How Americans rate the federal agencies in the news

How Americans rate the federal agencies in the news

The blame game for the nationwide airline ground stoppage last week began immediately. A combative Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy said Congress hadn’t provided nearly enough money to modernize an antiquated system, while Sen. Chris Van Hollen (D-MD) pushed back, saying Congress wasn’t at fault, pointing the finger instead at a slow-moving department that hadn’t spent appropriated funds. Being in the news is rarely positive for a government department or agency. It is worth looking at how the public views government work.This fall, both Gallup and Pew Research released updates. Pew looked at views of 12 federal government departments and agencies. Gallup has been asking about a larger group for at least 15 years. In September, Gallup asked people to rate the job being done by five Cabinet departments and 12 agencies.Neither pollster asked about the DOT, but Gallup asked about the Federal Aviation Administration and found that 43% rated the job the agency was doing as excellent or good, behind only the mostly highly regarded U.S. Postal Service (58%) and NASA (53%). We will have to wait for public reaction to the ground stoppage, but data are available on other agencies in the news recently, including Immigration and Customs Enforcement, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, the Secret Service, and NASA. In his interview with Ross Douthat on 60 Minutes, President Donald Trump said his immigration policies “both helped and hurt,” suggesting that the ICE investigations were “too tough.”Polls show the public agreed. The voter poll showed that 60% of voters disapproved of the way ICE was handling its job. Fifty-six percent in Pew’s late September-early October poll gave ICE an unfavorable rating. Views of the Department of Homeland Security in Gallup’s polling improved in 2025 as the public decided Trump was getting the border under control, but dropped this year to 36%, close to the department’s all-time low (32%).For decades, people have told pollsters that they want the government to do many things. At the same time, they say Washington isn’t executing those things well.A recent Gallup /Bentley University poll finds that 92% believe the federal government can make a positive impact on people’s lives. Only 43% believe that it is effective in doing so: a stunning 46-point gap. When CBS asked a similar question 35 years ago, the results were much the same. Negative views about the government as a whole are deeply entrenched, and they won’t be reversed any time soon. That is why it makes sense for policymakers and politicians to also look at opinions on individual government departments and agencies.The CDC’s rating plummeted during COVID-19, from 64% in 2019 to 40% in 2021 (Gallup). Although the agency has tried to hit the reset button, just 26% gave it an excellent or good rating for job performance in the new Gallup poll, while 25% did so for the Food and Drug Administration. Pew also asks about the CDC. In 2023, 56% had a favorable view. That is now 47%.Unlike the CDC, views of the Secret Service have improved modestly. Fifty-five percent rated its performance as excellent or good in 2023 (Gallup). That dropped to 32% in 2024 after failures to protect the president adequately. There has been a slight recovery, with 39% viewing it positively today.Performance matters. Neither Gallup nor Pew was tracking NASA ratings at the time of the 1986 space shuttle disaster, but other polls showed a deterioration in the agency’s standing and then a solid recovery. Unlike the federal government as a whole, NASA has a clear mission with a strong esprit de corps among its staff. The public recognizes it.PUBLIC TRUST IN THE GOVERNMENT AT ONE OF ITS LOWEST POINTSPartisanship also plays a role in these judgments. In Pew’s latest, there is a chasm in views about ICE, with 67% of Republicans and only 9% of Democrats rating it favorably. Other agencies and departments that show big partisan gaps include DHS, the Departments of Justice and State, and the FBI. Gallup notes that the Departments of Justice, State, and Defense reached a low in the new ratings: “[N]o more than 24% of Democrats rat[ed] any of the Cabinets positively, with a low of 11% for the Justice Department.”The political consequences of ignoring public opinion on federal departments and agencies can be serious, as the Republicans learned this fall. Both parties and policymakers need to pay attention.

Original Source

Read the full article at Washingtonexaminer →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.