A judge “erred in law” when he dismissed a £50 million claim for compensation over Scotland’s failed deposit return scheme (DRS), an appeal court has heard.Waste management firm Biffa won a contract as part of Scottish Government plans to bring in the scheme, and it took ministers to court when the initiative was shelved.Biffa had been seeking £51.4 million from the Scottish Government to cover losses it said it had incurred through the failure of the scheme.In January 2026, judge Lord Sandison found against the firm, saying in his judgment that its case “fails in fact and law”.Biffa had argued that former Scottish Green co-leader Lorna Slater, who was the minister in charge of the project, had made a “negligent misrepresentation” in a letter she sent the firm which “provided assurances in respect of the viability of the scheme”.It said the letter, sent in May 2022, had misrepresented the true level of risk facing the project as it failed to mention the Scottish Government would need an exemption from the Internal Market Act (IMA) for it to proceed.The Westminster legislation governs trade between the different parts of the UK post-Brexit.In the event, then Scottish secretary Lord Jack refused to grant the exemption which meant Holyrood ministers could not proceed with plans to include glass bottles in their scheme and, ultimately, left them unable to bring in the scheme as planned in August 2023.Deposit return sees shoppers charged a deposit when buying drinks, with the cash returned to them when they bring their empty cans and bottles back for recycling.Biffa appealed against the ruling, which was heard before a panel of three judges at the Court of Session on Wednesday.Lawyers for the firm said they did not dispute Lord Sandison’s factual findings, but said he had erred on a number of counts in his analysis of them.Greens MSP Lorna Slater was the minister in charge of the project (Jane Barlow/PA)PA ArchiveAndrew McWhirter opened submissions by telling the court: “The commercial judge erred in law in his conclusion that the letter of May 17 2022 was not a negligent misrepresentation.”Read MoreBiffa’s lead counsel, Roddy Dunlop KC, then took up the argument, saying Ms Slater’s letter was “accurate” – but that it was a “half-truth” as it had failed to mention something ministers knew could have scuppered the DRS.“By assuring Biffa of their unwavering commitment to delivering the scheme by August 16 2023 in order to persuade it to contract, there was an implied representation that the ministers knew of no matter which might prevent that from being fulfilled,” he told the court.“And they knew of one because delivery needed an exclusion (from) the IMA which not only did they not have, they had not even sought.”He said the Scottish Government also knew obtaining the exclusion depended on an “unpredictable counterparty” in the form of the UK Government, and that it involved “a process which had previously proven to be lengthy and complex”.Judge Lord Pentland suggested the letter was merely stating a political commitment, as it concerned a “high-priority, political project which that government was supporting”.The lawyer responded: “For what purpose? For the purpose of persuading (Biffa) to enter the contract.”Scottish Secretary Alister Jack refused to grant the exemption (Michal Wachuik/PA)PA ArchiveHe added: “There was no obligation on the ministers to write that letter.“Having chosen to do so, there are consequences that follow if it creates a misleading impression.”Mr Dunlop said by sending a letter of “comfort” to Biffa, in the knowledge that in signing the contract the firm would be exposed to an “eight-figure loss”, the Scottish Government had taken on an “assumption of responsibility” towards the firm.He said on any “sensible basis” this meant it should have disclosed the need for an IMA exclusion – and to the difficulty of obtaining one – prior to the signing of the contract.“If at any time prior to July 2022, Biffa had been told an IMA exclusion had not been applied for or granted, they would not have signed,” he said.The Scottish ministers’ lawyer Gerry Moynihan KC later disputed whether Biffa had understood the letter as providing “unqualified assurances” over the scheme.He said the firm recognised there were “matters outwith the control” of the Scottish Government that could affect it, and that it “continued to have doubts” it would be delivered on time even after receiving the letter.Roddy Dunlop is representing Biffa (Jane Barlow/PA)PA ArchiveMr Moynihan said this was reflected in the evidence of Biffa chief executive Michael Topham.He said: “The evidence of Mr Topham was that it was clear that the (Scottish ministers) alone could not guarantee that the scheme would go live on August 16 2023, because it was for CSL (Circularity Scotland Limited) to deliver it, and Biffa was concerned about CSL’s preparation.”The lawyer said the firm took a number of steps of mitigation before signing the contract.These included the right to terminate the contract if the scheme was not implemented by August 15 2024, and taking out insurance against “legislative delay or cancellation”.“(Mr Topham) did not understand the letter to give a guarantee that the scheme would be implemented by August 16 2023,” he said.“To the opposite, he continued to have concerns about the risk of delay despite the letter, and Biffa only contracted when it had these four mitigations in place.”He said the letter could not have been taken as a guarantee because at the time it was sent the scheme did not have an “infrastructure provider” – the role Biffa later signed a contract to provide.Closing his submissions, Mr Moynihan said: “In circumstances where Biffa quite properly chose not to accept the information they had been given (in the letter), then in my respectful submission there is no proper basis to impose a freestanding duty of care and assumption of responsibility.”At the end of the hearing judge Lord Pentland said it will take “some time” to consider the submissions, and added that a judgment will be issued “as soon as is practicable”.
Judge ‘erred in law’ when he found against Biffa in £50m lawsuit, court told
Full Article
Original Source
Read the full article at Standard →KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.