Dear Prudence I had hoped they’d be up to par. Advice by Enter your email to receive alerts for this author. Sign in or create an account to better manage your email preferences. Unsubscribe from email alerts Are you sure you want to unsubscribe from email alerts for Jenée Desmond-Harris? I’ve served as Prudie since 2021. In my personal life, I’ve composed text messages about delicate situations for people aged 12 to 80 and have received excellent reviews. Nov 17, 20266:00 AM Photo illustration by Slate. Photos by DMP/Getty Images Plus, Lupion/Adobe Stock, and BillionPhotos.com/Adobe Stock. Sign up for the Slatest to get the most insightful analysis, criticism, and advice out there, delivered to your inbox daily. For a special edition, we asked you all to write to us with your wildest Thanksgiving Day tales and fiascos. Prudie weighs in on what she would’ve done. Hey Prudie, You asked for a wild holiday story, and I’ve got one that’s basically become lore among my friends. I’ll start with some backstory. I did not learn to cook growing up. For my very first big girl, 18-year-old Thanksgiving, I set out to make The Feast. I got a recipe from a friend’s mom who owned a gourmet restaurant. It went mostly fine except that I basted over the little red timer and overcooked it by about three hours. Not to be deterred, I spent the next five years becoming a much better cook, now armed with a real thermometer. I love Thanksgiving. It’s my absolute favorite holiday. I typically cook and have people pass by throughout the day with a set dinner time. I love people hanging out in the kitchen and chatting with me as I cook. One year, I made 17 separate dishes, and it was a LOT of work. I reflected and realized I really only cared about five things: turkey, stuffing, gravy, corn, and mashed potatoes. For the last 10 years, that’s what I’ve made. Everyone near and far is still welcome, and I make it clear what I’m making. You want sweet potatoes, mac and cheese, or green beans? Then you’re welcome to bring those! For people who don’t want to cook but want to contribute, I ask for rolls, pies, or a can of cranberry sauce. I don’t care what doesn’t get brought because I know I have my staples covered and I’m just happy to see people! Enter the first year my mother-in-law moved to our state. She’s a lovely woman, and I have no gripes about her. She is decidedly not a cook. She actually has a cutesy sign in her kitchen that says, “If I heat it up in the oven … it’s homemade!” That is fine—to each their own. The first Thanksgiving they attended, I told her my dishes. She said she needed sweet potatoes. I told her she was welcome to bring some! Then she said she’d also do mashed potatoes, and I said not to worry; I had those covered. I like making them. She insisted, so I relented, hoping they’d be up to par. They arrived about 30 mins before dinner was set to start. She unpacked a lovely ceramic dish of sweet potatoes and asked if I could warm them in the oven. Then she pulled out the mashed potatoes … in a plastic clamshell container from Costco. I have RBF in the best of moments, but in the worst moments, it’s just straight-up Bitch Face. Not resting. I stared at the stupid, plastic, corporate-made potatoes for several seconds and coldly said, “I told you I would have made the potatoes.” Right then, my husband came into the kitchen. Husband: “Hey babe, let’s go outside!”Me: “I don’t need to go outside.”Husband: “You’ve been working so hard … let’s take a break.”Me: I said… And then he grabbed me by the shoulders and marched me outside, where I promptly lost my shit about the mashed potatoes. Luckily, not in front of my MIL. During dinner, she commented, “See… Costco potatoes are good!” (To be fair, they weren’t bad at all. They just were not the ultra-creamy garlic parmesan version I do.) Before I could respond, my husband shot me a look that can only be described as, “DON’T.” Was this a weird power play? Did she genuinely think she was being helpful? I don’t know. We’ve never celebrated Thanksgiving with them again, and my husband refuses to talk about potato gate. —Be Spud Eld (she/her) Dear Be Spud Eld, Thank you for the entertaining read. You’re a great storyteller, and I was rapt the whole time. I was also a little nervous that the story would end in violence (maybe your husband had the same concern?). I understand how mad you were because few things are more infuriating than a person who doesn’t really cook or care about food insisting on having control over some element of the menu. Plus, you weren’t a demanding host! You didn’t force everyone to cook according to your recipe or ask everyone to show up dressed like pilgrims (one day I will tell the story of how I ended up at a Boston-area Thanksgiving dinner with this theme!). You simply wanted to prepare and serve the five core items you really care about. My job here is to say what I would have done if I had been in your shoes in the Costco potato saga. When Mother-in-Law insisted on bringing them, I would have said, “OK! I’m still going to make mine because I’m attached to making the things I always make the way I like them. But we’ll have more leftovers if there are two options, so that will be great.” (Privately, I would have been thinking, “All the leftovers will be yours because they’re going to be mediocre at best and not have garlic or parmesan.”) And then when she raved about them, I would have replied, “Yeah, they’re pretty good.” Hopefully, I would have meant it, and not been filled with rage or needed to be physically restrained. Please keep questions short (<150 words), and don’t submit the same question to multiple columns. We are unable to edit or remove questions after publication. Use pseudonyms to maintain anonymity. Your submission may be used in other Slate advice columns and may be edited for publication. Hey Prudie, My mom remarried into a large family when I was an adult. My stepdad and three new step-siblings were wonderful, but I didn’t really get to know most of the extended family. One Thanksgiving dinner, as we sat around the table, I said to a step-uncle, “Oh, Alex, I met your son at work on Monday, and he says hi.” There was dead silence as Alex’s four adult daughters looked at him. Alex mumbled something like, “Oh, ahh yeah, OK,” and got up to get coffee. Turns out the 31-year-old son was a secret and a complete surprise to Alex’s daughters. I felt so bad that I had just blithely announced a decades-long secret son at Thanksgiving. I