Glut of paddy, but India imports pulses: Here's why farmers aren't switching crops

Glut of paddy, but India imports pulses: Here's why farmers aren't switching crops

A farmer, Prime Minister Narendra Modi said, will not accept an idea simply because someone delivers a long speech about it. He will believe it only when he sees it for himself. Making this point at the India Today Group's Kisan Tak Bharat Agriculture Conference, PM Modi pointed to how farmers often follow the practices of their neighbours, including how much fertiliser they use. He also said that farming was no longer about filling our granaries.PM Modi was talking about crop diversification and the need for smart farming by changing agricultural practices.But changing farming practices is not just about persuading farmers to try something new. It also requires changing the policies, incentives and market structures that influence what they grow and how much they earn. Unless farmers have a reason to move away from familiar crops and practices, calls for change may not be enough.That larger question ran through the discussions at the two-day Kisan Tak Bharat Agriculture Conference. In one of the panel discussions on the first day of the conference (November 11), agricultural economist Ashok Gulati questioned why India continued to import millions of tonnes of pulses despite having surplus rice stocks. He was questioning why Indian farmers couldn't grow more pulses in the same fields which are now devoted to paddy. Gulati also questioned the economics of using surplus rice to produce ethanol. His argument was that India's agricultural priorities and incentives need a rethink if farmers are to diversify crops and earn better returns."One challenge with our farmer brothers and sisters is that until they see something with their own eyes, they do not accept it. No matter how many long speeches are delivered, farmers do not simply accept something. They believe only after seeing it," Modi said in his plenary address at the conference on November 12. He illustrated this by referring to farmers following what their neighbours did. If a neighbour used two bags of fertiliser, another farmer would use two bags as well; if the neighbour used four, he would follow suit. Modi called on progressive farmers and others to help change this mindset and encourage the adoption of natural farming.While Modi focussed on the need to demonstrate the benefits of new farming practices, Gulati's remarks, a day earlier, highlighted another part of the challenge — the economic and policy framework within which farmers make their choices.Gulati shared the panel with Niti Aayog Vice Chairman Ashok Lahiri, agricultural economist Bina Agarwal and Nabard Chairman Shaji Krishnan. The discussion focused on the challenges facing Indian agriculture and ways to improve farmers' earnings.WHY INDIA IMPORTS PULSES DESPITE A RICE GLUTGulati cited India's surplus rice stocks alongside its dependence on imports of pulses as an example of the need to rethink agricultural incentives.He questioned why India continued to import five to six million tonnes of pulses every year despite having surplus rice stocks and being the world's largest rice producer and exporter. He argued that agricultural policies had created an incentive structure favouring rice and sugarcane, with a large share of fertiliser subsidies going to these crops.Pulses, on the other hand, are nitrogen-fixing crops and require less fertiliser support. Gulati suggested offering farmers growing pulses an incentive of Rs 35,000 per hectare. He said this could help save on power and fertiliser subsidies and make India self-reliant on pulses within three years."The point is that as long as the policy is not right, you will not see the right results," he said.Gulati also questioned the government's decision to use surplus rice for ethanol production, arguing that it made little economic sense when the country was already dealing with excess stocks. He said producing a litre of ethanol required 2.5-3 kg of rice, which cost the Food Corporation of India around Rs 150, while the ethanol was priced at about Rs 70."You are putting rice worth Rs 150 into making ethanol that costs Rs 70," he said.THE MISSING LINK IN INDIA'S AGRICULTURAL VALUE CHAINGulati also pointed out that India might be producing more food than ever, but higher production does not always translate into higher incomes for farmers. When tomatoes are in surplus, prices crash. And unlike dairy farmers, who benefit from cooperatives such as Amul, vegetable growers often receive only a small share of what consumers pay.Currently a Distinguished Professor at the Indian Council for Research on International Economic Relations (ICRIER), Gulati pointed to the sharp fluctuations in tomato prices, which can fall to Rs 10 per kg during periods of excess production and rise to Rs 50-60 per kg when supplies tighten.Unlike pulses and edible oils, which can be stored for longer periods, tomatoes and other perishable produce require a different approach, he said."At least 25-30% of perishable commodities need to be processed. Only then will the value chain stabilise," Gulati said. The Kisan Tak Bharat Agriculture Conference panel brought together economists Ashok Gulati, Ashok Lahiri, Bina Agarwal, and Nabard chairman Shaji Krishnan. (Image: Anand Singh) He observed that food processing remains underdeveloped in India, where consumers largely prefer fresh tomatoes despite the availability of processed alternatives such as tomato paste in other countries. Greater processing capacity, he argued, would help absorb surplus production and prevent farmers from suffering steep price crashes.Gulati also highlighted the unequal distribution of consumer spending between farmers and the rest of the supply chain. For vegetables and fruits, farmers typically