John Oliver remembers ‘Alligator Alcatraz’: ‘the utter disgrace’

John Oliver remembers ‘Alligator Alcatraz’: ‘the utter disgrace’

John Oliver opened the season finale of Last Week Tonight with a brief reaction to the Federal Aviation Administration’s shock grounding of all US flights on Friday afternoon, which brought nationwide travel to a halt and stranded travelers across the country. He zoned in on transportation secretary Sean Duffy, whose Friday press conference in the midst of a crisis left much to be desired. “Rather than use that press conference to dispense information, which would have been ideal, he instead took it as an opportunity to air grievances and make demands,” Oliver noted.Duffy blamed “old, legacy equipment that failed” and asked for $50bn from Congress to upgrade the system. “I can’t build things if i don’t have money,” Duffy said. “I want $50bn. President Trump is a builder. He is going to build this network for the American people.”“What are you doing going on TV to demand $50bn?” Oliver mocked. “You sound less like a secretary of transportation trying to calm people down and more like a Batman villain trying to hold Gotham hostage: ‘I need $50bn unless the Batman can solve my riddles in time!’”Duffy, said Oliver, was right about one thing: the US flight system is outdated. But as the host pointed out, Republicans have controlled both houses of Congress as well as the presidency for the past two years, making them responsible for any complaints about underfunding. And the Republican-led Congress, along with the Trump administration, collaborated to triple Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE)’s budget last year to $28bn, for a total that surpasses the annual budgets of almost all federal law enforcement agencies combined.“It is hard to take a panicked shakedown from Duffy,” said Oliver, “not just because his cost estimate jumped by $20bn mid-sentence, but also because he’s part of a flagrantly corrupt administration who spent a chunk of his time in office shooting a shitty reality show with his family to encourage Americans to take more road trips.” (Duffy, his wife and their nine kids shot The Great American Road Trip over seven months from 2025 to 2026.)“To that end,” said Oliver in reference to reports of stranded travelers renting cars last minute, “guess what, Sean? Mission fucking accomplished!”In his main segment, Oliver tracked the rise and fall of “Alligator Alcatraz”, the prison opened last year in the Florida Everglades by the state’s then governor, Ron DeSantis, to curry favor with immigration hardliners like Trump.“You might understandably have forgotten about Alligator Alcatraz given, you know, everything else,” said Oliver. “And this is the rare story where I’m actually going to tell you up front how it ends, and an even rarer one, given that it’s actually good news.” Because back in June, the Florida governor, Ron DeSantis, announced that the prison was closing down immediately. “And that is a genuinely good thing,” said Oliver. “Which is almost hard to absorb, isn’t it? The last few years, whenever you hear something was shut down, you naturally assume it’s an important clinical trial, or critical repairs at national parks, or maybe a beloved celebrity’s heart, not actually something you want to see end.”But though it’s now closed, Oliver argued that the erstwhile prison is still worth talking about. “For one thing, Alligator Alcatraz is a pretty good encapsulation of the performative cruelty of Trump’s second term,” he said. “But also, one of the key men behind it, Ron DeSantis, is now being floated as a possible replacement for Pete Hegseth, and there’s even rumors that he’s planning another White House run.”“And I am sure that DeSantis, like many of those who were behind Alligator Alcatraz, would like nothing more than for people to forget about it and move on. But … that should not happen.”The host then retraced the prison’s “incredibly stupid origins” as a “mashup of two different ill-thought-through ideas that Trump floated”. One was his first-term interest in a border wall with a water-filled trench stocked with snakes and/or alligators. Another was his proposal to reopen Alcatraz, the infamous island prison located within the San Francisco Bay. Florida attorney general James Uthmeier, one of many “mid-tier villains in Trump’s orbit”, appears to have smushed together the two slapdash ideas into a proposal pitched via social media, claiming such a prison would be “efficient and low cost” because one doesn’t have to invest too much in a “perimeter”.Trump’s team loved the idea, and the facility was assembled in under eight days – “slower than God, sure, but a lot faster than most high-intensity builds”, Oliver noted. To do so, the Florida state government relied on no-bid emergency contracts, including $219m to a portable restrooms company called Doodie Calls. In all, Alligator Alcatraz cost more than $1bn to construct, by using funds set aside for hurricanes, floods and other natural disasters because DeSantis declared US immigration in Florida to be a “state of emergency”. The vast majority of people incarcerated there, it should be noted, were neither convicted of a violent crime nor on a “final removal” order.Perhaps unsurprisingly for a swamp prison, conditions were reportedly terrible – cramped and unsanitary, with open toilets, rotten food and literal cages branded as “calming areas” for men to “reflect on their behavior choices, manage their emotions, reduce stress and practice self-directed behavior”.“That’s just straight-up torture,” Oliver corrected.Though one would think inhumane practices would close the prison, what actually shut Alligator Alcatraz down “wasn’t everyone suddenly having an attack of conscience”, said Oliver: “Instead, it seems to have been a very stupid oversight on Ron DeSantis’s part.” The governor had said that the costs of the prison would be fully reimbursed by the federal government, but the federal government legally had to declare it a state project, sticking Florida with all of the costs.The passing of the buck is one of many, many reasons, Oliver argued, states should not be allowed to run immigration detention facilities, full stop. “I’d actually argue that we shouldn’t be running immigration detention facilities in general, but that is a different story that we have already done,” he added.Even though Alligator Alcatraz is no more, “we should remember the utter disgrace that it was”, he concluded. Ultimately, Alligator Alcatraz was “a shoddy, shameless attempt to gain political points with public cruelty”.

Original Source

Read the full article at Theguardian →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.