Jared Padalecki Reveals Why He Thinks ‘Gilmore Girls’ Made Dean So Unlikable [Exclusive]

Jared Padalecki Reveals Why He Thinks ‘Gilmore Girls’ Made Dean So Unlikable [Exclusive]

Image via The CW/ Warner Bros. Television Ent Published Nov 18, 2026, 12:15 PM EST Kendall Myers is a Senior Author with Collider. As part of the TV and Movies Features team, she writes about some of the most popular releases before, during, and after they premiere. In three years, she has written over 900 articles with topics ranging from classic sitcoms to fantasy epics. Sign in to your Collider account Even nearly 20 years after the series ended, every Gilmore Girls fan has their own opinion about Rory's (Alexis Bledel) boyfriends. Dean (Jared Padalecki), Jess (Milo Ventimiglia), and Logan (Matt Czuchry) all have iconic moments, but none is perfect, which is why the debate gets so heated. Yet, any fan, regardless of their favorite, must admit that Rory's first love, Dean, changed dramatically throughout the series. Introduced in the first episode, Dean is friendly, easygoing, and understanding, but as the series goes on, he exhibits more and more red flags, culminating in the infamous storyline where he cheats on his wife to sleep with Rory. By the end, he becomes fairly unlikable, and Padalecki has his own theory on why. Gilmore Girls was an early role for Padalecki, who is now known for other projects, including Supernatural and Walker. Yet, his time as Dean Forester is far from forgotten. Reflecting on his role in Gilmore Girls during his Collider profile interview with Tania Hussain, the actor doesn't deny that Dean became problematic in later episodes, but he offers an unofficial explanation. Though Gilmore Girls' creator Amy Sherman-Palladino has never given an official reason, Padalecki suggests that his own availability is to blame for Dean's change. Though his reasoning doesn't erase any plot holes the transformation might create, it makes sense from a production perspective. Dean's Role on 'Gilmore Girls' Changed Over Time Initially, Dean plays an important role in Gilmore Girls and is seemingly perfect for Rory. He likes to read, gets to know Lorelai (Lauren Graham), and even braves the debutante ball, but as the series goes on, Dean grows less likable. His relationship with Rory faces competition in Season 2, when Jess moves to Star's Hollow, and Dean grows jealous and controlling, and that is only the beginning of his downfall. The show soon brings out the worst in Dean as he marries Lindsay (Arielle Kebbel) despite pining after Rory the night before his wedding. Worse, in the Season 4 finale, he has an affair with Rory, marking a low point for both characters. Padalecki addresses this moment in particular, saying, "As far as indefensible, I'm not a huge fan of the idea of sleeping with Rory when you're married. I don't think that was ideal. He had his moments." As beloved as Dean was in the early seasons, that's hard to come back from. Collider Exclusive · 8 Questions · 2 Minutes Which Iconic Romance Is Your Favorite? Harry & Sally · Love & Basketball · Heated Rivalry · Titanic Four great love stories, and four completely different ideas of what love actually is. One is a friendship that took twelve years to admit itself. One is two people who refuse to stop competing. One happens entirely behind closed doors. And one lasts five days and never stops mattering. Eight questions decide which one is really yours. 🍂Harry & Sally(1989) 🏀Love & Basketball(2000) 🏒Heated Rivalry(HBO Max) 🚢Titanic(1997) FIND YOUR ROMANCE → 01 How does your love story start? The first scene tells you what kind of story this is going to be. AWe are friends for years before either of us says anything. BWe want the same thing and neither of us backs down. CNobody can know, including our closest friends. DOne look across a room and everything changes. NEXT QUESTION → 02 What do the two of you keep arguing about? Every great romance has one fight it has over and over. AWhether this is actually happening, and what to call it. BWhose career comes first this year. CWhether we will ever be honest about this in public. DNothing small. When we fight, it is about everything. NEXT QUESTION → 03 How do you show somebody that you love them? Grand gestures are easy to write. This is the harder question. AI remember every single thing they have told me. BI show up to the things that matter to them. CI keep their secrets like they are my own. DI would give up something enormous for them. NEXT QUESTION → 04 What is actually standing in the way? There is always something. Which something tells you the genre. ATiming. We keep finding each other at the wrong moment. BAmbition. We both want big