Help! My Boyfriend’s Family Is Making a Ridiculous Demand for Thanksgiving Dinner. I Might Skip in Protest.

Help! My Boyfriend’s Family Is Making a Ridiculous Demand for Thanksgiving Dinner. I Might Skip in Protest.

Dear Prudence Photo illustration by Slate. Photos by Getty Images Plus. Our advice columnists have heard it all over the years—so we’re diving into the Dear Prudence archives to share classic Thanksgiving letters with our readers. Submit your own questions to Prudie here. Dear Prudence, For the past few years, I’ve celebrated Thanksgiving with my boyfriend’s family, which includes his ailing, elderly grandmother. But this year, his family is making a new demand. They’re demanding that we pay a cover—we’re each being charged $40 per person for a standard Thanksgiving dinner (not catered). Both my boyfriend and I are outraged. Don’t get me wrong. I’m not a freeloader. I’d be happy to cook a dish (or eight dishes!) and bring those to dinner. But paying $40 for a Turkey dinner with family? That’s ridiculous, especially since I’m a graduate student, and money is always tight. Unfortunately, my boyfriend has agreed to suck it up and cough up the $40. He hates that he has to pay a fee, but he refuses to stand up to his family. Meanwhile, he feels like he has to go to the dinner, because he doesn’t want to hurt his grandmother’s feelings by skipping out on Thanksgiving. My question is this: Should I suck it up, too, and pay this fee? And, aside from boycotting the meal, what can I do to communicate to the family that making money off of us at Thanksgiving is unacceptable? —Outraged Dear Outraged, I guess this year you can be grateful that your boyfriend’s family is not demanding you pay $80 a head for Thanksgiving. Putting in place a cover charge is not the way to engender good feelings. And unless his family is getting the meal catered, $40 a person sounds like a lot for white meat and sweet potato casserole. The obvious answer was to have everyone bring something so that no one’s cost was significant. On the other hand, maybe the burden of the meal usually falls on one family member, and he or she can’t handle it. In that case, there’s nothing wrong with people contributing so that no one goes broke for a family event. But you don’t do it by announcing a cover charge. Your boyfriend should explain that he’ll pay the full freight and something to cover your meal but that your finances are too tight to pay the listed price. I hope that means you still get to put whipped cream on your pumpkin pie. —Emily Yoffe From: Thanksgiving Misgivings. (Nov. 23rd, 2009.) Please keep questions short (<150 words), and don’t submit the same question to multiple columns. We are unable to edit or remove questions after publication. Use pseudonyms to maintain anonymity. Your submission may be used in other Slate advice columns and may be edited for publication. Dear Prudence, Whenever I host large dinner parties, only the women offer to help with dishes. I appreciate this, but when I take them up on their offer, there’s a gender imbalance in the kitchen I’m uncomfortable with. I sometimes end up refusing because I hate the optics of it: The men sit around drinking, while the women wash up. I’d like the men to help more, but I don’t want to ask any friends and guests to clean up if they haven’t offered. I’m hosting a Friendsgiving, and some people will bring their own dishes or booze, so I don’t even know if it’s appropriate to ask for help if they’ve contributed something to dinner. Is there a way around this cleanup issue, or am I forever doomed to do all the dishes by myself the next morning?—Thanksgiving Cleanup Anxiety Dear Thanksgiving Cleanup Anxiety, If you are hosting a holiday meal, you have every right to cheerfully conscript your friends and guests into whatever tasks need doing in order for them to get their free meal. That doesn’t mean you have to harangue everyone, but it’s perfectly appropriate for a host to say, “So lovely to see you. Thanks for coming. You’re on mashed-potato duty” to a guest, even if that guest has already brought you a bottle of wine. You’ve found—as is so often the case—that relying on an all-volunteer army usually means that the women notice you need help and offer to jump in, while the men seem to think dishes magically appear clean and tucked away in the cabinets the next day. I think the best way to correct this is to be brisk and upfront: Once the chatter has died down after the dessert course, grab a few plates and say, “Every time I host a dinner party, it’s always women who want to help me clean up afterward. Guys, I’d love it if a few of you would help me with the dishes this time. Are there any men who can help me out?” Hopefully—I’m assuming the guys you socialize with are more passively than actively sexist when it comes to kitchen cleanup—you’ll see a few chastened faces, followed by a hasty offer or two. But don’t be afraid to name a conspicuous dynamic, and don’t worry that you’re breaking some sort of hosting etiquette by pointing out the obvious and asking for a solution. —Danny M. Lavery From: The Men Never Help With Thanksgiving Cleanup. (Nov. 15th, 2018). Dear Prudence, Since my mother-in-law retired to Florida five years ago, I have been saddled with the traditional Thanksgiving gathering because our home has four bedrooms and a large kitchen. My five in-laws and their families all live in much smaller places. Their offers to “help” don’t involve much beyond bringing a pumpkin pie they picked up at the