I Discovered What My Brother Did With My Family’s Precious Heirlooms. Now It’s Time for Payback.

I Discovered What My Brother Did With My Family’s Precious Heirlooms. Now It’s Time for Payback.

Dear Prudence I knew he would do something like this. Advice by Enter your email to receive alerts for this author. Sign in or create an account to better manage your email preferences. Unsubscribe from email alerts Are you sure you want to unsubscribe from email alerts for Jenée Desmond-Harris? I’ve served as Prudie since 2021. In my personal life, I’ve composed text messages about delicate situations for people age 12 to 80 and received excellent reviews. Nov 18, 20266:00 AM Photo illustration by Slate. Photos by Getty Images Plus. Sign up for the Slatest to get the most insightful analysis, criticism, and advice out there, delivered to your inbox daily. Dear Prudence is Slate’s advice column. Submit questions here. Dear Prudence, My parents downsized so they could move into a senior living community this past summer. In the process, they gave away many cherished things that had been in the family to my brother “Dan” and his adult daughters, while I was ignored. Their rationale is that they “want them to stay in the family,” and I don’t have any kids. They failed to take into account that Dan and his brood are a bunch of greedy vultures who only ever come to them with their hands out and couldn’t care less about heirlooms. I have a friend whose brother runs a pawn shop, and last month, she called to tell me he told her Dan and his wife and kids were in there recently and sold him jewelry that belonged to my great-grandparents. He was kind enough to set it aside and sell it to me at a below-cost price. Should I tell my parents what Dan and his family did or keep quiet about it? —Black Sheep Dear Black Sheep, I spent some time thinking about what good could result from you reporting on Dan’s shady behavior, and I didn’t come up with much. On a practical level, the jewelry has been recovered, thanks to your friend and her pawn shop-owning brother. The saga is over. But I have some ideas about why part of you wants to tell your parents everything anyway. I imagine what you really want them to be aware of is not the whereabouts of the family heirlooms but rather the fact that Dan isn’t more deserving of love, thoughtfulness, and inclusion than you are. You hope they’ll realize they have messed up by treating you as the black sheep and elevating Dan’s status in the family simply because he procreated. You also want a different and better relationship with them. While it’s tempting to go about this by throwing the evidence of Dan’s vulture-like behavior in their faces, I worry that would backfire. If their longstanding habit is to give your brother preferential treatment, they’ll spin a story about his latest antics that will hurt you even more (“Poor Dan! He must be broke! We should all rally around him! Can you help by providing free childcare or letting him have your car?”). So I think a better way forward will be to decide between two options: Do the (admittedly difficult but worth attempting) work of deepening your relationship with your elderly parents and coaching them to break whatever patterns have left you feeling shunned. Maybe that’s asking for more individual time with them; asking them to celebrate your non-parenting-related life moments; sharing with them how you plan to honor their legacy, to encourage them to imagine this happening in ways that don’t involve grandchildren; or being honest about the things they’ve done that have made you feel alienated and telling them what you need from them. Or step back from the family enough that you are less hurt by their inexplicable obsession with a son who isn’t who they think he is. Please keep questions short (<150 words), and don’t submit the same question to multiple columns. We are unable to edit or remove questions after publication. Use pseudonyms to maintain anonymity. Your submission may be used in other Slate advice columns and may be edited for publication. Dear Prudence, I attended my best friend’s wedding (at considerable cost), and at my friend’s suggestion, I brought along my sister as a plus-one. After dinner, but before any of the dances or other events, my sister developed a stomachache. She went into the hallway and made a scene—splaying out in a public place in her formal attire and loudly commenting that the food made her ill. When the bride came over, she said she was ill (to the bride!) over my assurances that we were having a lovely time and enjoyed the food. She went on to comment on how bad the restroom smelled (there were other restrooms!) and refused any offer of ginger ale or suggestions to take a walk or move someplace quieter in order to feel better. I brought her some medicine to help her, but she still pressured me to leave right away. I insisted that we stay until the cake was served (I think it’s rude to leave earlier, especially my best friend’s wedding … and I wanted to