No money changes hands when users join Facebook, but their personal information helps keep the advertising business running. EU judges must now decide whether that counts as payment.(CN) — Facebook promised users they’d never have to pay to join, but an EU court adviser said Thursday that the price of signing up could be the right to use their data.In February 2015, Facebook’s German-language sign-up page told users, “Facebook is and remains free.” The Federation of German Consumer Organizations sued Meta Platforms Ireland to stop it from using the slogan with German consumers.Germany’s top court turned to the Court of Justice of the European Union to answer the federation’s central question: Did users pay by handing over their personal information and letting Facebook use it commercially?Advocate General Laila Medina said they did under the bloc’s unfair advertising rules.Facebook required users to share data and give the company permission to use it before they could sign up. That let the company build detailed profiles and sell targeted ads that helped fund the network. In Medina’s view, the permission itself had value even though users kept their information. Her reading would still let companies call a service “free” if they used the data solely to provide it or meet a legal obligation.A Facebook signup page displaying the promise “It’s free and always will be,” published on Sept. 6, 2015. (Prylarer/Pixabay via Courthouse News)Some versions of the EU rule pointed to payment in money, while others left room for other forms of payment. Medina looked at what consumers could actually see when they signed up. A cash price is right there on the screen. Someone who hands over data for commercial use has less to go on.“That person is unlikely to be aware of the economic value of what he or she is giving, or of the extent of the advertising to which the disclosure of those data may give rise,” Medina wrote.Andreas Kotsios, a senior lecturer in EU law at Uppsala University, questioned whether users saw their data as something they were spending. “Following the same logic, one could argue that the time spent watching advertisements also constitutes a similar cost,” he said. “After all, time is money!”Kotsios thought the judges might adopt Medina’s reading. He worried that treating data as payment could give companies a rationale for exploiting it as an asset, and he doubted dropping the word “free” would change many people’s minds about signing up.Before suing, the federation asked Facebook to sign a formal pledge to stop using the slogan. The company refused. Two Berlin courts sided with Facebook, with the first finding the rule applied only when consumers faced a financial burden. Germany’s Federal Court of Justice put the case on hold in September 2025 to seek an answer from the EU judges.Ramona Pop, the federation’s executive director, welcomed the opinion as an encouraging sign for consumers who trade data for everyday services. Facebook had already dropped the slogan, she noted, but the stakes went beyond social media. Germany’s top court also paused the federation’s case over whether discount grocer Lidl made the cost of using its rewards app clear enough to shoppers.Meta argues that free means no monetary charge and that EU privacy law already protects users. Treating personal data as payment, it says, would turn a fundamental right into a commodity and unfairly restrict ad-supported services.“We respectfully disagree with the advocate general and await the European court’s decision,” a Meta spokesperson said.Medina said privacy law governed how companies handled data, while consumer law governed what they told customers. Her reading left companies free to run ad-funded services. Once a free offer fell under the ban, she said, there was no need to prove that a particular user had been misled.Donato Maria Matera, a lecturer in information technology law at Italy’s LUM Giuseppe Degennaro University, said Italian regulators and courts had already taken a similar approach. In his view, it kept businesses from using a narrow reading of advertising law to sidestep consumer protections while leaving privacy rights intact.“It is particularly important that this transparency should be ensured from the very earliest stages of commercial communication,” he said.What people see before they click Sign Up, he noted, can shape whether they click at all.Medina’s opinion is advisory and cannot be appealed. The EU judges will give the binding answer on what counts as payment. Germany’s top court will then decide whether Meta can bring back its old promise.Courthouse News reporter Eunseo Hong is based in the Netherlands.Subscribe to our free newslettersOur weekly newsletter Closing Arguments offers the latest about ongoing trials, major litigation and rulings in courthouses around the U.S. and the world, while the monthly Under the Lights dishes the legal dirt from Hollywood, sports, Big Tech and the arts.Additional Reads
Hidden price of Facebook’s free sign-ups faces EU court test
Full Article
Original Source
Read the full article at Courthousenews →KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.