receive only a third or a quarter of what consumers pay. Milk, however, offers a successful alternative.Citing Amul, Gulati said that 75-80% of the price paid by consumers reaches farmers because of the cooperative structure built around milk procurement and marketing."That is one experiment that has worked in this country," he said, arguing that similar institutional arrangements were needed for other agricultural commodities.WHY INDIA NEEDS ANOTHER VERGHESE KURIENGulati recalled that the government had earlier been advised to establish a price-stabilisation mechanism for TOP (tomato, onion and potato), similar to the cooperative-led transformation of India's dairy sector."The Finance Minister had approved an allocation of Rs 500 crore for TOP," he said. However, Gulati questioned how the programme was implemented, saying the money was handed over to the food-processing industry without adequate clarity about who was responsible for executing it."Nobody knew who was doing what. If you want to fix this, you need a person like Kurien," he said, invoking Verghese Kurien, the architect of India's White Revolution and the cooperative movement behind Amul.Gulati also questioned the limited impact of Operation Green, which replaced Operation TOP."Operation TOP was changed to Operation Green, but nothing much happened. What was the price of tomatoes recently? It is still volatile," he said.India, he argued, needs to identify a capable leader and build an institution dedicated to streamlining the value chain. This would require sustained investment and patience."You will have to select such a person and create such an institution. It will take five to seven years and money. Only then can you streamline the system," he said.Gulati stressed that agricultural commodities cannot all be treated alike. While rice and wheat have relatively established procurement and storage mechanisms, fruits and vegetables require specialised arrangements because of their perishable nature.THE OTHER CHALLENGES HOLDING INDIAN AGRICULTURE BACKGulati was not alone in pointing to the need for a rethink. The other panellists, too, highlighted gaps in the way Indian agriculture is organised, supported and linked to markets.Niti Aayog Vice Chairman Ashok Lahiri pointed to a more fundamental problem — the disproportionate number of people dependent on agriculture compared with the sector's contribution to the economy. He said this was a key reason behind low farm incomes."At present, around 46% of our labour force is in agriculture, while agriculture contributes only around 16–17% to GDP. If half the people are working in a sector that produces only 16–17% of the output, productivity will be low and incomes will be low," he said.Improving productivity is one part of the answer. But for small farmers, particularly women, the challenge also lies in the scale of their operations and their ability to access markets. Agricultural economist Bina Agarwal highlighted the importance of collective farming, citing examples from Kerala where groups of women had pooled resources, arranged labour and entered into contracts with buyers to improve their returns."For fruits and vegetables, I think there is a different approach to the value chain, and we cannot use a single-point approach," Agarwal said. She cautioned against treating farmer producer organisations as merely a way to aggregate produce."Farmer Producer Organisations (FPOs) are not just about production. The small plots of land have to be pooled. The basic problems of agriculture, such as climate change, deteriorating land quality and water scarcity, have to be addressed first," she said.Agarwal's emphasis on collective action also points to the role institutions can play in connecting farmers to markets. Nabard Chairman Shaji Krishnan spoke about efforts to strengthen cooperatives and build district-level value chains."Nabard is working with the Ministry of Cooperation to establish two lakh multipurpose cooperative societies. These will not be credit cooperatives, but activity-based cooperatives," he said.He added that Nabard was also strengthening around 75,000 existing cooperatives, which have nearly 13 crore farmer members.The aim, Krishnan said, is to make these institutions part of a wider, digitally connected market network. "Our target is to develop one value chain in each of the country's 700 districts, and these will be digitised value chains," he said. He explained that digital systems would help track the movement of produce and money, prevent cash leakages and make it easier for banks to finance farmers and businesses.Lahiri also spoke about the marketing bottlenecks farmers face after harvesting in the context of not diversifying their crops.He said even when crops such as pulses and edible oils can be stored, farmers often need money immediately and are forced to sell. He suggested developing a warehouse receipt system, under which farmers could deposit their produce in a warehouse, receive a receipt and use it to access payment without having to sell immediately.The discussions at the Kisan Tak conference returned to a larger question — despite India's growing agricultural output and its position as a major global producer and exporter of several commodities, why have farmers' incomes not risen at the same pace?Modi's appeal to farmers to adopt natural farming and Gulati's arguments on crop diversification, processing and market access point to different parts of the same challenge. Increasing production alone will not solve the farmers' income problem. Without effective policies, storage, processing, marketing and institutional support, higher production can also lead to falling prices and mounting losses for cultivators.- Ends

Original Source

Read the full article at Indiatoday →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.