supermarket. The only exception was “Carissa,” my brother-in-law’s then-girlfriend and now new wife. Carissa is lovely, kind, and helpful. She’s also vegan. But she’s not preachy and was a professional chef. Seriously, her food is usually the first to go at potlucks and she even got my picky toddler nephew to eat tofu and veggies. They recently bought a new house and wanted to host Thanksgiving this year. Everyone was all for it, especially me. Then my brother-in-law said it would be all vegan and cooked by Carissa. So everyone lost their minds. They cried that it was tyranny and forcing an alternative lifestyle down their throats. They said it would ruin Thanksgiving. I told everyone to stuff it and that if they wanted a traditional Thanksgiving, they should stay home and cook themselves—my husband and I would be enjoying Carissa’s fantastic feast. My husband reluctantly backs me up but everyone else is whining and crying about the “ruined” holiday, especially my mother-in-law. I pointed out that we have had ham, prime rib, and even chicken instead of turkey before on the holiday, and no one cared. Carissa is a much better cook than me and alternating holidays is more than fair. Or everyone could meet up at a restaurant and pay their own way. Carissa and her husband privately thanked me but are worried about causing a family feud. I think they are just full of hot air. If they can go to rival schools and cheer rival football teams, they can eat delicious vegan food once every few years. Call it my line in the sand. What do we do next? —Tofu Turkey Day Please Dear Tofu Turkey, Frankly, I think this maybe should cause a family feud. Your family members are being enormous jerks, and you are correct that they should not have their requests accommodated; if they cannot navigate this situation for themselves, that is their problem. It sounds like Carissa is laid back enough that she would even be ok with it if someone else cooked and brought over a turkey dish themselves. But even if she keeps her home entirely meat-free, she is allowed to do that, and I am happy for you that you at least have one generous and talented in-law. How things proceed materially, though, is really up to Carissa and your brother-in-law. I wouldn’t blame them if they decided to call off their offer to host entirely. You can tell them you’re excited about Thanksgiving at their place, and that you will help them hold the line firmly against the rest of the family. You can let those family members know that if they are going to show up, they need to do so with joy in their hearts about eating Tofurky—or at least smiles pasted on their faces. In future years, I would also reconsider if you really want to keep hosting at the level you have been. You say your place works well because of the space you have; it may be sanity-saving to say that you are happy to offer your kitchen and dining room, but that you are not going to cook. People can bring dishes potluck style, or you can all split the cost of buying a turkey and sides from the super market. The current dynamic is just making you resentful, which isn’t good in the long run for anyone. —Shannon Palus From: Help! My Sister-in-Law Has Offered to Save the Family Thanksgiving. But Her One Condition Is Tearing the Family Apart. (Nov. 14th, 2024) Dear Prudence, My father had an affair on the side many years ago, and I found out about it. The affair had resulted in the birth of my half sister, Annie. Dad has successfully kept Annie a secret for 25 years. She’s now a young married mother, and we are somewhat close friends. While my mother knows of Annie, she does not know she’s my sister. My parents divorced when Annie was 5 for unrelated reasons, but my parents still get along quite well. I host Thanksgiving each year. Mom and Dad are coming. Annie just told me that she would like to be invited to Thanksgiving. While I have explained the situation to her, Annie says she’s tired of being kept a secret. I’m worried of not only causing discomfort for my dad, but humiliation for my mom if Annie decides to let the cat out of the bag. I have tried to tell Annie that we could have a get-together some other time, but she insists. What should I do? —Thanksgiving Big Reveal Dear Big Reveal, You surely want to avoid a pumpkin-pie-throwing contest on Thanksgiving. There’s something so despicable about trying to keep the existence of certain people a secret for the sake of other people. How hurtful this situation is to Annie and how humiliating it is for your mother. You’ve got little time to address this so that Thanksgiving is not a debacle. Tell your mother the truth, and set up a meeting for you, her, and Annie. Yes, it’s going to be a shock, but she’s been divorced from your father a long time and it’s well past the point that she should know you have a half sister. —E.Y. From: My Secret Sister. (Nov. 13th, 2012.) Dear Prudence, My husband and I will be hosting Thanksgiving for my family and his this year. The trouble is that my sister, “Erica,” and her husband have 5-year-old twins who are absolute tornadoes. Erica and my brother-in-law refuse to supervise or discipline them whenever they are guests in other people’s homes, and there have been more than a few instances where they have broken/stained/drawn on things. She expects everyone she visits with her kids in tow to have childproofed their home and/or have put away anything breakable before their arrival. My husband doesn’t want them here if they can’t behave, and I agree. I don’t think expecting my