault.Justice P.V. Kunhikrishnan found that the petitioner was not present in court when the alleged remarks were made and had relied on her junior lawyer’s statement regarding the incident. The court held that since the junior lawyer had not made a statement in court, there was no material to establish that Ms. Varghese had made the alleged remarks, other than the petitioner’s hearsay account.The court said it was improper for the media to report such conversations between a lawyer and a judge in a manner that might tarnish their image. The media should know, based on experience, what to neglect, it said. “Lawyers deserve dignity and fair treatment, and they should not leave the court after arguing a case, feeling that the court insulted or humiliated them. A lawyer’s right to argue a case on behalf of his/her client before a court of law includes the right to receive fair treatment from the Bench,” the court said.The petitioner alleged that Ms. Varghese had said that she appeared in court for only 10 days during the trial, attended court for only half an hour, and nodded off in court, treating it as a resting place. Ms. Mini claimed that there were eyewitnesses to the incident and that the media amplified the comments immediately after they were made in public.Ms. Mini had sought sanction from the Advocate General (AG) to initiate contempt proceedings against Ms. Varghese. However, the AG said that the alleged statements were not contemptuous but amounted only to excessive or extravagant language, which did not warrant a criminal contempt case.She approached the High Court, aggrieved that the “unwarranted” comments relating to her conduct and character had destroyed her as a person and her reputation as a lawyer.The court observed that the petitioner’s capacity as a lawyer was not in question and that she should not worry about social media comments. The court said it had no doubt about Ms. Mini’s capacity as a lawyer and urged her to carry on with her professional duties, adding that she would one day be rewarded for the same. Published - November 18, 2026 01:16 am IST

Original Source

Read the full article at Thehindu →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.