You may know Katharine Birbalsingh by her sobriquet – “the strictest headmistress in Britain”. The 53-year-old daughter of an Indo-Guyanese academic and a Jamaican nurse (she was born in New Zealand, raised in Canada and moved to the UK at 15) founded the Michaela Community School in Wembley, north London, 12 years ago, and has become a keen advocate of traditional teaching methods. To her, discipline and good manners are essential for academic success. She believes that schools should have high expectations of all their pupils, regardless of background or ability, and she promotes strict behaviour policies, respect and hard work. The school regularly outperforms the national average, but Birbalsingh has drawn criticism from the left, for what they see as her traditional and regressive ideas, and from the right, who are suspicious of her espousal of multicultural values. Her views are forthright and divisive, and some find them unpalatable. She has now written a book, Diversity is Not Our Strength: How the Left and Right Broke Multiculturalism – and How to Fix It, which will doubtless encourage more controversy. I’ve interviewed Birbalsingh before and I’m an admirer of her work; I believe this could be one of the most important books of the year. In it, she argues for “patriotic multiculturalism”, where duties to others should speak louder than our individual rights. This can be fostered, she writes, in ordinary families and, of course, ordinary schools. “What I want to do is make people listen,” she says. “On the left, you have those obsessed with DEI [diversity, equality and inclusion] and anti-racism; and on the right, you have the ethnonationalists – ancestry, deportation etc.” In her mind, “those people are on the extremes and I’m never going to get to them”. Instead, she says, “I’m aiming for those in the centre”.“The centre-left are the liberal multiculturalists who love eating sushi and have a black friend, live in Hampstead and bury their heads in the sand and have absolutely no idea what’s going on. And the centre-right, who are generally my people, might be upset by this book, as they think that fixing multiculturalism is impossible.” You may know Katharine Birbalsingh by her sobriquet, ‘the strictest headmistress in Britain’ (Photo: Stuart Thomas) People across both political camps may very well disagree with this summary – as well as the idea that multiculturalism needs “fixing”. In the book, Birbalsingh is mostly critical of the left, but she is also critical of the right. “When the centre-right talk about multiracial, they say we need something to bind us together. But it’s not true, because we are multicultural. We are not multiracial as a society – that’s Bridgerton: people in the Regency era who all wear the same clothes, dance the same way at parties and do the same stuff, but they’re just different colours. “We shouldn’t want to knock down the temples, the mosques and the synagogues, and we don’t want to stop people wearing Nigerian headdresses. But as soon as you accept multiculturalism, you have to think about how we are managing it,” she says. “We’ve done everything possible to undermine multiculturalism. I’m trying to give a different option: multicultural patriotism – putting the country above our tribe, while celebrating our different tribes. I believe in having a successful multicultural country, but we should put our country first. “Politicians matter, but culture is more important,” she continues. “When it comes to race and diversity, I don’t think people are honest. They pretend because they don’t want to appear racist. It requires bravery, but, unfortunately, the only brave ones are the extremes on both sides. We need the centrists to speak up.” Katharine Birbalsingh’s Michaela school has attracted controversy (Photo: Stuart Thomas) The extreme left, she says, think the problem is white people. “They think the countryside is too racist, that white people have too much power,” she says. “But this encourages the right ethnonationalists, who say we have too many immigrants, and we have ended up more disintegrated than ever. That division is getting worse.” The Michaela Community School has attracted controversy – most notably over its strict behaviour policy and its ban on “prayer rituals” in a student body where about half of pupils are Muslim. But I have visited it three times, and it is the most impressive state school I have ever seen, with a collective spirit of efficiency, ambition and respect. The pupils all wear a uniform, phones are banned and they act as though they have voluntarily signed up for an educational army. At a time when there is growing pressure on teenagers to see themselves as their own personal brand, the overarching sense here is one of success through harmony. And while Birbalsingh’s book is a treatise on society as a whole, its roots are in her experiences as a head teacher. “Whenever I hear a politician, educationalist, podcaster or journalist talk about multiculturalism, I hear an absence of knowledge. Childhood matters and you have to catch people early,” she says. She brings up the right-wing author Jordan Peterson, whose visit to the school in 2022 sparked public debate and criticism. “Since [he] came to the school, he has started talking about schools, but most people don’t. I’ve watched how the country is falling apart because we don’t take enough interest in children.” In her mind, this interest should be about making them proud of their lives but also proud of their country. “Harmony needs to be achieved, and you can only do that by teaching children to have respect for their country,” she argues. “We have taught our children to hate our country, so naturally they don’t want to wear the poppy. But not in our school. We make them grateful for the freedoms we have. I don’t know of another school in the country where every pupil will wear a poppy. People in their twenties only see the country as the oppressors and the oppressed because that’s what they’ve been taught, and they can’t see the world in any other way.” Katharine Birbalsingh argues for ‘patriotic multiculturalism’ in her new book Whether or not it is true that today’s children have been taught to hate the country, her school certainly follows a distinctive ethos. “The culture at Michaela is that it doesn’t matter how little you have, you also have an opportunity to make the most of your life. And we teach them gratitude. “We teach them that living in Britain is pretty amazing. We are very lucky to be here. Schools should teach British history, which obviously includes black and brown people, but you don’t need to march around saying this needs to be done in a special month, or we need special consideration. “We all need to show respect and deference to the country, including white people. The ethnonationalists are wrong in thinking that it’s all the fault of ethnic minorities – never forget that the police in front of [murdered student] Henry Nowak were white.” Birbalsingh has been withering in her comments about the former education secretary, Bridget Phillipson, accusing her of being a Marxist, but has even harsher words for the incumbent, Lucy Powell. “[She] is 100 times worse than Phillipson, as she is an ideologue.” By focusing on vocational and technical education and moving away from traditional forms of education, “she is about to ruin the entire education system, even though a lot of Labour-supporting teachers are begging her to stop. She is blind to what works, and doesn’t care, even though our schools are improving”, she says. “Ideologues would rather harm disadvantaged children than actually change their minds. Lucy doesn’t listen to advisers and I’m afraid that Andy Burnham is going down that same road. He hasn’t got the strength of character to lead the country. You can’t be henpecked by white guilt.” Powell’s team declined to comment when these remarks were put to them. But if Birbalsingh sounds pessimistic about the future of the country, she isn’t. “Change will come if we parent like we are at war with a world that is not giving us the values our children need,” she says. “Change will come if our schools embody the values, responsibility and respect required, rather than engineering the guilt, victimhood and individualism that have brought us to this place. Change will come if we have the bravery to live by the values that are, ultimately, our real strength.” ‘Diversity is Not Our Strength’ (Constable, £25) is out now
Katharine Birbalsingh: ‘We have taught our children to hate our country’
Full Article
Original Source
Read the full article at Inews →KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.