Former US Palestine Action activists risk contempt of court over refusal to testify before Grand Jury

Former US Palestine Action activists risk contempt of court over refusal to testify before Grand Jury

Two former Palestine Action activists in the US are risking imprisonment by refusing to testify before a federal grand jury in New Hampshire on Wednesday. Sophie Ross and Bridget Shergalis risk up to 18 months in prison for contempt of court for defying grand jury subpoenas issued by the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI). The FBI has not disclosed any details of the investigation, nor named a defendant. Reports suggest that it is likely that the target of the investigation is Fergie Chambers, a millionaire left-wing donor currently facing extradition to the US from Spain, where he is detained pending a decision by a Spanish court. The extradition order is in part based on allegations that Chambers helped fund a protest in November 2023 targeting Israeli weapons manufacturer Elbit Systems in Merrimack, New Hampshire. New MEE newsletter: Jerusalem Dispatch Sign up to get the latest insights and analysis on Israel-Palestine, alongside Turkey Unpacked and other MEE newsletters Ross and Shergalis also participated in the action and were sentenced to 60 days in prison for misdemeanour convictions. Speaking at a press conference on Tuesday, Shergalis referred to Israel's actions in Gaza when she described the pair’s refusal to testify as “an effort to not incriminate ourselves or anyone who believes it is their moral obligation to stop genocide”. 'We know that that information can be used against us even later on if we do decide to testify' – Sophie Ross, former Palestine Action activist She added that she and Ross would give their names to the court and assert their fifth amendment rights – the right to remain silent – and refuse to answer any questions by the prosecutor. “It's something that we saw as our responsibility to refuse to testify, not only to protect whoever's being targeted by the grand jury, but also anyone else in our networks,” Ross told Middle East Eye. She explained that grand juries, a legal proceeding to determine whether there is enough evidence to indict a suspect, are empowered to ask a broad array of questions that are not strictly related to the investigation. “We know that that information can be used against us even later on if we do decide to testify,” Ross said. The Intercept reported earlier this month, citing Chambers’ Spanish legal team, that the extradition case against him is based on a criminal complaint signed by a single FBI agent rather than an indictment, which is highly unusual. The report cites a summary of the complaint, which states that: “If Chambers’ extradition to the US is granted, another charging document called an indictment will be sought from a federal grand jury.” MEE understands that Ross and Shergalis refused to answer prosecutors’ questions at the Grand Jury session on Wednesday, and that they were informed they were free to go. They expect to hear from the prosecutor. MEE contacted the Department of Justice, but it declined to comment. A ‘secretive, one-sided proceeding’ Federal grand juries – panels of between 16 and 23 citizens – are held to determine whether there is probable cause that a federal crime has been committed. Sessions are held behind closed doors, with no presiding judge, and the subject of the investigation and their legal representation are absent. 'We were unable to speak to each other at all to coordinate. We could not show a united front' – Bridget Shergalis, former Palestine Action activist “It is a very secretive, one-sided proceeding,” defence attorney Kira Kelley, who represents Shergalis and Ross, told MEE. “Oftentimes, the person that is being investigated doesn't even know that the grand jury is happening. In fact, most times they're not aware.” The jury is handed sweeping investigative powers and can issue subpoenas to compel testimony. Witnesses cannot have lawyers in attendance. “There's no defence attorneys. There's nobody who is in the room able to stick up for the rights of witnesses, or to represent the interests of the grand jurors themselves,” Kelley said, adding that evidence presented is one-sided and highly susceptible to manipulation. An ongoing case involving anti-ICE protesters known as the "Broadview Six" saw allegations of prosecutorial misconduct, as transcripts of grand jury proceedings suggested that prosecutors improperly tried to influence jurors. If witnesses refuse to testify, they can be held in contempt of court and imprisoned for the duration of the grand jury proceedings, for up to 18 months. The measure is designed to coerce testimony, as the law bars punitive custodial sentences for civil contempt. Fergie Chambers tells Spanish court Gaza is 'moral question of our time' Read More » Kelley said that, given the breadth and ferocity of the Trump administration’s crackdown on political protest, fifth amendment rights – which can be invoked – “should become broader, as the body of politics and activities being criminalised also grows in the United States”. In 2025, Trump issued the National Security Presidential Memorandum-7, which effectively recast anti-fascism as “domestic terrorism” and directs the FBI to investigate “violent and terroristic activities” associated with “anti-fascism”. In response, activists have launched the NSPM-7 Defendants union, which will offer access to legal clinics, media training and support for people facing prosecution under the memorandum. Central to the project is the signing of a pledge that commits activists to not cooperating with law enforcement, “collective legal strategies”, and to “not denounce others in the movement”. Ross, Shergalis and Chambers have all signed the pledge. ‘Just a given’ Shergalis and Ross said their decision to defy their subpoenas was rooted in their own experiences of being subject to a gruelling year-long investigation into their participation in the 2023 Elbit protest, for which they were initially facing felony charges that carried potential decades-long custodial sentences. The pair said they were issued non-association orders and were separately offered several cooperating deals throughout the ordeal. Palestine Action ban appeal enters closed proceedings at UK Supreme Court Read More » “We were unable to speak to each other at all to coordinate. We could not show a united front,” Shergalis told the press conference, adding that the order meant the defendants could not tell one another about the deals they were being offered. Despite this, she said, they both refused the deals. Shergalis linked this decision to the 60-day sentences they were handed for misdemeanour charges. For both women, the lessons learned from this experience meant that their decision to refuse to testify on Wednesday was a no-brainer. “It was not even a decision. It was something that we didn't really have to decide to do it. It was just a given,” Ross said.

Original Source

Read the full article at Middleeasteye →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.