Opposition parties have moved the Supreme Court seeking permission to formally question the Election Commission of India (ECI) during the hearing of petitions challenging the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls. In an application filed on Monday, they alleged that the poll body, in its response to the ongoing proceedings, has made assertions instead of placing relevant facts and supporting documents before the court.The application argued that the interrogation is necessary to obtain detailed answers, backed by official records, on various aspects of the SIR exercise. It maintained that the information and documents sought are exclusively available with the Election Commission and that the questions are intended to verify the poll body's own claims, rather than initiate a fishing enquiry.The INDIA bloc petitioners submitted 48 questions to the Supreme Court, seeking answers from Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar, his fellow commissioners Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi, along with other officials, including Deputy Election Commissioner Bhanu Prakash Yeturu."Whether particular decisions were taken by the Commission acting as a body; when and in what manner they were taken; who authorised particular actions in the name of the Commission; and how ECINET has been designed, altered and operated. The Petitioners have no means of access to those facts except through the Respondents themselves," the petition argued, explaining the necessity of the move. One of the key questions concerns the decision to launch a nationwide SIR. It seeks clarity on the ECI's decision to conduct a nationwide SIR, the approval process and possible differences among Election Commission members. A recent report about such differences has triggered a massive uproar and led to nationwide protests by the INDIA bloc, which has now landed in a legal fight in the Supreme Court.On the nationwide SIR decision, the Opposition parties want the ECI to disclose when, how and through which official process it decided to conduct a Special Intensive Revision across the country. They have also questioned an apparent contradiction between the ECI's 2025 order announcing a nationwide SIR and a later RTI response, which stated that no information regarding such a decision was available with the Commission. "In respect of each of the SIR Orders, state the number of the file in which the decision of the Commission was taken, the date of the decision, whether it was taken at a meeting, upon circulation of a file or through electronic means, and the date on which each member signified approval," the petitioners asked.They also sought details of access to electoral roll databases, audit trails of voter additions and deletions, changes to Form 6, appeals against judicial officers' orders in West Bengal, and the number of voters excluded during the revision. The petitioners have also sought records of decisions and approvals, including those obtained through electronic communications.On the alleged differences within the Commission, the petitioners asked, "State the number of occasions, between 19.02.2025 and 26.10.2026, on which Dr. Sukhbir Singh Sandhu or Dr. Vivek Joshi recorded in writing an objection, dissent or reservation concerning any matter relating to the SIR, ECINET, Form 6 or the filing of appeals; and, for each such occasion, state its date, the file number and the subject matter.""State whether any decision relating to the SIR has been taken by majority under Section 18(2) of the 2023 Act; and, if so, state the particulars of each such decision and identify the dissenting member," it continued.The application argued that the Election Commission, as a constitutional authority entrusted with the superintendence, direction and control of the preparation of electoral rolls, ought to welcome the opportunity to place the true facts before the court.The petitioners have also raised questions about access to the electoral roll database and the auditability of changes made to voter records. They have sought details of officials and other entities authorised to add, delete, modify or restore entries in the database, including whether employees of private vendors or contractors have had privileged or write access.The interrogatories further seek details of ECINET's audit trails, including whether every alteration to electoral roll entries is recorded with the user account, date, time and corresponding order of the Electoral Registration Officer.The application also seeks explanations on the online Form 6 process, including the introduction of a declaration and the number of applications rejected or kept pending because of the non-submission of the declaration or mapping details.On West Bengal, the petitioners have sought details of appeals filed against orders of inclusion passed by judicial officers, including the number of appeals, the officials who authorised them and the criteria used to select cases for appeal.The application is part of the INDIA bloc’s broader legal challenge to the Election Commission and the SIR process. The Supreme Court has scheduled the bloc’s petitions for Tuesday. At the previous hearing on October 27, a three-judge bench headed by Chief Justice Surya Kant granted the petitioners 10 days to respond to the ECI’s counter-affidavit, in which the poll body maintained that all three major decisions concerning the SIR were taken unanimously.- Ends
INDIA bloc wants to quiz CEC in Supreme Court over SIR, submits 48 questions
Full Article
Original Source
Read the full article at Indiatoday →KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.