stay to show my support for her), but she claimed she was having an allergic reaction and began to sob. I offered to take her to urgent care, but she would only go home. I think my sister should have taken 15 minutes to herself in the coat room and had a ginger ale, and I deeply regret leaving so early. What do I do during her next “allergic reaction”? Is it reasonable to ask someone to stick it out or to insist they sit in the coat room/lobby for a bit? To be fair, I think it’s quite likely that she was uncomfortable (or even mildly ill), but she didn’t seek out any medical care and wouldn’t accept any. —Can We Stay for Cake? Dear Stay for Cake, There has to be more to this story. More about your sister’s anxiety that presents as physical discomfort, her long history of selfish behavior, her legitimate sudden-onset mystery illness, or her jealousy over your best friend and her commitment to sabotage the relationship by any means necessary. I really have no idea what made her behave the way she did, but it’s something deeper. Luckily, you didn’t ask me to figure out why she made a scene at the wedding. You just want to know what you should do if you find yourself in this situation again, and I think I can help with that. As a general rule, if you’re with someone who says they’re having a medical emergency, you should believe them and help them get care. If they’re not feeling so terrible that they need to seek care immediately, it’s still a nice gesture to take them home. But this nice gesture shouldn’t be expected if it takes you away from a once-in-a-lifetime or very meaningful event, like your best friend’s wedding. In this case, the sick person can decide for themselves whether they need to find a quiet place to sit down and have a glass of water, take a rideshare to urgent care, or call an ambulance. Those are the options you should present to your sister if she has another episode and expects you both to cut your night out short. Prudie Wants to Hear From You! Readers often have great suggestions for our letter writers, occasionally disagree with a point Prudie makes, or simply want to provide some additional advice. Each week, Prudie will be replying to some of these comments and suggestions from readers, which will be featured on the site on Fridays for Slate Plus members. Write to us! Or submit a question here. Dear Prudence, My boyfriend and I are fighting about whether to go to his parents’ home for Thanksgiving. To say his family is dysfunctional would be the understatement of the decade. We went last year, and it was Hell on Earth. His parents spent nearly the entire holiday arguing while his siblings’ bratty kids ran amok unsupervised while their parents boozed it up (I had to prevent one of the toddlers from stabbing himself with a fork someone dropped), and the food was awful. He says it’s expected that everyone in his family comes home for Thanksgiving. He’s wonderful on his own, but the rest of his family is a goddamn nightmare. Would it be worth ending my relationship rather than face a future that includes these neanderthals? —Trashfire Family Dear Trashfire Family, It would indeed be worth it to end this relationship. Commitment to family and tolerance for unpleasant family experiences are topics people who are going to be life partners really need to be aligned on. Your boyfriend isn’t wrong to decide that continuing family traditions and meeting expectations are non-negotiable to him, even if the experience involves inedible food, sloppy drunks, and a toddler’s attempts to visit the emergency room. He might even enjoy all of this on some level, because it feels familiar and comfortable to him. And you aren’t wrong to honor your total lack of tolerance for any of it. The bad thing would be for you to agree to attend, have a terrible attitude, make everyone feel judged, and get in the way of his enjoyment of the chaos. Or for him to guilt trip you into showing up and pretending not to be miserable. The intensity of your disdain for his relatives tells me there’s not much room for compromise here. Go your separate ways and look for a partner who seems like they might enjoy a quiet, civilized holiday meal at a nice restaurant—maybe followed by a quick FaceTime with relatives, while you use headphones so you don’t have to hear any of it. Classic Prudie When my brother went to college across the country, I added him onto my Netflix and gave him all the info. At the time it was still cheap and allowed four people to use it at time. I also sent him money, gift cards, bought him nice meals and pizza remotely, and listened to him complain about how much he hated the beautiful, tropical destination vacation spot his college was located in. Our parents supported him fully; rent, phone, car, insurance, grocery money, etc. This was not something offered to me, as I am the “black sheep” of the family, but I digress… Advice Dear Prudence Family

Original Source

Read the full article at Slate →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.