Television The Altruists reduces a complex criminal disaster to … a love story? By Enter your email to receive alerts for this author. Sign in or create an account to better manage your email preferences. Unsubscribe from email alerts Are you sure you want to unsubscribe from email alerts for Nitish Pahwa? Nov 19, 202611:56 AM Netflix Sign up for the Slatest to get the most insightful analysis, criticism, and advice out there, delivered to your inbox daily. Somehow, the people whom convicted crypto grifter Sam Bankman-Fried defrauded never show up in The Altruists, Netflix’s new limited series about the rise and fall of Bankman-Fried’s FTX cryptocurrency exchange, as well as his fraught on-and-off relationship with co-conspirator Caroline Ellison. Those SBF victims are somewhere out there, conceptually; they’re forgettable enough if you never think about them and are made to focus, specifically, on how Bankman-Fried supposedly felt about the international wreckage he fostered, instead of its actual impacts. In a real display of narrative gymnastics, The Altruists manages to mention his early Anthropic investment way more than any of the people who were, say, suckered by big celebrity partnerships into trusting their funds to SBF so he could direct them toward more such investments, sponsorships, and political megadonations. (And what timing for this show to drop, with Anthropic’s unfolding IPO!) The argument Bankman-Fried has repeatedly, unsuccessfully made from behind bars, all the way up through this week, is that the returns from this now-megahyped A.I. firm would have made up for all the money people lost under his watch. Just conveniently set aside the fact that he’s the reason that money went missing, as he used his own customers’ funds to acquire that Anthropic stake, just to support his effective altruist friends at the company, even after he repeatedly proclaimed that FTX did not siphon client deposits, and after those folks insisted they never gave him permission to use their money thus. Does a fictionalized retelling of a complex financial scheme need to be 100 percent—or even, say, 75 percent—faithful to real-world events? Of course not. The Altruists is not a docuseries, not does it claim to be, even as it explicitly draws from New York magazine’s (excellent) coverage of SBF’s 2022–23 downfall, which kicked off after his crypto hedge fund, Alameda Research, was revealed as having shakier finances and more inappropriate ties with FTX than either company publicly let on. But it’s the very people behind The Altruists who are asking us, the viewers, to take its narrative seriously. “I felt this tremendous responsibility to make sure we were telling these real people’s real story accurately,” said Graham Moore, the Oscar-winning screenwriter who created The Altruists, in a Tudum interview. Even star Anthony Boyle—who at various points does manage to eerily emulate some of SBF’s most antic mannerisms—would like us to keep the scammed in mind. “People did go bankrupt, and people unfortunately died by suicide through this. Marriages broke up. Families tore apart because all of their money was in this,” he acknowledged to Vanity Fair, in an interview where he also mentioned speaking at length with the imprisoned Bankman-Fried. “That’s something that we have to remember when talking about the show. There were real-world consequences because of this crash.” So, if the show’s creator and star are asking us to evaluate this series on those grounds, then, in my capacity as someone who reported in depth on both Bankman-Fried’s downfall and his federal trial for Slate, I’m happy to do just that. In that regard, this show fails so miserably as to be deceitful to its audience and insulting to everyone left ruined by FTX’s shenanigans. It’s bad enough that The Altruists, on a storytelling level, parrots all the worst ideas Netflix has about optimized TV in the age of second screens: easing the binge-watch impulse, relying on horrible scene lighting, stuffing in stilted explanatory dialogue wherever possible, and using a hokey score for dramatic effect. It’s even worse that The Altruists reduces a truly complex, fascinating, still-unraveling criminal disaster to the mere contours of a doomed romance between two power players—a saga that’s so exaggerated and cheesed-up here that it (spoiler alert) ends, after eight episodes, with Caroline Ellison (Julia Garner) telling SBF over the phone that she loves him right as the Bahamian authorities arrest him. I’m not going to mince words: This is terrible TV that’s also incorrect on the merits. The most telling aspect of The Altruists is that it tries to inculpate almost everyone except the man at the center of the scheme. Ellison’s leaked personal diaries—notably made public years ago by SBF himself—describe him as the ultimate decisionmaker