lives and they do not match. CThe world. It is not safe to be open about this yet. DEverybody around us has decided this cannot happen. NEXT QUESTION → 05 Which romantic moment gets you every single time? Be honest. There is one that works on you and you know which. ASomebody running across a city to say it before midnight. BSomebody in the stands who stayed until the very end. CA look across a crowded room that nobody else catches. DSomebody promising to hold on, and meaning it. NEXT QUESTION → 06 What would you actually risk for the right person? Every romance asks this. Most people find out far too late. AA friendship I could never get back. BThe plan I have had for my life since I was a kid. CMy privacy. All of it would become public. DEverything. I would not think about it for long. NEXT QUESTION → 07 Where are the two of you in ten years? Some love stories are about the meeting. Some are about the staying. AStill talking. We have never run out of things to say. BBuilding something together, both of us still ambitious. CFinally open about it, after years of being careful. DApart, and I still think about it constantly. NEXT QUESTION → 08 Which of these sounds most like something you would say? Eight questions in, this is the one that decides your romance. AI would rather talk to you than anybody else, forever. BI am not giving up either of us. We find a way to have both. CThis is mine, and I am not explaining it to anyone. DI would do the whole thing again, even knowing how it ends. REVEAL MY ROMANCE → Roll The Credits Your Romance Is…Four love stories, four completely different ideas of what it means to be somebody's person. This is the one that matches how you actually fall, and what it would ask of you. Harry & SallyYou do not fall for strangers. You fall for the person you have already been talking to for years, which is the slowest and by some distance the most durable way anybody has found to do this. When Harry Met Sally made the case that the best romance is an argument you enjoy, conducted over a decade, by two people refusing to admit what is happening. You want to be known rather than swept away. Somebody who remembers your worst story is doing better work than anybody arriving with flowers. The film is unusually honest about timing. These two are wrong for each other repeatedly until suddenly they are not, and neither of them engineered it. You would still be talking about everything at eighty. That is the entire promise. Love & BasketballYou want a partner, not an audience. Somebody who wants their own life as badly as you want yours, and who would never ask you to be smaller to make the relationship easier. This is the rare romance where both people have a real career and the film takes both of them equally seriously. You would rather be pushed than protected. The right person for you is also a bit of a rival, and that never entirely goes away. It understands the actual problem in ambitious relationships. Not whether you love each other, but whose turn it is this year. You would still be competing at forty. That is how you would know it was working. Heated RivalryThe intensity was never the problem. The secrecy is. You are drawn to a love that lives entirely in private, and to the particular ache of wanting somebody you are not supposed to want. Heated Rivalry runs on the oldest engine in romance: two people on opposite sides, meeting in secret, getting far more attached than either of them planned. You keep your private life genuinely private, and something in you finds hidden things more real than public ones. The tension is not only between the two of them. It is between what they have and what it would cost either one to say it out loud. Years of this, and the whole story is really about whether either of them will finally stop hiding. TitanicYou do not do this cautiously. When it happens for you it is immediate and total and it rearranges everything, and you would not accept a smaller version of it. Titanic gave us the biggest romance in film history and then made it last about five days, which is precisely the point of it. You measure love by intensity rather than duration. A few days of the real thing beats decades of something merely comfortable. The film is not only about the romance. It is about a woman who went on to live an enormous life afterwards because of it. You would still be telling this story at a hundred years old, and telling it exactly the same way. ↻ RETAKE THE QUIZ Though he appears throughout Season 5, as Dean dates Rory again, their relationship doesn't last long. After all, it's hard to redeem Dean after everything, and the audience instead becomes invested in Rory and Logan, allowing Dean