I took an instant disliking to my new next-door neighbour... but I never imagined the horror that was to follow months later, writes GRAEME CULLIFORD

I took an instant disliking to my new next-door neighbour... but I never imagined the horror that was to follow months later, writes GRAEME CULLIFORD

I am not sure whether it was the flash of his perfect white teeth, his smarmy expression or his garish Hawaiian shirt, but I took an instant disliking to my new next-door neighbour, Skip.Ernest Scherer III, to give him his full name, was a professional gambler with a limp handshake and an insincere smile - narcissism oozed through every pore of his perma-tanned skin.He seemed thoroughly untrustworthy. What I never imagined, was that he was a cold-blooded killer capable of murdering his parents.But just months after we first met Ernest battered his mother and father senseless with a baseball bat, finishing them off by slitting their throats with a ceremonial sword.It was a double-homicide that shocked America and for me – a British journalist who had only recently settled in the States – it came as quite a surprise too.Detectives took months to get to the bottom of the savage murder of his father, Ernest Scherer II, 60, and his mother Charlene Abendroth, 57, at their Castlewood Country Club home in affluent Pleasanton, central California, population 80,000.By then Ernest had gone on the run and his wife of nine years and high school sweetheart Robyn had gone into hiding with their son Ernest IV in case he came for them too.A painstaking investigation revealed our neighbour had been living a double life, taking on multiple mistresses and messaging women all over the country. Ernest Scherer III was a professional gambler with a limp handshake and an insincere smile Ernest Scherer II and Charlene Abendroth were murdered in their home in 2008He also owed eye watering sums, having accumulated $90,000 in unpaid gambling debts and $40,000 in outstanding credit card bills.The moment that tipped him over the edge was when his property investor father complained about having financial issues and demanded repayment of a five-year loan, which Ernest had used to buy an $880,000 home in Brea, California.What none of us could have known, was that his professional poker player son had run out of luck and was desperately searching for a winning hand.The cards he ended up playing – hoping to pay his debts through a premature payout on his inheritance - were pure evil.It's been 15 years since he was tried and convicted in a high-profile court case in which he was described as every parent's 'worst nightmare.'I find myself looking back on what unfolded with bewilderment and horror.I first met our new neighbours in the summer of 2007 when my family moved into a reasonably priced apartment building with a swimming pool in South Bay, California.Ernest, his wife and toddler son - who was a similar age to my oldest son - lived in the flat opposite.By autumn they had moved into a huge, detached house in a leafy community in nearby Orange County.But we kept in touch and in November, knowing we had few American friends, they kindly invited us over for Thanksgiving dinner at their new home.We always suspected Ernest was an adulterer due to his long absences away.But a murderer capable of parricide? That's still hard to fathom and it feels surreal as I write the following words.At 8:30 pm on March 7 2008, Ernest entered his parents' home – either letting himself in or getting his mother to let him in – and executed both of them, one after the other.Charlene, a devout Mormon who disapproved of his career, was his first victim and suffered the worst of his ire. After catching up with her at the top of the stairs, he inflicted 20 blows to her head with a baseball bat and stabbed her 12 times.His father came next, receiving a more modest six blows and six stab wounds before Ernest took a ceremonial sword from a collection hidden in a closet and used it to sever both their throats almost to the bone.With the corpses lying on the floor, Ernest set about staging a burglary. The Castlewood Country Club home in affluent Pleasanton, central California, where the bodies of Ernest Scherer II and Charlene Abendroth were foundHe made muddy footprints all over the carpet using a size 12 Nike trainer, rifled through drawers and smashed valuables. But he failed to steal the $9,000 in $100 bills his father had left stuffed in pockets all over the house after a recent gambling win.That was one of the key anomalies that made detectives realise the 'break-in' was suspicious.One of the officers on the case said: 'It was like someone had watched a TV show, this is what a burglary is supposed to look like.'Ernest was meticulous in covering his tracks, however. He did a decent job of playing the grieving son after the decomposing bodies of his pyjama-wearing parents were found by a concerned neighbour on 14 March 2008.Despite a series of blunders including asking to see a copy of his parents' will two days after they died, he came close to pulling off the perfect murder.There were no witnesses and no fingerprints at the scene. His phone had been turned off in the hours before the attack, meaning he could not be traced.The one piece of evidence that gave detectives hope – a grainy CCTV image of what appeared to be Ernest's red Chevrolet Camaro convertible entering the country club – did not identify him behind the wheel and so could not 100 per cent place him at the scene.Under questioning, the gambler was typically cocksure and full-of-himself, bragging about his wins and penchant for carrying tens of thousands in cash and chips.Footage of his police interview shows him maintaining a poker face throughout before smoothly praising his interrogators, saying: 'Thank you for doing your job, guys.'In a statement that was as cold as it was insouciant, he insisted: 'The drive time from my house to my parents' house was roughly six-and-a-half-hours so it's kind of unrealistic for me to drive all the way up to their house, kill them, and drive all the way back. And you'll be able to track me almost all the way to my door on my cell phone.'Ernest insisted he was fast asleep at his new home on the night of the murders, but like most killers, he made a fatal mistake.His decision to fill up his car at a Chevron petrol station in Primm, Nevada, led detectives to a nearby sports outlet where he had paid cash for a baseball bat, gloves and a size 12 Nike shoe two sizes too big for him.A bloodied warranty card for a youth baseball bat was also found at the scene.Knowing the noose was closing around his neck, Ernest told his wife he needed time to grieve and hit the road, driving across the States to visit his many mistresses.Finally accepting that her husband must have had something to do with the brutal crime, Robyn bravely decided to help the prosecution. Pallbearers carry the bodies of husband and wife Ernie Scherer II and Charlene Abendroth after a memorial serviceWearing a wire, she called and confronted him with the news that a CCTV camera had captured his car entering the country club. His reaction was: 'I need time to think.'The combined evidence was enough to convict Ernest, then 32, at his January, 2011 Alameda County trial despite him shamelessly flirting with a female juror.On 23 March he was convicted of two counts of first-degree murder and he is currently seeing out two life sentences.When I found out what he had done, I simply could not believe my ears.Ernest was thoroughly unlikeable, but he acted in awe of his dad when I was introduced to his parents at that same Thanksgiving dinner.His mother, by contrast, was cold and distant and devoid of maternal warmth. Looking back, I wonder whether there had been an argument about money before we arrived – and the awkwardness meant I breathed a sigh of relief when it was time to head home.Our hosts walked us out, and I remember Ernest and I tossing an American football across a neatly manicured lawn, before I put my kids in the car and said goodbye.What a quintessentially American experience, I mused, as we drove off.And what an incredible house. Robyn had confided in us about their debts and financial problems. My last thought before we hit the highway, never to return, was: I wonder how they can afford it?

Original Source

Read the full article at Dailymail →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.