Karnataka High Court grants relief to medical seat aspirant, says mere possession of mobile phone cannot be termed ‘unfair means’

Karnataka High Court grants relief to medical seat aspirant, says mere possession of mobile phone cannot be termed ‘unfair means’

A view of high court of Karnataka in Bengaluru. | Photo Credit: ALLEN EGENUSE J The Karnataka High Court has quashed the National Testing Agency’s (NTA) decision to withhold the NEET (UG) 2026 re-examination result of a medical student over an allegation that she had carried a mobile phone into an earlier examination that was subsequently cancelled.A Division Bench comprising Justice M. Nagaprasanna and Justice Hema Kulkarni allowed a petition filed by a 20-year-old girl from Ranebennur in Haveri district and directed the NTA to issue her scorecard without any remark indicating that her result was withheld or cancelled.Seat confirmedThe bench also confirmed a medical seat allotted to her in a government medical college in Karnataka based on her rank secured in the re-NEET held on June 21, following the interim order passed by the court earlier allowing her to participate in the seat selection process.The student had appeared for the NEET examination conducted on May 3. However, the NTA cancelled the examination following widespread allegations of question paper leakage and other malpractices and announced a fresh examination on June 21.After issuing a fresh admit card to the student for the re-NEET, the NTA served her a show-cause notice on June 17, alleging that she had carried a mobile phone into the examination premises during the May 3 examination. Her result of the re-NEET was withheld even though she had scored 570 marks out of the total 720 marks.Carried inadvertentlyThe student, in her reply to the show-cause notice, contended that she carried the mobile phone in her pocket inadvertently due to examination anxiety and stress and had never used it. The examination centre authorities had found no incriminating activity on the mobile phone after detecting it, it was contended.However, the NTA defended its action, arguing that carrying a prohibited electronic device into examination premises itself constituted an unfair means practice, irrespective of whether it was actually used.“It must be remembered that the mere possession of a mobile phone, though capable of constituting a breach of examination instructions, cannot, without regard to the governing rules and attendant circumstances, invariably be equated with the actual use of unfair means to secure an undeserved academic advantage. A breach of discipline and the procurement of merit by deception are not necessarily synonymous,” the bench said while rejecting the NTA’s contentions.Noting that the student appeared in the re-NEET without any allegation of violation of norm and had secured a rank that earned her a merit seat, the bench said that “the law must be firm against dishonesty, but it need not be unforgiving towards every inadvertent lapse. An examination authority must be vigilant against malpractice, but vigilance cannot degenerate into rigidity that defeats the very purpose of the examination.” Published - November 19, 2026 09:52 pm IST

Original Source

Read the full article at Thehindu →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.