Three years ago I bought a small cottage for my son but kept it in my name. He has now rented it out and is travelling abroad, living off this income. Which is fine with me.However I’m guessing I will be liable for paying tax on the £858 he receives each month, after the agency’s fees are paid.I am a pensioner but still work and have some savings, so I do pay tax anyway.As I don’t receive a penny of the rent can I avoid this extra tax burden?I know I could put the house in his name, which I want to do really, but as he is abroad that makes it difficult. J.P.Heather Rogers, founder and owner of Aston Accountancy, replies: The answer to who is entitled to the profits from the rental of this property and therefore responsible for the tax bill is not straightforward.From what you say about the cottage being in your name, it seems clear that you are the ‘legal owner’.However, depending on what arrangements you made with your son when you bought the property for him, he might be the ‘beneficial owner’. Tax on rental income: Who will HMRC hold responsible for paying the bill?If that is the case, it would mean he owes the tax rather than you. This is because for income tax purposes, the person liable for the tax on the rental income is the person ‘receiving or entitled to the profits’.Let me disentangle all this for you below, but ultimately your best course of action is to consult a new solicitor or go back to the firm who acted for you over the purchase, to clarify these matters between you and your son.Legal and beneficial ownershipNormally, with a property, the person who holds the legal title and is registered at the Land Registry as the ‘legal owner’ is the same person who would benefit from the rights to the property.The legal owner can sell the property, determine if they or someone else lives in it, and would normally benefit from the proceeds of any sale.However, there is another form of ownership called ‘beneficial ownership’, and it is the beneficial owner to whom HMRC looks when determining who is responsible for tax purposes.The beneficial owner has a right to benefit from the property even though they are not the legal owner.They may be someone who has invested money into the property, or have the right to live in the property under the terms of an agreement between them and the owner - for example a child of the owner who does not pay rent - or they may be entitled to a share of the proceeds.However their name does not appear on the legal title of the property.Normally, to avoid issues arising at a later date, when there is a beneficial owner an agreement would normally be drawn up as a Deed of Trust or just an ‘express agreement’.The latter is an oral or written agreement stating your joint intentions. A written agreement is better, a Deed of Trust is better still.Either one of these would identify the rights of the beneficial owner. For example, how they are entitled to benefit from the property; whether they have a right to the income arising, or that of residence; whether they have to contribute to the property; and what happens when the property is sold. Scroll down to find out how to ask Heather Rogers your tax questionIs your son the beneficial ownerWhether your son is the ‘beneficial owner’ and therefore liable for the tax bills will depend on a number of factors.First, do you have any written agreement between you identifying that he has the right to the rental income?You say your son has let out the property, but as you are the legal owner are you or is he the landlord?If you are the landlord and the money is paid to you and you hand it to him every month, then there is a strong argument that you are the person controlling the income and you are entitled to it.The fact that you then choose to gift the monies to him would not necessarily make him the beneficial owner and the chances are HMRC would deem you liable for the tax on the rental income.However, if your son is the named landlord - which would be difficult as he is not the legal owner - and he receives the funds directly, then he could be deemed to be the beneficial owner.This would then make him liable for the tax, even if you are assisting him with regards to the property, for example if you deal with the rental agent on his behalf whilst he’s away.If you and your son are both named as landlords then you could both be assessed for tax equally, depending on what happens in practice.My expectation is that unless you have an agreement in place, you as the legal owner are the landlord.What should you do now?It is important that you consult a solicitor about this, and if you have not already done so that you establish either a Deed of Trust or an express agreement.This would ensure that any rights your son has as a beneficial owner are clearly defined, including the right to the rental profits.Once this is in place, he will be taxed on it and not you.If he is clearly identified as the beneficial owner of the income, then he will need to pay the tax on the rental profit, as it is arising in the UK and will be taxable in the UK, regardless of where he may be resident.He will need to register for self-assessment.You are correct that the most straightforward course of action would be for you to gift your son the property as then he would be both the legal and beneficial owner.This would be classed as a Potentially Exempt Transfer (PET) and would be outside your estate within seven years for inheritance tax purposes.There could be capital gains tax due if the property has increased in value since you bought it, but you might be able to claim Private Residence Relief for the period in which your son lived in it as his main residence.You should be able to do so if you already have a Deed of Trust, or if it can be established there is already an implied trust, which I suggest there is, as your son had the right to occupy the property.Private Residence Relief is available for trusts if a person is entitled to live in a property as their main residence under the terms of the trust.Disputes about beneficial ownership are commonThe determination of beneficial ownership can be very complicated and a lot of tax enquiries are opened on the back of it.In two recent Court of Appeal cases, either ‘receipt or entitlement’ was given as a definition of who paid the tax on profits.In a First Tier Tribunal on an earlier case, the Tribunal found that the person who should pay tax on the profits was the one who received and controlled them.In this case, the property was owned by someone other than the person deemed liable for the tax. Ask Heather Rogers a tax question Heather Rogers, founder and owner of Aston Accountancy, is our tax columnist. She is ready to answer your questions on any tax topic - tax codes, inheritance tax, income tax, capital gains tax, and much more.If you would like to ask Heather a question about tax, email her at taxquestions@thisismoney.co.uk.Heather will do her best to reply to your message in a forthcoming monthly column, but she won't be able to answer everyone or correspond privately with readers. Nothing in her replies constitutes regulated financial advice. Published questions are sometimes edited for brevity or other reasons.Please include a daytime contact number with your message - this will be kept confidential and not used for marketing purposes.If Heather is unable to answer your question, you can find out about getting help with tax here, including sources of free professional advice if you are elderly and/or on a low income.You can also contact MoneyHelper, a Government-backed organisation which gives free assistance on financial matters to the public. Its number is 0800 011 3797.Heather gives tips on how to find a good accountant here, including when to seek help, hiring the right type of firm and typical costs.
I bought my son a cottage but he's gone off travelling and rented it out. Am I on the hook for the tax?
Full Article
Original Source
Read the full article at Dailymail →KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.