nephews to behave like they haven’t just wandered in from the wilderness is a big ask. The rest of my family, however, will never let it go if I don’t invite them. Can you provide a solution that doesn’t involve having to take turns with my husband in watching them while Erica and my BIL kick back and ignore them? —Double Trouble Dear Double Trouble, Your husband has the right idea. If you know having the twins over is going to lead to property damage, resentment, and stress, you shouldn’t have them over. This is a much better plan than hosting and spending the whole time resenting your sister and brother-in-law for failing to supervise their kids. The last thing you want is to put yourself in a situation in which you’re micromanaging someone else’s parenting. You’ll be full of rage and judgment, your sister will feel it, and it will damage your relationship. That’s the opposite of what’s supposed to happen on Thanksgiving! So here’s a script: “We’ve talked about it and we’ve realized our home is not child-friendly. [What you really mean is that it’s not child-friendly for totally unsupervised, high-energy, chaotic children, but you don’t have to say that explicitly.] So, can someone else step in to host? We’ll still bring all the food that I was planning to prepare, but I think we’ll all be more relaxed if we’re in an environment where Ted and Max can run freely without getting hurt or damaging anything.” If your family wants to give you a hard time over it, well, that’s their choice. When you know you’re being reasonable, the blowback doesn’t feel that bad. What would feel worse is if you hosted the holiday, and then they criticized you for being preoccupied with protecting your vases and throw pillows all day long—or for losing your cool and yelling, “Can someone control these feral children???” If you’d told me you really loved hosting and wanted to do it, I might have suggested clearing anything delicate out of at least one area, going to a thrift store and buying enough used toys to break one out every 30 minutes and keep them occupied, and/or hiring an older cousin or neighborhood teen (probably tough to arrange on Thanksgiving, but who knows?) to be on twin duty, with the mandate to “keep them alive and don’t let them break anything.” But I didn’t get that impression. So have the uncomfortable conversation before Thanksgiving—not when you’re taking a turkey out of the oven and a child is throwing a football at your TV screen—and make a plan that lets you enjoy the holiday. —Jenée Desmond-Harris From: Help! It’s Our Turn to Host Thanksgiving. We’re Dreading Two Terrible Little Guests. (Oct. 20th, 2025.) Dear Prudence, My 20-something son brought a college friend home for Thanksgiving who was a very polite guest: Before leaving, he stripped all the sheets and left them on the bed with his used towel. This caused a guilty realization that I’ve never coached MY kids to do that! But I also felt it was a bit like peeking at someone’s underwear. What if the sheets had a rip in the corner or the mattress had a stain? It felt slightly invasive and potentially embarrassing (maybe not this time, but it could be). Is it weird that I kind of wished he hadn’t? Is it common etiquette to strip beds and are we rude for not doing so? I’ve had guests ask about stripping beds and I always say “don’t worry, just leave it!” My own track record as a guest is 50/50: sometimes I ask/strip and other times I just slink away. And while we’re at it, what should guests do with wet towels? I get a little nutty when kids and guests drape them on doors, furniture, or other surfaces that can get damaged by moisture. How best to communicate about these things as a host or guest? What are the protocols?! —To Strip or Not to Strip Dear Strip, A real, old-fashioned etiquette question. I love it. When it comes to what to do with bedding, I think the answer is to ask first. Or rather, announce and be open to being talked out of it: “Should I put the sheets from the bed in the hamper or throw them in the washing machine? Warm or hot?” And give the host a chance to say, “No, please leave them.” At this point, insisting would be wrong because they truly might not feel like dealing with the laundry right away. If that’s the case or if, God forbid, they don’t plan to change the bedding between guests, you don’t want to make their life harder—that would be the opposite of politeness.Wet towels should get the same treatment and if the host says “Don’t worry about it,” fold them neatly and place them on the edge of the bathtub. To avoid having them draped throughout your own home, simply say to guests: “Here are some clean towels for whenever you want to shower—and there’s a hook in the bathroom where you can hang them when you’re done.” —J.D.H. From: Dear Prudence Live Chat. (Nov. 28th, 2022) Classic Prudie I am taking my son to visit my dear uncle and aunt later this year. My aunt prides herself on her cooking, and meals are a big part of socializing with them. My uncle has already told me how happy they are that we don’t have any “food issues” and that we can enjoy our meals together. (My cousin is vegan, and his spouse is gluten-free.) But here’s the thing: My aunt has served us spoiled meat before. Never miss new Slate Advice columns Get the latest from Prudie and our columnists in your inbox each weekday, plus special bonus letters on Saturdays. Advice Dating and Relationships Family

Original Source

Read the full article at Slate →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.