A unanimous panel said the lower court lacked a sufficiently detailed record to bar enforcement of the law against nine major platforms.(CN) — A Fifth Circuit panel on Thursday lifted a second preliminary injunction blocking Mississippi’s Walker Montgomery Protecting Children Online Act, an age-verification and parental-consent law for social media platforms.U.S. Circuit Judge Cory T. Wilson, writing for a unanimous three-judge panel, found internet advocacy group NetChoice failed to produce a sufficiently detailed record showing the statute is unconstitutional as applied to its members’ specific sites and features.The panel determined the lower court erred by enjoining the law in its entirety as to nine NetChoice member platforms — including Facebook, Instagram, YouTube, X, Reddit, Snapchat, Pinterest, Nextdoor, and Dreamwidth — without conducting the intensive and specific analysis required for as-applied relief.“Because the district court did not perform the fact-intensive analysis necessary to substantiate why the Act is unconstitutional as applied to each member website, and because it did not tailor injunctive relief to each member website, it erred in issuing the second injunction,” Wilson, a Donald Trump appointee, wrote for the panel.The panel determined general declarations claiming the law’s requirements would be burdensome fell well short of the particularized evidence needed to craft a narrowly tailored injunction.“Simply put, the district court had too little to go on in entering its second injunction — which included a complete bar on enforcement of the act as to nine covered platforms operated by NetChoice’s members. Because the injunction was not narrowly tailored as applied to those sites, the relief entered by the district court was at least premature, if not unwarranted.”The panel remanded the case for further proceedings consistent with the Supreme Court’s decision in Moody v. NetChoice and its own prior guidance in the case. Whether the statute ultimately violates the First Amendment remains an open question.Mississippi enacted the law in 2024 after the suicide of 16-year-old Walker Montgomery, who was targeted in an online sextortion scheme. The act requires covered interactive platforms to make commercially reasonable efforts to verify users’ ages, obtain parental consent before allowing known minors to hold accounts, and implement strategies to mitigate listed harms to those minors. It also limits collection and use of minors’ data and authorizes enforcement by parents or the attorney general.“The Walker Montgomery Protecting Children Online Act asks social media companies to make reasonable changes that a responsible corporate citizen should embrace,” Mississippi Attorney General Lynn Fitch wrote in a social media post Thursday. “Today, the Fifth Circuit ruled unanimously against NetChoice’s challenge to this law, delivering an important victory in our fight to keep our children safe in the digital age.”NetChoice, a trade association representing major internet companies, first secured a facial preliminary injunction from a Mississippi federal judge in 2024. After the Supreme Court decided Moody, the Fifth Circuit vacated that order and remanded. On remand, NetChoice shifted to an as-applied challenge; the lower court again blocked the law as to the nine platforms.The Fifth Circuit stayed that second injunction pending appeal, and the Supreme Court left the stay in place.“We’re disappointed in today’s decision, but nothing in the ruling holds that [the act] is constitutional,” Paul Taske, director of the NetChoice Litigation Center, said in a news release. “Justice Kavanaugh has already said NetChoice is likely to win on the merits, and we are assessing all options to best preserve access to lawful speech in Mississippi. Today’s ruling is about procedure and paperwork, not about whether the state can force its residents to hand over their IDs before they are allowed to access speech online.”The Mississippi case is one of a series of NetChoice challenges to state laws requiring age checks or parental consent for minors on social media. Outcomes have been mixed. Courts have blocked similar measures in several states, but appellate panels have grown more skeptical of broad injunctions after Moody. The 11th Circuit recently vacated an injunction against Georgia’s comparable law, and a divided Sixth Circuit revived Ohio’s parental-consent requirement, among other developments.Subscribe to our free newslettersOur weekly newsletter Closing Arguments offers the latest about ongoing trials, major litigation and rulings in courthouses around the U.S. and the world, while the monthly Under the Lights dishes the legal dirt from Hollywood, sports, Big Tech and the arts.Additional Reads
Fifth Circuit lifts block on Mississippi social media age-check law
Full Article
Original Source
Read the full article at Courthousenews →KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.