Flights Grounded: Who Is to Blame?

Flights Grounded: Who Is to Blame?

AdvertisementSKIP ADVERTISEMENTlettersReaders cite mismanagement and ill-advised cuts by the Trump administration for the air travel breakdown on Friday.Nov. 16, 2026, 1:32 p.m. ETDespite widespread cancellations across the country on Friday, some flights were able to depart.Credit...Justin L. Stewart for The New York TimesTo the Editor:Re “Breakdown After Breakdown, Aging Air Traffic System Frays” (front page, Nov. 15):I’ve spent over 25 years in information technology with IBM, H.P. and Compaq, planning and implementing mission-critical cutovers for Fortune 25 clients, including major brokerages, banks and the New York Stock Exchange.Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy attributes the Federal Aviation Administration’s outage to a router overload during a copper-to-fiber upgrade at a remote facility, and says it is not yet known whether the equipment or the installation was at fault. Your article describes a contractor upgrading air traffic control equipment, a broader job than that account suggests.Either way, a change at one remote site should not be able to cascade across a national network. Systems like this are built with testing and redundancy precisely to prevent that. Hidden dependencies can defeat even good planning, but that raises its own questions.The contractor, L3Harris, has worked for the F.A.A. for decades and should know this infrastructure well. What was the failover plan? Did the agency review it? And why can’t the cause be identified quickly, when faulty equipment usually shows itself during a cutover?If the account is accurate, it points to serious failures in planning and oversight. If not, the public deserves a fuller explanation.Brian O’MalleyWestport, Conn.To the Editor:Officials are blaming an aging air traffic control system for Friday’s disruption. Professional football teams spend billions to build new stadiums (often with taxpayer dollars) even though they have perfectly fine ones already.But to spend a comparable sum to modernize and upgrade a system so critical to the nation’s and the world’s economy isn’t all that important?No one is likely to die if a new stadium isn’t built; but to venture into the crowded skies in a thin aluminum tube guided by a jerry-built system will someday kill hundreds or even thousands.Orin HollanderJamison, Pa.To the Editor:The shutdown of the nation’s air travel system on Friday was a warning not only about how technology can fail, but also about how leaders can fail. In the mid-20th century, when the Eisenhower Interstate System was built, government leaders funded highways while failing to subsidize railway systems. Had the United States retained its world-class intercity and local rail systems, Americans would now have another significant transportation option beyond highways and runways.As it is now, we are left with cars, trucks and planes that cost increasingly more in fuel prices, longer door-to-door travel times and more extensive environmental impacts: Both highway and air travel consume more land and energy, and also emit more climate-changing carbon emissions than rail travel.Meanwhile, other developed nations enjoy high-speed intercity rail that is efficient, inexpensive and safe. Is this America at its greatest?Michael WrightGlen Rock, Pa.To the Editor:The Trump administration’s transportation secretary, Sean Duffy, raised the notion that there is partisanship in the funding of the Federal Aviation Administration, but he ignores the Trumpian elephant in the room.Two years ago Congress passed and President Joe Biden signed into law the bipartisan F.A.A. Reauthorization Act of 2024, covering everything Mr. Duffy is asking for and more: $105 billion over five years. What happened?Since Joe Biden signed it, Donald Trump gutted it. No reporting or public discussion on F.A.A. funding is complete without acknowledging this.Bill HarderKirkland, Wash.To the Editor:Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy has estimated the cost of $50 billion to properly upgrade the entire air traffic control system nationwide. This would benefit millions of Americans and visitors who rely on safe air travel in our country.Contrast these costs with the cost of the war in Iran, estimated at close to $50 billion by the end of 2026. This war has benefited no Americans, resulting in inflation and death of 23 service members. Let’s end the senseless military spending and invest on our critical infrastructure needs.Stephen KurtzHollywood, Fla.To the Editor:I’m an old lady, but I’m not dumb. Seems that Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy is laying this on us to get the money to fix it. This whole episode is suspect.How can this country help create a trillionaire but have no money for safe infrastructure? Are we a poor country with a few rich people or are we a rich country run by fools?Mr. Duffy stands there and says President Trump has insisted time and again the air systems be upgraded. I haven’t heard that. His priorities seem to be tearing down things so he can build things. Lately, he’s been focused on an arch.But now we have a huge emergency, and it’s on Congress to come up with the money and Mr. Trump to build a brand-new air traffic system.Good luck, fourth estate, yours is not an enviable position, but an important one. Thank you in advance for the work you will be doing to investigate all responsible parties in this fiasco.Donna MondayZionsville, Ind.To the Editor:Perhaps some of the money for the ballroom or the grandiose proposed arch can be diverted to help to upgrade the vastly outdated air traffic control communications system.Just a thought.Joanne RosenParamus, N.J.Related ContentAdvertisementSKIP ADVERTISEMENT

Original Source

Read the full article at Nytimes →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.