ICJ ruling on Rohingya genocide could strengthen South Africa's case against Israel

ICJ ruling on Rohingya genocide could strengthen South Africa's case against Israel

The International Court of Justice's landmark ruling that Myanmar committed genocide against the Rohingya could have far-reaching consequences for Israel, after judges rejected the argument that military operations against armed groups provided an adequate explanation for a campaign of mass killings, sexual violence and widespread destruction. The judgment, the first time the UN's highest court has found a state responsible for genocide, offers South Africa a potentially significant legal precedent in its case accusing Israel of committing genocide against Palestinians in Gaza, particularly over how judges assess genocidal intent when a state claims its military actions are driven by security objectives. In a 9-6 decision on Thursday, the ICJ found that Myanmar's security forces had committed genocide against the Rohingya population in northern Rakhine State during the military's 2017 operations. "The only reasonable inference that can explain Myanmar's actions is an intention to destroy a substantial part of the protected group, namely the Rohingya population in Northern Rakhine State," the court said. The judgment is particularly significant for South Africa's case, which hinges on establishing that Israel acted with the specific intention of destroying Palestinians, in whole or in part, as a national, ethnic, racial or religious group. New MEE newsletter: Jerusalem Dispatch Sign up to get the latest insights and analysis on Israel-Palestine, alongside Turkey Unpacked and other MEE newsletters Under the 1948 Genocide Convention, the commission of mass killings or other atrocities is not, by itself, sufficient to establish genocide. Prosecutors must also demonstrate the specific intent to destroy a protected group. Where that intention cannot be established through direct evidence, the ICJ has traditionally required it to be the only reasonable inference that can be drawn from a pattern of conduct. One of the most consequential aspects of Thursday's judgment concerned the relationship between military objectives and genocidal intent. Myanmar had argued that its operations were a legitimate response to attacks by Rohingya armed groups, maintaining that its forces were conducting counterinsurgency operations rather than seeking to destroy the Rohingya population. The court rejected that defence, finding that the scale and nature of the military's conduct could not be adequately explained by its stated security objectives. 'Israel has killed over 20,000 children, which is far more than the 2,000 killed by Myanmar' – Melanie O'Brien, ex-president of the International Association of Genocide Scholars Israel has repeatedly maintained that its military campaign in Gaza was directed against Hamas and other armed groups, rather than Palestinians as a people. However, the judgment provides South Africa with an important response to the argument that Israel's stated objective of defeating Hamas automatically rules out genocidal intent. "Myanmar argued that its goal was to fight terrorists, but the court held that all the evidence demonstrated genocidal intent. This is what Israel will argue, that it is fighting Hamas," Melanie O'Brien, the former president of the International Association of Genocide Scholars, told Middle East Eye following the judgment. "Also, a substantial part of the conduct that the court deemed to be genocidal was the killing of children. Israel has killed over 20,000 children, which is far more than the 2,000 killed by Myanmar." O'Brien also noted that the court has taken into account the long history of discrimination and persecution of the Rohingya and the destruction of their property as indicative of genocidal conduct, an aspect of the judgment that could be replicated in the Gaza judgment. "This conduct is also part of Israel's treatment of the Palestinians and its destruction of Gaza," she said. The ICJ could 'reach a similar conclusion' Nimer Sultany, a professor of law and a genocide expert, said the court's reference to historical aspects of the genocide were instructive for the Gaza case. "I find it particularly significant that the court recounted previous military campaigns starting at 1978 by the Myanmar military in its discussion of genocidal intent," he told MEE. "As is well known, Israel attacked Gaza several times since 2000." He expects similar disagreement among the judges, who were split nine to six regarding the determination of genocide and its attribution to Myanmar's state. In historic judgment, ICJ concludes that Myanmar committed genocide against Rohingya Muslims Read More » "We can expect similar disagreement among the judges in the case of Gaza, in a much more challenging political environment," said the London-based Palestinian scholar. "But as far as the court's reasoning is concerned, and its application of the law to the facts in Myanmar, it would seem very likely that it would reach a similar conclusion regarding Israel, given the scale of Israel's crimes in Gaza." The court has also relied extensively on reports by UN investigative mechanisms on Myanmar as sources of evidence, saying they are reliable sources of factual evidence in cases where access by the authorities is denied. The same might apply to the case of Israel, which has consistently barred UN investigators from access to investigate alleged atrocities both against Palestinians and Israelis. Yet, the UN's commission of inquiry has found that genocide was committed in Gaza, and that Palestinian children have been a direct target of the genocide and other crimes. It is highly likely the court will rely on these reports in its assessment of the Gaza case, and that accordingly he expects the court will find "more genocidal acts" in Gaza than it did against Myanmar. "In fact, given the findings of the UN Commission of Inquiry and the UN's Integrated Food Security Phase Classification regarding famine and starvation, it is likely that the ICJ will determine more acts of genocide than in the case of Myanmar," said Sultany. The court found Myanmar has committed three out of four genocidal acts included in the Gambia's submission: killing members of the group, causing serious bodily or mental harm, and imposing conditions intended to prevent births within the group. It did not, however, find that Myanmar committed the genocidal act of the imposition of conditions that are calculated to bring about the destruction of the group. Sultany said that particular act will be relevant and stronger in the Gaza case, due to the abundance of reports by UN bodies on the destructive conditions imposed on Palestinians since October 2023, including findings regarding famine, starvation and the blocking of humanitarian aid. The ICJ has issued multiple interim orders for Israel to prevent acts of genocide and refrain from genocidal acts, but UN bodies have concluded that Israel has continued with its campaign against Palestinians and has disregarded the court's legally binding orders.

Original Source

Read the full article at Middleeasteye →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.