Fake farewells fool nobody, but a great encore is worth the wait

Fake farewells fool nobody, but a great encore is worth the wait

OpinionA good encore should raise the roof. After all, this is show business.JournalistNovember 21, 2026 — 5:30amNovember 21, 2026 — 5:30amWe know they’re coming back. The exit was too casual, it’s still dark out here and the stage lights are throbbing like jazz hands. Look around, though. That punter’s checking his public transport app. That one’s rubbing her temples. Could the band not just play Wonderwall and then leave the stage?Loathe it or just dislike it, the encore is inescapably a thing. But sometime between Elvis leaving that building in Shreveport, Louisiana 70 years ago and the modern musician’s all-but-contracted toilet break a few songs before the end of the show, the curtain call caper shifted from pandemonium to charade.I blame the artist. Not least Roger Daltrey. “I call it bullshit time,” the Who’s moonlighting singer announced before he led his Ultimate Rock Symphony offstage and back on at Colonial Stadium in March 2000. Way to kill the vibe, Rog. What might have been a romping climax left this fan with a 26-year-long grudge.A memorable encore requires commitment and imagination.Richard CliffordDaltrey’s long antipathy – “The encores, the bloody encores. We hate ’em,” he told a press conference in 1975 – says the quiet bit out loud for many. Fair enough for the Who, I guess. They’d smashed everything to pieces during My Generation. But begrudging the return says more about the artist’s lack of imagination than the ritual itself.Sam Fender’s recent Australian tour offered an example of the thing done right. After the communal uproar of his signature hit Seventeen Going Under, he returned alone under a spotlight for The Dying Light and suddenly the encore was an invitation to listen again.The band joined later, swelling towards the final blast of Hypersonic Missiles, but that moment of solitude reset the emotional scale. Turns out you can bring a crowd closer by giving them less to shout about.“If you own a cape, rock star, this is the time to put it on.”Indulging the past is fine too, but a surprise payoff is the difference between escalation and obligation. A risky, under-rehearsed cover version. Dragging the support band back up. Even bagpipes and a kilt can work – just make sure you’re Jimmy Barnes first.Mike Skinner knew he’d have to come back for a few random hits after performing the Streets’ A Grand Don’t Come For Free in its entirety last summer, but he kept himself interested by crowd-surfing the length of the venue each night.It’s not like every performer can be Rufus Wainwright, magicking up a whole Mardi Gras of dancing fools with fruit on their heads to take over the concert hall as he re-costumes as Judy Garland for a roof-raising re-entry. But if you own a cape, rock star, this is the time to put it on. And if not, why not? This is show business.Speaking of James Brown, you don’t even need to physically leave to make people suddenly realise how much they’re going to miss you. Even threatened departure is drama on a stick, as long as you commit fully enough to make the audience want to play along.Walking off with your biggest hit still in your pocket is where the eye-rolling starts. Deep Purple moved Smoke On the Water back into the main set decades ago. “We wanted to teach it a lesson,” singer Ian Gillan told me, like a boss. If the air guitars are still plugged in and wailing after that, that’s an encore you deserve.As we grow more jaded out here in the dark, making the charade feel real is the part of the deal that’s slipping. I was a more credulous young man when I first saw Leonard Cohen in 1980, but when he came back eight times I was convinced I was witnessing history. Surely this hadn’t happened in Adelaide.By the end he was taking requests. Songs like It Seems So Long Ago, Nancy that he pretended to dredge with real effort from the depths of his memory, just for us. He signalled the true finish with a poet’s flourish: ending “the way we began”, with Bird On A Wire. Circle closed. Nobody asked for a ninth lap.Which brings me back to Roger Daltrey, a man not prone to bullshit, who has suggested his recent US tour may be his last. Perhaps his own realisation that he might not be coming back this time has made him more gracious.At Mesa Arts Centre in Arizona in August, after smashing through a finale of Rockin’ in The Free World, he wandered back for a solo acoustic guitar rendition of The Kinks’ sentimental song of gratitude, Days. Just the thought of it gets me a little misty. I’d wait 26 years for him to come back and sing that.Want more Verdicts?Civilians landing planes in movies: Call me cynical, but I doubt I could wing itSuperhero movies: They’re what we need right nowStar ratings: As a reviewer, I believe they’re an insult to the publicTribute bands: Pay tribute to musicians – just spare me the wigsBarenaked Ladies: This ‘novelty act’ belongs in the Rock & Roll Hall of FameIn praise of the queue: Why we ‘stan’ standing in lineRadiohead: Anyone else think this beloved band kinda sucks?More:The VerdictOpinionSpectrumLive musicLive musicSpectrumFrom our partners

Original Source

Read the full article at Smh →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.