Elon Musk repeated Kremlin state propaganda narratives and made verifiably incorrect claims about the Russo-Ukrainian War, a Kyiv Post fact-check of a high-profile Wednesday interview with the world’s richest man has found. The SpaceX CEO and sometimes ally of US President Donald Trump made the comments during the 2026 DealBook Summit organized by DealBook, hosted by the business and financial newsletter of the New York Times.JOIN US ON TELEGRAMFollow our coverage of the war on the @Kyivpost_official. Newsletter author Andrew Ross Sorkin interviewed Musk for 47 minutes from the Lincoln Center in New York, with Musk responding to questions remotely from China. Promotional materials for the summit featured the Musk-Sorkin interview alongside a blue-ribbon speaker list that also included US Vice President JD Vance, Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney and New York Mayor Zohran Mamdani. The full-length video of the Musk interview is here. A full transcript of the interview is available here. About 13 minutes of the interview covered Ukraine-related topics, including the war with Russia and the communication services provided by Musk and SpaceX to Ukraine’s armed forces. Many of Musk’s assertions on these subjects were inaccurate or misleading, and several were demonstrably wrong. A few of his comments were in lockstep with Kremlin propaganda. 1. Musk claimed his company’s delivery of Starlink services prevented the collapse of Ukrainian defenses during Russia’s second invasion of Ukraine in early 2022. Fact: This is misleading and, in many respects, not true. Musk said: “I think it would probably be accurate to say that there is no private individual who has helped Ukraine more than I have. I made sure that Starlink was in Ukraine prepositioned ahead of the Russian invasion. Other Topics of Interest New EU rules cover Erasmus+ exchanges and Erasmus Mundus master’s scholarships. Their effect on previously funded awards remains unclear. “And when Russia invaded, they disabled all communications, all cell towers, all fiber cables, and every satellite communication system. There was one system they could not disable, and that was Starlink. And if they [Ukrainians] had not had Starlink, their entire line would have collapsed because they had no communication system, and Russia would have won. Now, does that sound like a pro-Russian action to you?” Reality: At the outset of Russia’s full-scale invasion, most Ukrainian mobile phone and cable communications worked normally, and Starlink wasn’t critical at that time (Starlink was also not “prepositioned”: it was switched on in Ukraine only after the invasion began). Details: At the outset of Russia’s second invasion, the default way for Ukrainian combat units to exchange information was commercial encrypted text and voice messages via smartphone. Ukrainian military and civilian landlines continued to work. In late February 2022, Musk ordered Starlink coverage activated in Ukraine, which helped Ukrainian combat units possessing Starlink receivers – at the time a minority of all fighting units, most of them special operations forces – to communicate and, in some cases, operate primitive drones of that day more efficiently. It is worth noting that, at some point following February 2022, Musk ordered the Russian-occupied Ukrainian territory of Crimea geo-fenced from Starlink coverage. This triggered an early Ukraine-Musk conflict after Kyiv accused Musk of preventing Ukraine’s special forces-operated naval drones raid into Crimea to attack Russian warships and for, de facto, treating Crimea as a part of Russia and not as Ukrainian territory. 2. Musk claimed providing Starlink/SpaceX services to Ukraine’s military is proof of his serious support of Ukraine and its fight to defend itself. Reality: Musk’s companies’ service delivery to Ukraine’s military has been spotty, with at times seemingly arbitrary cut-offs. Regarding Musk’s claim of altruism, Ukrainian users pay for their terminals and service, mostly through foreign governments or out of their own pockets. Musk said: “Starlink provides the backbone of communications for the Ukrainian military and for Ukraine more broadly. And if we were to turn off Starlink, the entire Ukrainian front would collapse immediately. So, this is, I think, an action that can only be described as incredibly supportive of Ukraine.” Details: According to open-source estimates, more than 50,000 Starlink terminals are in use in Ukraine at any given time, with thousands more bought that need replacement almost immediately because they are widely mounted on Ukrainian kamikaze drones. The biggest single paying customer for Starlink services in Ukraine is the Polish government, followed by the German government. However, hundreds of Ukrainian combat units pay for terminals and monthly subscriptions themselves. Although no Ukrainian commander would say Starlink isn’t a massive help in combat operations, Ukrainian fighting units have at times operated for months effectively without Starlink coverage. For instance, during the invasion of Russia’s Kursk region, where Starlink is switched