Claim: A video that circulated in November is authentic footage of a massive wave crashing upon a full container ship and flooding it to the point of crashing against the wheelhouse's window. Rating: Recently, social media has been inundated with videos apparently depicting "rogue" or "freak" waves — unpredictable waves greater than twice the size of surrounding waves, according to NOAA — crashing over massive container ships. In November, a YouTube video (archived) of a massive wave rushing atop the containers and whiting out the wheelhouse's window of one such ship was viewed 32 million times in the first week since its upload. While the video was most popular on YouTube, it was also shared to other social media sites such as X (archived) and Reddit (archived). Although many people in comment sections reacted to the video as if it was real footage of a rogue wave striking a container ship, this video was actually generated by artificial intelligence tools. Therefore, we've rated the video fake. To start, we did a reverse image search of frames from the video with Google Lens. We could not find a credible source for the video through the search. Based on the search, the YouTube video linked and embedded above is the earliest upload of the video. The YouTube video was posted by the "UNIQUE SARANG" YouTube channel. Snopes reached out to the channel's creator by email to confirm it was the original source of the clip and will update this fact check if and when we receive a reply. The channel's short videos appear to be mostly or entirely AI-generated videos of impossible or dramatic events. For example, one video depicts a giant dragonfly far larger than any living species on Earth. When the dragonfly suddenly flies up and away from the camera, which is several feet away from the fisherman on the pier, the fisherman reacts as if the dragonfly just buzzed by his own ear. Such an inconsistency is evident of AI generation. Another video shows the moon cracking into two pieces. That video has YouTube's "Made by AI" label. On Nov. 9, two days after the upload of the widely viewed video of the wave crashing over the container ship, the channel posted three short videos depicting massive waves impacting ships. The first two were of a wave crashing into small craft, such as a sailboat, and in neither video is there any reaction from the people on the ship or from the people recording the footage. In the last of those three videos, the container ship seems remarkably unscathed despite the size of the wave. Similarly, there are no reactions from any people in that one, as well. Evidence of AI generation within the video Evidence within the contents of the container ship video viewed over 30 million times indicates that it was generated by AI. The two most obvious pieces of evidence can be spotted by watching the mug in the foreground and looking at the containers closest to the camera. At about 16 seconds into the video, the mug falls over to its side and then immediately rights itself just before the wave actually hits. Additionally, throughout the video the two blue containers in the bottom right appear to be off the side of the ship, based on what we can see of the ship and the rest of the containers in the rest of the video. A third giveaway to the video's AI origins is that the ship appears to be completely still, without any real interaction with the waves before the massive one. While it appears the ship could be riding up a significant wave at the very beginning of the video, there's no evidence of the ship impacting the water in any way when it appears like it should land back down after the wave. The water also appears to have a trough just before the massive wave hits, although the ship never seems to point down towards it. Finally, the wave and it's interaction with the ship do not appear to be realistic at all based on what small amount of footage we have of real rogue waves caught on video. Real and fake rogue wave footage Massive, ship-wrecking "freak" waves have had a mystique to them for much of human history. They were once regarded as "marine folklore" from sailors to explain shipwrecks, but have been recognized by scientists as real in the past few decades. One clip of a rogue wave caught on cameras for the Discovery show "Deadliest Catch," a reality show that follows fishermen off the Alaska coast, showed the vessel Aleutian Ballad rocking between its left and right on stormy seas. At 0:51, the rogue wave, which hits the boat from the side, crashes suddenly into the fishing vessel life a wall rather than falling upon it like a wave breaking near the shore. A clip of a rogue wave hitting the crab-fishing boat Saga similarly shows the wave crashing into the boat like a suddenly appearing wall rather than a wave that breaks and falls on top of it. Another clip of the Saga from "Deadliest Catch," this time with a different captain piloting the boat, shows two rogue waves rushing against and into the boat back-to-back. While the first wave crashes against the boat like the others, the second wave pours into it. Neither wave falls upon the boat from above like the wave does in the AI-generated video. Similarly, yet another "Deadliest Catch" clip depicts a massive wave simply pouring over the boat's side. The clip most similar to the AI-generated version of a rogue wave was not from "Deadliest Catch," but instead was a video of a New Zealand Navy ship in the Southern Ocean. That video has been promoted by the New Zealand Defence Force, which identified the ship as the HMNZS Otago and was uploaded in 2021, before generative AI video was of the quality it is now. While the wave that crashes into the ship does break just before colliding with the boat, the initial splash came from the warship landing upon the water after crossing the peak of the previous wave, which is something the AI-generated container ship did not do. In all of the videos, a noticeable amount of water remained on the boat in the aftermath. In the real clips, objects on the boats were at minimum disturbed and dislodged, and in some cases the waves swept them entirely off the sides of the ships. The wave in the Navy ship video even disturbs the gun on the boat so that it points higher up after the wave. However, in the AI-generated video, none of the containers appear so much as jostled slightly out of place after the wave crashes into them and the ship as a whole. The video with over 32 million views is far from the only AI-generated video of a rogue wave hitting a container ship. One video from Instagram shows a massive wave failing to so much as nudge cargo containers, even though a few of them are already partially tipped over. A TikTok video of a cargo ship riding a giant wave like it's surfing is labeled by its creator as being made with AI. For further reading, Snopes has previously fact-checked other AI-generated imagery involving the ocean, including this fake clip of an Amazon delivery robot driving itself off of a pier.
Is video of massive wave hitting container ship real?
Full Article
Original Source
Read the full article at Snopes →KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.