Representative Image (AI-generated)An Indiana man who bought a condominium hoping to move in with his daughter has lost an appeal over unpaid homeowners' association fees, after a court upheld a judgment against him and remanded the case for the determination of the association's reasonable appellate attorneys' fees. Onnie James Florence Jr. purchased a unit at Meridian Arch Condominiums in 2020 but continued living in Illinois because he was unable to move into the property. After he fell behind on monthly assessments, the homeowners' association obtained a $9,213.50 default judgment against him in 2021. Florence later paid $9,489, but the association pursued additional unpaid assessments, late fees and legal expenses. In a November 19, 2026 memorandum decision, available on Justia, the Indiana Court of Appeals affirmed the subsequent summary judgment in favour of the association and sent the case back to the trial court to determine its appellate attorneys' fees.Condo purchase led to unpaid association assessmentsFlorence bought the condominium at Meridian Arch Condominiums in 2020, intending to live there with his daughter. However, he was unable to make the move and continued residing at his home in Illinois. Although he did not occupy the Indiana property, Florence remained responsible for paying its monthly homeowners' association assessments. Under the association's rules, unpaid assessments could become a lien against the condominium and eventually lead to foreclosure.By May 2021, Florence owed $5,229.80 in unpaid assessments. The Meridian Arch Owners Association filed a lawsuit seeking to foreclose on its lien. The association initially attempted to serve Florence personally but was unsuccessful. It then sent the summons and complaint by certified mail to his Illinois residence. His wife signed for the documents on June 15, 2021.Florence did not respond to the lawsuit or appear in court. The association subsequently requested a default judgment, submitting an affidavit showing that he owed $9,213.50 as of September 14, 2021. The amount included unpaid assessments, late fees, collection costs and attorneys' fees. The trial court granted the request on September 28, 2021.Florence challenged the judgment and paid $9,489After the association began proceedings to sell the condominium through a sheriff's sale, Florence appeared in the case and asked the court to set aside the default judgment. He argued that he had not received the necessary court filings and that the association had filed its foreclosure complaint prematurely. He also sought dismissal of the case, arguing that the association had failed to notify CrossCountry Mortgage, the holder of the property's first mortgage, before initiating the proceedings. The trial court rejected both requests in January 2024.In April 2024, a foreclosure decree was sent to the sheriff for the sale of the condominium. However, the sale was cancelled after Florence paid the association $9,489. The association treated the payment as a partial satisfaction of the existing judgment because post-judgment interest had accumulated. It later informed the court that Florence still owed $1,922.84 on the original judgment's principal portion because of accrued interest. The association also sought to recover additional assessments, late fees, costs and attorneys' fees that had accumulated after the original judgment.Association pursued additional unpaid feesIn November 2024, the association obtained permission to set aside the original default judgment and amend its complaint to include the additional amounts that had accrued since the initial case was filed. Its amended complaint sought recovery of the outstanding assessments and related expenses. CrossCountry Mortgage was also joined as a party.In September 2025, the association requested summary judgment, submitting evidence that Florence owed $26,813.22 in unpaid assessments, late fees, costs and attorneys' fees. Its affidavit specifically recorded that his $9,489 payment had been credited to his account on August 20, 2024. Florence received two extensions to respond to the summary-judgment request but did not file a response. The trial court granted the association's motion on February 3, 2026.Florence subsequently challenged the decision, arguing that the association had failed to account properly for his payment and that he should have received a detailed accounting of how the money was applied.Appeals court upholds judgment and orders determination of legal feesThe Indiana Court of Appeals examined Florence's arguments and found no basis to overturn the trial court's decision. The judges noted that Florence's wife had signed for the original complaint and summons sent to his Illinois residence, satisfying the state's service requirements. They also found that his challenge to the denial of his request to set aside the original default judgment had been filed too late for appellate review.Regarding the $9,489 payment, the court pointed to the association's affidavit, which explicitly confirmed that the amount had been credited to Florence's account. He had not submitted evidence contradicting that record or showing that the payment had been omitted from the calculations. The court also rejected his argument that the association had failed to include the mortgage lender, noting that CrossCountry had subsequently been added to the amended proceedings.In its November 19, 2026 decision, the appeals court affirmed the summary judgment in favour of the Meridian Arch Owners Association and remanded the case to the trial court to determine reasonable appellate attorneys' fees owed to the association. The decision was issued as a memorandum decision under Indiana Appellate Rule 65(D), meaning it is not binding precedent for other courts and may be cited only for persuasive purposes or certain limited legal proceedings. Florence's $9,489 payment therefore did not eliminate his outstanding obligations. The association's judgment remained in place, with the additional appellate legal fees still to be determined.
Indiana condo buyer pays $9,489 in HOA dues, court says he still owes more
Full Article
Original Source
Read the full article at Timesofindia →KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.