to be naturally written off. In many ways, the goodbye goes unnoticed, but Padalecki believes there was more to it than the story's progression. Jared Padalecki Believes 'Gilmore Girls' Wanted to Make Dean Less Likable Though it is a dramatic change for the character, Padalecki understands why the series chose that direction for Dean, saying, "I think part of the reason why Dean kind of veered off was because [I] wasn't on a multi-year contract. So if the audience and Rory fell head-over-heels in love with Dean, and then I got Supernatural, all of a sudden, Dean's not around anymore; he's in Vancouver. He's named Sam now." Gimore Girls wasn't in a rush to write Dean off, but it's reasonable that Padalecki would choose a more substantial role over returning as Dean, so the series had to prepare an exit strategy. As Padalecki puts it, "they had to cover their asses, so to speak, and go, like, 'Let's make him questionable.'" This leads to Dean changing dramatically, but it also enables the series to tell a variety of stories about his character. If Padalecki's suspicions are right, the precaution worked in the show's favor. Gilmore Girls eventually wrote Dean off after Season 5, just a few months before Supernatural premiered, and it works because most fans weren't too sad to see him go. Padalecki's explanation is logical, but unconfirmed, and the actor himself admits, "I haven't talked to Amy [Sherman-Palladino] about it." Yet, it wouldn't have been hard for Sherman-Palladino to see the writing on the wall. Padalecki even admits, "Like even Season 5 of Gilmore Girls, I did Flight of the Phoenix and Cry Wolf and House of Wax, and so I wasn't there. I wasn't in L.A. to do it at all." Given his increasingly busy schedule, it makes sense that Gilmore Girls needed to plan a story without Dean. Over the years, Padalecki has developed a new perspective on the industry, working behind the camera as well as on it. The actor explains, "Knowing what I know now about multi-year shows and different contracts as a producer and whatnot, I think part of it was like, 'Shoot, if Jared goes…'" If Padalecki is right, his slow transition was a clever way to write him off without fully committing. Dean disappeared, allowing Padalecki to pursue different projects, but it left an easy opening for later, like his return in Gilmore Girls: A Year in the Life. Jared Padalecki Roots Against His 'Gilmore Girls' Character Image via The WB Despite the way things turn out, Dean will always be a beloved part of the long-lasting series, and many Gilmore Girls fans still consider Dean the best of Rory's boyfriends. Yet Jared Padalecki himself isn't among them. Padalecki's choice isn't about the controversial moments his character had later in the series, but because of his friendship with Milo Ventimiglia. Given the animosity between their characters, it's ironic that Padalecki is "Team Jess," but it shows the behind-the-scenes dynamic and adds a hilarious layer to the ongoing debate about Rory's boyfriends. Ultimately, Gilmore Girls makes it clear that Dean wasn't right for Rory, but he leaves an impression on fans as they continue to talk about the character after so many years. Padalecki's thoughts offer an interesting perspective on Dean's character arc for fans to consider as they return to the series year after year. More to the point, this is the perfect time to think about these things as the series gets both an official documentary and the recently released Drink Coffee, Talk Fast. Jared Padalecki has built an impressive career, but many fans will always remember him first as Gilmore Girls' Dean, and despite the character's later storylines, that isn't a bad thing. Gilmore Girls is streaming on Prime Video and Hulu in the U.S. Release Date 2000 - 2007-00-00 Network The WB, The CW Directors Jamie Babbit, Amy Sherman-Palladino, Lee Shallat Chemel, Kenny Ortega, Michael Katleman, Matthew Diamond, Michael Zinberg, Gail Mancuso, Lesli Linka Glatter, Steve Clancy, Bethany Rooney, Jackson Douglas, Robert Berlinger, Steven Robman, Alan Myerson, Lev L. Spiro, Rodman Flender, Adam Nimoy, Arlene Sanford, Bruce Seth Green, Danny Leiner, David Paymer, David Petrarca, Eric Laneuville Writers Rebecca Rand Kirshner, David S. Rosenthal, Sheila R. Lawrence, Jennie Snyder Urman, Joan Binder Weiss, David Babcock, Bill Prady, Gayle Abrams, Gina Fattore, Jane Espenson, Jenji Kohan, Keith Eisner, James Berg, Stan Zimmerman, Allan Heinberg, Jed Seidel, Jessica Queller, Lisa Randolph, David Grae, Rina Mimoun, Jordon Nardino, Scott Kaufer, Joanne Waters Creator(s) Amy Sherman-Palladino

Original Source

Read the full article at Collider →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.