India rebuked by UN discrimination watchdog

Caste remains a powerful determinant of social status in India, shaping access to resources, education and opportunity.(AFP) — India must better protect tribal peoples and disadvantaged castes from extrajudicial killings, torture and violence by law enforcement, a United Nations watchdog said Tuesday.The U.N. Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination also said the world’s most populous country urgently needs to address hate crimes against Bengali-speaking Muslims.“The committee was gravely concerned about reports of large-scale violations perpetrated by law enforcement officials against ethnic and ethno-religious groups, Indigenous and Tribal Peoples, including Scheduled Tribes, Scheduled Castes, particularly Dalits, and non-citizens,” it said in a statement on its findings.“These included racially motivated violence, excessive use of force, extrajudicial killings, arbitrary and prolonged detention without due process, torture, ill-treatment and sexual violence.”The committee called on India to investigate all such allegations and bring those responsible to justice.The committee’s opinions and recommendations are nonbinding but carry reputational weight.Caste remains a powerful determinant of social status in India, shaping access to resources, education and opportunity.The millennia-old social hierarchy divides Hindus by function and social standing.“For Dalits, it’s important to have indicators showing that segregation was effectively and substantively reduced,” based on the committee’s previous observations, committee member Stamatia Stavrinaki said.The committee, made up of 18 independent human rights experts, monitors adherence to the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination by its 182 member countries.Under the convention, which took effect in 1969, countries must eliminate racial discrimination, eradicate practices of segregation and guarantee equality before the law.Rohingya and asylum-seekersIndia appeared for review before the committee earlier this month for the first time since 2007, with Solicitor General Tushar Mehta leading its delegation.The committee highlighted an increase in law enforcement operations targeting Rohingya, Bengali-speaking Muslims, migrants and asylum-seekers.It said police stops and identity checks involving racial profiling had reportedly resulted in arbitrary arrests and detention without due process, as well as torture and mistreatment.The committee also voiced concern about deportations and forced returns of people needing international protection.It urged India to “urgently address discrimination, hate speech and hate crimes” against such groups, protect their rights and refrain from collective expulsions.Stavrinaki told a news conference that the perceived lack of accountability was important because if a law exists but is not implemented, “hate crimes cannot be effectively combated.”Another major gap for India is that “racial discrimination in the private sphere is not clearly prohibited by law,” she added.During the dialogue, India insisted that it respects human rights defenders, Stavrinaki said.However, “in practice, threats, hate crimes, hate speech and the negative environment faced by human rights defenders are not fully prevented or addressed,” she said.Following the review, India’s mission said in a statement that its delegation had “highlighted our pluralism; diversity; scale and complexity; constitutional and legal framework and safeguards … as we continue our journey towards ensuring equality, dignity and opportunity for all Indians.”Categories / InternationalSubscribe to our free newslettersOur weekly newsletter Closing Arguments offers the latest about ongoing trials, major litigation and rulings in courthouses around the U.S. and the world, while the monthly Under the Lights dishes the legal dirt from Hollywood, sports, Big Tech and the arts.Additional Reads