Government plans to switch off Freeview and move to online-only TV are a threat to national security and must be scrapped, an influential Lords committee has said. Ministers want to switch off Digital Terrestrial TV (DTT) broadcasts, received by household aerials, as soon as 2034 as more people sign up to streaming platforms. But in a scathing report warning that the UK is seriously underprepared for a national emergency, the Lords Resilience Committee said switching off broadcast TV would leave pensioners and vulnerable groups without a vital source of communication. The committee also said that the UK’s network of digital television “tall tower” masts could be the only reliable network capable of transmitting emergency messages if a Russian or Iranian cyberattack caused an internet blackout. ‘Older people at risk’ Committee chair Baroness Coussins told The i Paper: “In a national emergency, access to reliable information can be a lifeline. Switching off digital terrestrial television risks leaving millions of people, particularly older and more vulnerable groups, without a vital source of communication.” “At a time when we should be strengthening our national resilience, it makes no sense to remove a system that helps ensure information can reach everyone.” The warning comes amid growing hybrid warfare attacks. The report warns the public “don’t have a full picture of the level and frequency of current subthreshold hostility against the UK from Russia, China and Iran”. These include cyber-attacks, proxy acts of violence, or threats to undersea cables and pipelines “on which our communications and energy flows depend”, the report added.It points to a recent Russian operation intended to discredit a counter-disinformation campaign run by the Government. National resilience risk The report is a blow to the government, which is committed to phasing out DTT. The move is also backed by the BBC and other broadcasters. But an estimated 220,000 homes will still be without broadband by the mid-2030s. Ministers are considering whether switch-off should be pushed back to 2044. However the peers said a forced move to internet-only TV, which could cost some households an additional £218 a year to access high-speed broadband, should be dropped altogether. The plan risks “weakening national resilience by reducing universal access to communication”. The peers found that national resilience is “heavily reliant on digital communication, but the supporting infrastructure remains vulnerable to power outages and/or damage to subsea cables”. The Government’s “dependence on digital systems without comprehensive back-up arrangements [is] a significant resilience weakness”, the report added. ‘Older people could lose lifeline’ Rhodri Talfan Davies, BBC Deputy Director-General, told the committee that broadcasters and the Government must ensure that people who depend on DTT are supported through the transition to digital services. The corporation would fall back on lower tech networks to keep people informed in an emergency scenario, he added. “Clearly, access to a radio, whether a wind-up or a battery-operated one, which has access, ideally, to both FM and DAB frequencies is probably the best option that users would face.” The peers also urged the Government to “learn lessons” from switching off the Public Switched Telephone Network. Remaining traditional phone landlines will be replaced by digital connections in January next year. ‘No-one will be left behind’ Dennis Reed, director of Silver Voices, the campaign group for older people, said the report “has hit the nail on the head. The PSTN switch off has left millions of older and vulnerable customers with a telephone system which does not work in a power cut or if the internet is down.” “To go down the same route with Freeview, and scrap universal access to TV and the trusted aerial distribution system would be playing fast and loose with the defence of the nation. In the event of a Black Sky event, to rely solely on the internet for all forms of communication would be irresponsible.” A Government spokesperson said “there is a strong case for a transition to IPTV (TV over broadband), but no decisions have been made”. The Department for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport has been “gathering views from across the sector and the public before any final decisions are taken”. The spokesperson added: “We are committed to ensuring that no one is left behind as TV viewing increasingly moves online. Any future transition would only proceed once we are confident the right safeguards, infrastructure and support are in place so that everyone can continue to access television affordably and with confidence.” Ministers will set out a path to switch-off in a White Paper “in due course.”
How online-only TV could leave millions vulnerable to hostile-state cyber attacks
Full Article
Original Source
Read the full article at Inews →KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.