Jaguar Land Rover's HR boss has £4million discrimination case struck out after 'adversarial' questioning leaves him too ill to continue

Jaguar Land Rover's HR boss has £4million discrimination case struck out after 'adversarial' questioning leaves him too ill to continue

An HR director at Jaguar Land Rover brought a £4million discrimination case – only to have it struck out after the 'adversarial' style of questioning left him too ill to continue.James Baker issued a wide array of claims, including disability discrimination, against the British car manufacturer, alleging he was the victim of 'bullying and harassment'.But after his first day of cross-examination in June the case had to be adjourned when Mr Baker's blood pressure spiked, with his GP and psychiatrist being consulted.A judgment detailed how the latter believed Mr Baker was 'suffering from intense anxiety and that the adversarial approach in the hearing had triggered an injection of adrenalin which produced a spike in blood pressure'.It added the psychiatrist 'wrote that "this style of questioning" triggered intense symptoms of PTSD'.The psychiatrist suggested Mr Baker could be provided in advance with a list of topics that JLR wished to cross-examine him on to help mitigate these symptoms.But when the hearing resumed in September, the judgment outlined how the HR director 'failed/refused to use the (medically recommended) adjustment made for him'.After another day of cross-examination, Mr Baker's blood pressure spiked again - this time to a degree that required hospital treatment. Birmingham Employment Tribunal heard the 'adversarial approach' had caused James Baker's blood pressure to spike He had been head of HR, Overseas, for the car manufacturer before the dispute took placeThe tribunal had already agreed that Mr Baker – who had been head of HR, overseas, for JLR – could take a break for ten minutes every half hour while giving evidence.But the medical evidence before the tribunal suggested a 'chicken and egg' scenario where Mr Baker 'would not recover his mental health until the dispute with his employer had been resolved'.JLR submitted that Mr Baker's medical situation by September was 'demonstrably worse than it had been' in June and any further adjournment breached its right to a fair trial 'due to loss of cogency of evidence'.But Mr Baker's lawyer submitted that JLR could now be asked to provide a list of written questions, and floated the possibility of his client being allowed to reply in writing.A judge concluded, however, that requiring JLR 'to provide its cross-examination questions in advance to [Mr Baker] was a fundamental interference with [JLR's] right to a fair trial and was unreasonable and disproportionate'.Employment Judge Hilary Harding granted JLR's application for a strike out part-way through the tribunal because 'a fair trial was no longer possible'.Mr Baker had demanded 'compensation in excess of £4million' at Birmingham Employment Tribunal.He lodged claims of direct disability discrimination, discrimination arising from disability, a failure to make reasonable adjustments, harassment related to disability, whistleblowing detriment, victimisation, automatically unfair dismissal, ordinary unfair dismissal and breach of contract.Mr Baker claimed to suffer from chronic pain, PTSD, anxiety and depression but this was contested by the car manufacturer.His claims 'referred to a history of bullying and harassment, including events which led to Mr Baker's hospitalisation on September 5, 2018, October 21, 2018, and April 23, 2019'.He alleged 'unlawful, unfair and detrimental treatment' which were the main causes of sickness absence and mental ill-health.The tribunal heard that, in January 2021, Mr Baker described a failure by JLR 'to make reasonable adjustments' following an occupational health report. 'Furthermore, he states how working a 14-hour day caused a herniated disc in his back during the Covid pandemic,' a tribunal judgment states. 'On July 29, 2022, [Mr Baker] reported that [a colleague] telephoned him when he was on holiday and this caused [him] to have a panic attack.'In 2023, he reported the 'behaviour of a work colleague undermining him in his role' had also caused months of 'considerable stress'.The tribunal heard Mr Baker went on sick leave in September 2023 and 'did not return before he resigned' in May 2025.The triggers for Mr Baker's 'anxiety/PTSD' were twofold: being exposed to a situation which reminded him of alleged 'index incidents' - the starting point of an issue - at work, and 'the tribunal process as a whole but in particular the style of questioning'.The judgment said: 'Whilst [the psychiatrist] accepted that, objectively, there was a difference between hostile treatment and adversarial questioning, [Mr Baker] perceives adversarial questioning as hostile.'EJ Harding said: 'Ultimately, we reached an agreed position that, as a result of the amount of time already lost, taken together with the amount of time that would be needed to deal with the application and cross applications, it was no longer possible to conduct a fair trial in the amount of time we had available within this trial fixture.'

Original Source

Read the full article at Dailymail →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.