It Will Take New Yorkers Even Longer to Break Even Buying an Apartment In Brooklyn Heights, rental prices are so high, it may make more sense to buy. Photo: Alexander Spatari/Getty Images Rent-or-buy calculators often seem a little bogus, assuming as they do that there’s money for a down payment, the ability to get a mortgage, and enough reasonably priced inventory to even consider moving out of your current place. Then there’s the reality of what making a sound financial decision means; it might be smart on paper to give up your charming two-bedroom rental in Fort Greene to buy a smaller, generic postwar co-op in Clinton Hill. That doesn’t mean you want to. But for all their faults, the calculators do illuminate certain market realities. A new report from StreetEasy on the New York neighborhoods where buyers can break even fastest underscores that the choice between renting and buying has gotten murkier; it now takes a buyer purchasing a median-priced apartment of $900,000 nearly 15 years to pull ahead of a renter, or two more years than in 2025. There are simply not enough apartments to go around, driving up the rents and sales prices for those that do come on the market. In October, 21 percent of New York City homes sold above asking — up from 18.9 percent the year before — and spent a median of only 48 days on the market. Rental inventory, meanwhile, fell 15.2 percent in the last year, and rents are up: In Manhattan, the median asking rent rose 8.6 percent. And it’s not as though rents were affordable before: This spring, median rents in the city hit an all-time high of $4,120 a month. There are some surprises, however: In a few tony neighborhoods, the rental prices are so high that buying is now the better option. In most places, buying only makes sense if you plan to live somewhere at least ten years — time for the home’s price to appreciate enough to make a profit after closing costs and brokers’ fees. In Brooklyn Heights, the median sales price in October was $870,000, while the annual asking rent was $5,150 — meaning that a buyer would break even in just 6.8 years. This may not hold true for larger apartments — $5,150 will get you a one-, maybe a two-bedroom in Brooklyn Heights. But it’s a market quirk of a neighborhood with a dwindling number of rentals due to so many single-family conversions. Gramercy Park is a similar story: The median sales price is $962,000, and the median rental is $5,500, so buyers would break even in 7.2 years. (this is not to say the neighborhood is affordable, exactly; its median sales price is pretty high compared to the others on the break-even list). The other neighborhoods where it’s a good deal to buy are more expected: Rego Park and Oakland Gardens in Queens and Riverdale in the Bronx, with a median sales price of $400,000 and a relatively high rental median of $3,275 a month bringing the break-even time down to 3.9 years. New York is an unusual market for both buying and renting, however. Nearly three-quarters of New Yorkers are renters, and rentals span the market from dumpy basement apartments to ultraluxurious penthouses. In most of the country, rentals are often less-than, but New York is one of the few cities where people — and quite a lot of them — choose to blow $30,000 a month on rent. It Will Take New Yorkers 15 Years to Break Even Buying Your product is saved! You’ll receive emails when your saved products go on sale. Manage preferences.
It Will Take New Yorkers Even Longer to Break Even Buying an Apartment
Full Article
Original Source
Read the full article at Curbed →KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.