didn’t know he “only” had daughters. —Ruined the Pumpkin Pie Dear Ruined the Pumpkin Pie, If I’d realized in the moment that I’d revealed a family secret, I probably would have stumbled over my words trying to backtrack by saying something like, “Oops, I said son? I meant little brother … that’s how the guy you once mentored referred to himself, which I thought was really sweet. I’ve clearly had a little too much wine. Why would I say son?” and then added a little awkward laugh. I suppose this is where the difference between the advice I would have given and what I would have personally done becomes clear! Because you did nothing wrong, and Alex is living with the consequences of his own choice to keep a secret, which was going to come out at some point anyway. In that moment, you didn’t need to do a thing. Prudie Wants to Hear From You! Readers often have great suggestions for our letter writers, occasionally disagree with a point Prudie makes, or simply want to provide some additional advice. Each week, Prudie will be replying to some of these comments and suggestions from readers, which will be featured on the site on Fridays for Slate Plus members. Write to us! Or submit a question here. Hey Prudie, My wildest holiday story: My husband and I traveled from out of state to be home with my mom for Thanksgiving one year. When we arrived, we discovered to our horror that she had been thawing a giant turkey in a variety of ways—over multiple days. This included leaving it in a guest room, the garage, and on the kitchen counter. We were pretty worried and had to call the Butterball Turkey hotline on Thanksgiving Day. They immediately told us not to cook or eat this turkey under any circumstances! So we had to toss it. Every store in town was closed, so we couldn’t buy a new one, and we ended up scrounging up a ham with her fruit Jell-O. Thank goodness for the hotline, or I don’t think we could have convinced my mom to give up on the turkey. —Unthawable Holiday Chaos Dear Unthawable Holiday Chaos, Oh God. I cried real tears thinking about the turkey in the guest room. Why was she moving it around the house? This is hilarious and not that tragic. (Also, I didn’t know there was a turkey hotline, but that’s a good number for everyone to have on speed dial this year.) I’ll set myself up for rebuttals from people who are proud of their cooking techniques, but turkey is dry and not that good anyway! Hey Prudie, Ten years ago, my husband and I took in a macaw, “Frank,” that belonged to a friend who had passed away. On Thanksgiving, we had both sides of the family over, including my uptight religious in-laws. When we were all gathered at the table, my father-in-law forced the family to sit through a lengthy grace. As soon as he said, “Amen,” Frank shouted, “Suck my dick!” My in-laws were mortified, while the rest of us got a huge laugh and a story we still tell to this day. And yes, we still have Frank, and yes, he still says dirty (and insanely funny) things. —Frank’s Proud Mom Dear Proud Mom, Oh my God, Frank!! I would have been right there with you, laughing. To the offended elders, I would’ve said something like, “So sorry. He’s been hanging out with the wrong crowd.” I have so many questions, like how many times was the phrase said around your house for him to pick up on it? I hope the in-laws gave him some credit for waiting until the end of grace and not interrupting. Hey Prudie, My sister and her husband realized one Thanksgiving Day that their oven wasn’t working perfectly. It could heat up, but not high enough to roast a turkey, which they realized while wondering why their turkey didn’t seem to be progressing as it should have been. They tried to make up for it by cooking it for a longer time, but the meat thermometer showed that it wasn’t hot enough, and it didn’t look done when they served it. The side dishes were all foods that could be cooked on the stove, so I ate those and skipped the turkey that year. They both ate the turkey and didn’t get sick… —Giving Up Warm Turkey Dear Giving Up Warm Turkey, They ate the undercooked turkey?! I want to throw up just thinking about that. I’m glad they were fine. I’m reminded of Slate writer Luke Winkie’s journey to try medium-rare chicken, who also didn’t suffer from a nasty bout of food poisoning after his … culinary adventure. As mentioned above, I would gladly never eat turkey again, so enjoying more room for sides sounds like the right idea. Hey Prudie, One Thanksgiving, we hosted both our mothers, which was a mistake considering neither one really liked the other. But they were both recently widowed and sort of invited themselves, so we were stuck. Our daughter decided she would make sangria punch, but added vodka because she thought we were too worried about “dueling grandmas.” Fast forward to us being incredibly sloshed, so we put the main course (a veggie loaf because we are vegetarian) into the oven and went for a walk to clear our heads. Only to discover our oven’s thermometer was broken and the temp had risen so high the main course was burnt to a crisp when we came back. Right then, dueling grandmas appeared, and each one said something about how they knew we would screw it up. We were too drunk to care, so we just laughed at them. Strangely, that Thanksgiving was even worse than the one where I got food poisoning and our cat died. Let’s just say, Thanksgiving isn’t a holiday tradition we love very much around here. —Thanksgiving Is NOT for the Vegetarians Dear Thanksgiving Is NOT for the Vegetarians, This is hilarious, and I’m happy it worked out. Assuming the dualing grandmas knew they were going to be consuming vodka and that dangerous interactions with medications weren’t an issue, this was a great idea. A charred veggie loaf is a small price to pay for a day that’s full of laughter instead of tension. Classic Prudie I am taking my son to visit my dear uncle and aunt later this year. My aunt prides herself on her cooking, and meals are a big part of socializing with them. My uncle has already told me how happy they are that we don’t have any “food issues” and that we can enjoy our meals together. (My cousin is vegan, and his spouse is gluten-free.) But here’s the thing: My aunt has served us spoiled meat before. Advice Dear Prudence Family
Help! When My Mother-in-Law Revealed Her Mashed Potatoes at Thanksgiving, I Had to Be Taken Outside.
Full Article
Original Source
Read the full article at Slate →KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.