A Canadian couple who built a wooden deck beside their holiday cabin without obtaining the required written permission have won a legal battle to keep the structure after a British Columbia appeals court upheld a $5,000 damages award instead of ordering its removal. The November 13 decision in Valley’s Edge Park Ltd. v. Holden followed a dispute between the homeowners and the company overseeing their recreational resort. The British Columbia Court of Appeal’s judgment, its official case summary and reporting by Canadian Legal News provide details of the ruling. Moira and Denis Holden owned a property at Valley’s Edge Resort in Edgewater, British Columbia, where residents are required to seek approval before making certain improvements to their lots. The requirement is part of a registered building scheme that gives the resort administrator authority over construction and alterations. The couple had previously obtained permission for improvements to another property they owned at the resort. However, their relationship with the company’s president later deteriorated, and a disagreement over the proposed deck eventually reached the courts.How the dispute beganIn 2022, the Holdens approached the elected president of the strata council with their plans for the deck. They were informed that the council did not have the authority to approve the construction. Although the plans were subsequently forwarded to the company, the couple had already completed the work by then.Valley’s Edge Park Ltd. gave them 30 days to either dismantle the deck or submit a complete application for approval. The couple responded with a hand-drawn diagram, but the company’s president rejected it, describing the submission as incomplete.The matter became contentious when the company sought to have the structure removed. However, the judge who first heard the dispute found that the company’s president had not clearly explained what information was missing from the application or what changes would make it acceptable. The court also considered the appearance and impact of the deck. It found that the structure was consistent with the cabin and the surrounding resort environment. There was also no evidence that it prevented neighbouring property owners from accessing or enjoying their own lots.Why the court allowed the deck to remainThe resort administrator argued that allowing the structure to remain would set an undesirable precedent, potentially encouraging other property owners to construct unauthorised improvements before seeking permission.The court acknowledged that the Holdens had knowingly proceeded without the necessary approval. However, it also considered whether demolishing the deck was necessary to protect the interests of the wider resort community. An injunction, which is a court order requiring someone to stop or take a particular action, is generally the preferred remedy for breaches of registered building schemes. However, the court can consider the circumstances of an individual case before deciding whether removal is appropriate.The judge concluded that financial compensation would be sufficient in this instance. Valley’s Edge had sought $20,000 in damages, while the couple maintained that they had spent approximately $1,800 building the deck themselves and argued that only nominal compensation should be awarded. The court ultimately ordered the Holdens to pay $5,000. Neither side challenged the amount in the subsequent appeal.Both sides lose their appealsValley’s Edge Park Ltd. challenged the decision, arguing that the judge should have ordered the deck’s removal and that the company was entitled to recover its entire legal bill from the homeowners. The Holdens also challenged the original costs order, arguing that they should not have been required to pay the resort administrator’s legal expenses.However, the British Columbia Court of Appeal dismissed both appeals in its November 13 ruling. Justice DeWitt-Van Oosten, writing for a unanimous panel, found no reason to overturn the lower court’s decision to award damages instead of ordering an injunction. The judges also rejected the company’s argument that the building scheme automatically entitled it to recover all its legal fees. Although the agreement allowed the administrator to recover expenses associated with work undertaken to correct a breach, its wording was not sufficiently clear to make homeowners responsible for every legal expense incurred while pursuing an injunction.The original costs award in favour of Valley’s Edge was therefore upheld, as the company had successfully established that the couple breached the building scheme and obtained damages. For the appeal proceedings, the court ordered each side to pay the other’s costs for defending the respective appeal. Both amounts will be assessed at Scale A, reflecting the court’s view that the parties had made the proceedings more complicated than necessary.The ruling leaves the deck standing, but it also reinforces that property owners cannot simply disregard construction approval requirements. Even when demolition is considered unnecessary, building without permission can still carry financial consequences.
Fired over marijuana smell near car, Connecticut woman's $62,530 award upheld
Full Article
Original Source
Read the full article at Timesofindia →KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.