and hard-minded bull who belittled, underpaid, and sidelined her from the beginning; it was a dynamic she also recounted under oath, in a trial where Bankman-Fried himself mostly responded to even simple questions with “I don’t remember.” (Another group that had early awareness of Bankman-Fried’s duplicity: the very effective altruists to whom SBF cut checks.) In The Altruists, however, it’s Ellison who’s the sexed-up, aggressive femme fatale pushing Bankman-Fried into escalating criminality: ordering him to screw over his first business partner at Alameda, suggesting that Alameda and FTX illegally trade customer funds (and demanding that he tank any monetary safeguards), telling him to push forward with a ruinous bailout of a collapsing crypto firm, insisting that he send out a falsified balance sheet to worried investors—all to his repeated resistance. (This goes against everything we’ve long known about SBF, a guy who was so “utilitarian” and willing to take any chances that he once said on a podcast that he’d take on a hypothetical experiment even if it had a 49 percent chance of extinguishing the entire planet.) At one point, Ellison even throws an iced coffee at a journalist, something that, as far as I know, has never been reported on in real life. It’s only Garner’s absolutely masterful mimicry of Ellison—down to her unique voice and nervous physical habits—that remotely saves this character from entirely being a cliché caricature. (Garner is also, far and away, the best part of this wretched property.) Even if you think Ellison may not have been entirely truthful on the stand, it’s worth underlining that none of what The Altruists shows of her jibes with anything we know from Ellison’s contemporaneous accounts, or with SBF’s own recollections in the trial. This extends not just to Ellison, but to plenty of people within Bankman-Fried’s circle. Sam Trabucco (Alex Lawther), a co-CEO of Alameda who left the firm in the middle of 2022 and has all but disappeared ever since FTX’s collapse, is presented here as remorsefully having come up with all the ideas that allowed Bankman-Fried to build up his crypto empire, from Alameda’s Bitcoin arbitrage (which Bankman-Fried was already doing at his prior employer, Jane Street) to minting the in-house FTT token that enabled a lot of asset inflation and eventually unraveled the whole thing. (The Altruists also positions him as an opponent of Sam and Caroline’s efforts to prevent the collapse, even though he tweeted in defense of Ellison right before everything gave out.) SBF pal Gary Wang (Eugene Young) is shown as insisting on criminal behavior from the beginning, only to be discouraged by Bankman-Fried and later let in on the real fraud while everything is collapsing. (In reality, per Wang’s testimony, he’d long helped encode many of the backdoors that allowed for SBF’s accounting trickery, again at his friend’s/boss’s behest.) Bankman-Fried’s aggravated attempts to shift all the culpability away from himself couldn’t ask for a better complement than The Altruists, which coddles him to an almost astonishing degree. And frankly, it seems that may have been part of creator Moore’s intent here. “I genuinely believe that both Sam and Caroline were deeply committed altruists from day one, who set out to do as much good for as many people as they could. And over the course of the years that our show depicts, they—with the very best of intentions—talked each other and themselves into committing a number of terrible crimes,” he told Tudum, calling the two “real 26, 28-year-olds who were suddenly thrust into this position where there are billions of dollars riding on their every decision.” (The passive voice, as ever, proves damning. As if these twentysomethings had no agency! As if Bankman-Fried was not repeatedly documented as making those orders!) In fairness, it might be difficult to cast attempts to impersonate real Thai prostitutes to get around China’s 2021 freeze on Alameda’s accounts—something that very much happened—as acts that were the result of “the very best of intentions.” So, naturally, The Altruists can’t show that, nor can it bother to even acknowledge the many misdeeds and contradicting accounts SBF engaged in after FTX’s fall, because that would be too inconvenient for Moore’s bizarre interpretation of events. As much as he tries to spin things in another direction, this is not primarily a story about love, or about good intentions gone wrong. It’s a story about opportunistic cowards—and, apparently, the people who see fit to burnish their reputations afterward. Crime Cryptocurrency Netflix TV FTX SBF Trial
I Covered the Sam Bankman-Fried Trial. Netflix’s New Show About Him Gets Everything Wrong.
Full Article
Original Source
Read the full article at Slate →KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.