Five EU nations strike Rwanda deportation deal, critics cry foul

Sending migrants to Rwanda is back on the table. After Britain’s scheme failed, five European nations want to send ineligible asylum-seekers to the small African nation. (CN) — Five European Union nations, including Germany and Greece, teamed up Monday to send rejected asylum-seekers to Rwanda, a move panned by critics as a deeply flawed and inhumane scheme.Calling themselves the “group of implementers,” Germany, the Netherlands, Austria, Greece and Denmark said they planned to experiment with deporting up to 200 people to Rwanda next year.Other EU countries may join the scheme, which has the support of EU institutions. The plan mirrors a previously botched project by the British government to send asylum-seekers to Rwanda for processing. Britain spent nearly $1 billion on its efforts. On Monday, the five countries did not provide cost estimates for their scheme.However, unlike the British plan, only migrants ineligible for asylum and unable or unwilling to be sent back to their home countries would be transferred to Rwanda, officials from the five countries said.“For me, today marks a crucial step toward a new migration system,” Danish Prime Minister Mette Frederiksen said at a news conference in Vienna where the agreement with Rwanda was announced. “I think this will be a game-changer.”Frederiksen, leader of Denmark’s center-left Social Democrats, said the plan was the culmination of a yearslong push to set up deportation centers outside the EU and create a more “orderly” asylum and migration system.At its core, the scheme aims to deter migrants from seeking entry to the EU, reflecting both the EU’s increasingly tough stance on immigration and the growing influence of far-right politics.In June, far-right politicians provided key votes to push the EU into adopting rules allowing deportation centers — or so-called “return hubs” — to be set up outside the bloc.Still, the plan faces legal challenges.Human rights groups have blasted the scheme as a cruel and dangerous precedent in which rejected asylum-seekers are sent into a legal “black hole” where their safety and rights cannot be guaranteed.Critics also point to Rwanda’s very poor human rights record and accuse the EU of turning a blind eye to Kigali’s support for the M23 rebel group, which has occupied eastern parts of the Democratic Republic of Congo.Concerns over Rwandan President Paul Kagame’s regime were heightened last month when one of his fiercest critics, exiled former Rwandan army officer Robert Kabera, was found decapitated in Uganda.“By providing this service, Kagame hopes to win EU silence to the annexing of eastern DRC,” said Michela Wrong, a British expert on Rwanda and author, on social media. In an interview with a Danish newspaper, she linked Kabera’s killing to his criticism of Kagame. She did not return a message seeking comment.Critics contend that sending migrants to Rwanda violates EU human rights laws because deportees may face ill treatment, torture and getting transferred from Rwanda onto countries where they face persecution.In a statement, the German government said Rwanda was “a reliable and responsible partner in addressing the global challenges related to migration.”Berlin added the scheme would uphold EU law, Rwandan law and international law, including international human rights law.Florian Trauner, a political scientist and expert on migration policy at the Brussels School of Governance, said the EU has sought to “create an explicit legal basis for EU return hubs.”“This should make the hub compatible with EU law in principle,” he said in an email.He noted the European Court of Justice, the EU’s high court, appears inclined to not “entirely reject this type of scheme.”In April, an advocate general at the Court of Justice found Italy’s separate scheme to send asylum-seekers to detention centers in Albania did not fall foul of EU laws as long as migrants sent to the Balkans nation were are afforded the usual rights asylum-seekers are entitled to, such as access to lawyers, translators and medical care.Trauner said European courts could be expected to demand similar assurances for migrants sent to Rwanda.He said Rwanda and the five EU countries see benefits in the deal.“The EU may have hoped for a country with a better human rights record but the political priority has been to get a deterrence tool,” Trauner said.He added the rising popularity of far-right parties put pressure on the five governments to act.As for Rwanda, he said it “hopes to get more international legitimacy” and to be paid for taking in migrants.“The risk for the EU is to create expectations that are difficult to meet,” Trauner said.He said the Rwanda plan may prove very expensive and difficult to uphold legally.Courthouse News reporter Cain Burdeau is based in the European Union.Subscribe to our free newslettersOur weekly newsletter Closing Arguments offers the latest about ongoing trials, major litigation and rulings in courthouses around the U.S. and the world, while the monthly Under the Lights dishes the legal dirt from Hollywood, sports, Big Tech and the arts.Additional Reads

Original Source

Read the full article at Courthousenews →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.