Family buys $1.41m cottage, finds ban on expansion; wins $1.3m from broker

Family buys $1.41m cottage, finds ban on expansion; wins $1.3m from broker

Following a multi-year Norfolk Superior Court battle, a jury awarded the buyers $1,280,886 in damages.Squeezing eight family members into a 1,200-square-foot cottage sounds like the setup for a cramped summer sitcom, yet for a Connecticut couple, that coastal squeeze turned into a five-year courtroom drama. Hoping to carve out a spacious retreat on one of America’s priciest islands, Dr. Mary Murray and attorney Jeffrey Ment bought a modest Nantucket house on the promise that they could double its footprint, only to discover too late that legal restrictions froze the home’s size permanently.Promises of expansion on Polpis RoadAccording to Realtor, Murray, an obstetrician, and Ment, a lawyer, reside in Westport, Connecticut, and regularly vacationed on Nantucket with their six children. After previously relying on William Raveis Nantucket agent Melanie Gowen to secure island rentals, the couple worked with her in 2020 to purchase a two-bedroom cottage at 151 Polpis Road for $1.41 million, though Nantucket Current noted the sale price at $1.45 million. With Nantucket’s median listing price hovering near $6 million, the buyers viewed the property as a rare foothold in an ultracompetitive market, Realtor report added.Because a two-bedroom layout could not accommodate a family of eight, Murray and Ment sought assurances before closing. Gowen, who also presented herself as possessing interior design and property development experience on the island, allegedly informed the buyers that she had visited the local building department and confirmed the undersized structure could be doubled in size, Realtor report noted. She even sketched out a potential addition, shared a video of the planned build, and suggested in writing that local bedroom limits could be bypassed by labeling new rooms as dens or living spaces, according to Realtor.A deed restriction halts plans and sparks a lawsuitWhen the couple contacted town officials in early 2021 regarding septic upgrades and construction, they learned that zoning rules and a strict deed restriction prohibited adding even a single square foot to the house, according to both outlets. After Gowen’s colleague Kenny Hilbig confirmed the deed restriction and unsuccessful attempts were made to arrange a property trade or a brokerage bridge loan, representatives indicated the couple would need to file suit to recover losses from the firm directly, Realtor reported.In June 2021, Murray and Ment filed an action in Norfolk Superior Court alleging negligence, breach of fiduciary duty, misrepresentation, and violations of the Massachusetts Consumer Protection Act, known as Chapter 93A, Realtor noted. Following a multi-year legal battle, a jury ruled in the buyers’ favor in January 2026, awarding $1,280,886 in damages—a figure that included over $867,000 in doubled damages alongside interest and legal expenses, Nantucket Current reported. The jury attributed 65 percent of the negligence to Gowen and 35 percent to the buyers, according to Nantucket Current. Superior Court Judge Ira Gant upheld the verdict and issued an amended judgment in June 2026, both outlets noted.Defense arguments and the financial falloutWilliam Raveis Nantucket and Gowen have denied wrongdoing and filed a notice of appeal in October 2026, while interest continues accruing on the nearly $1.3 million judgment, Nantucket Current reported. In statements to both outlets, brokerage attorney Ray Cashen—also spelled Chasen by Nantucket Current—argued that Ment admitted during trial testimony he did not believe Gowen intentionally lied. Defense counsel further contended that the buyers received the restrictive document eleven days before closing, had two attorneys review it, unsuccessfully asked the sellers to waive a two-bedroom septic restriction, and still completed the purchase, Realtor reported. Brokerage representatives also maintained to Nantucket Current that the firm upholds high standards of integrity across its decades-long history.Ultimately, Murray and Ment sold the Polpis Road cottage in 2021 for $1.95 million, though Murray told Nantucket Current that mortgage payments, improvements, and Land Bank fees reduced their net gain to roughly $125,000. Forced back into a surging market where entry-level properties had climbed past $2 million, the couple borrowed against their retirement accounts and took out a home equity loan to purchase a five-bedroom home on Gardener Road for $3.1 million, leaving them carrying substantial debt despite their courtroom victory, according to both outlets.Image Courtesy: Google Gemini

Original Source

Read the full article at Timesofindia →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.