off, from August 2024 to May 2025. Shifting to backup communications when a Starlink fails is standard procedure in the Ukrainian Armed Forces (AFU). Within the AFU, the view is almost universal that Starlink’s key advantage is accurate and nearly unjammable control of Ukrainian drones attacking Russian forces in Russian-occupied territory in Ukraine. Musk is currently denying that capability with a switch that shuts down any Starlink terminal in Ukraine, if the terminal is moving at speeds above 100 mph (160 kph). According to almost all Ukrainian drone operators, Musk’s decision to impose the cap has been a godsend for Russian military logistics – trucks and even cargo ships that would otherwise have been destroyed by Ukrainian drones. What’s more, because of the Musk-imposed speed limit, Starlink-guided interceptor drones designed to knock down Russian kamikaze drones attacking Ukrainian homes and businesses, don’t work, which increases the death and injury of Ukrainian civilians. In Ukraine, these actions are widely seen as hostile to Ukraine and directly supportive of Russia. 3. Musk said he and his companies are neutral operators interested only in peace and business, and that he doesn’t want himself and his corporations to be forced to pick sides in a war. Reality: Delivery of the military version of Starlink coverage to the Pentagon, a system called Starshield, is critical to Musk’s businesses, and Starshield has reportedly helped kill people in Iran. In Ukraine, Musk did not object to the operation of Starshield by the AFU, including for attack operations against Russian forces for more than three years of the war. Musk said: “From the beginning, I’ve said that Starlink is a civilian system. It is not meant to be used for offensive drone attacks that kill people. That is, if you want to do that, you need to do Starshield, which is a separate system that is controlled by the US government. “But do not ask me as a private individual to make kill decisions that sometimes result in the loss of innocent lives, not just soldiers. That is not my position to do…” “So, you know, I repeatedly said, look, if they want you to do something that’s an offensive military action, it needs to be the Starshield system where the kill decision is that of the War Department, perhaps ultimately the president, and not mine. And that’s how it’s going to be.” Details: Starshield is the main platform for the US military’s large-scale communications worldwide, giving Musk’s companies preferred access to military contracts, intelligence, and allied markets, for decades to come. According to open sources, Starshield-linked US drones have conducted attacks and conducted combat operations in Iran since March 2026 at least, undermining and possibly directly contradicting Musk’s contention that what he really wants is separation between his businesses and military operations that kill people. Ukrainian access to Starshield was given by the Biden administration in 2023, but usage was never massive, reportedly with only about 3,000 terminals delivered to date, reportedly primarily to Ukrainian special operations long-range attack units targeting Ukrainian territories occupied by Russia. Musk’s argument that the US government, not he, the SpaceX CEO, should decide whether the AFU can use Starshield and/or Starlink for lethal military attack operations quite possibly holds water – provided it is reasonable to assume that SpaceX/Starshield-enabled destruction of Iranian life and property, both military and civilian, is moral, but of Russian life and property (intentionally only military) is immoral. A complicating factor is that White House officials, including President Donald Trump himself, have stated they did not order the slowdown of Starlink for Ukraine’s drone forces and the cutoff of access to Starshield, calling it a “technical issue” Musk and his companies are responsible for. Most Ukrainian drone operators will suggest if asked – perhaps unfairly – that the reason SpaceX imposed the speed limit is that Musk wants to protect Russian forces from Ukrainian drone attacks, and because Musk doesn’t want Ukrainian interceptor drones stopping Russian kamikaze drones from attacking Ukrainian civilian homes and businesses. 4. Musk said thousands of Russian and Ukrainian “boys” are being conscripted and sent involuntarily to their deaths in the Russo-Ukrainian War every day, and that human empathy dictates action be taken to help those innocent young men stay alive. Reality: Musk conflates conscripts with mobilized soldiers and volunteers. In both Russia and Ukraine, the law bars sending young conscripts doing regular military service into combat. In Ukraine, men can be mobilized for combat only from age 25. Regarding the numbers killed, he’s more or less right about Russians but wrong by at least an order of magnitude about Ukrainians. Moreover, Musk gives moral equivalency to Russian citizens participating voluntarily in an armed invasion of a neighboring country, and Ukrainian citizens choosing to defend their homes and families – quite probably undermining Musk’s argument that Russian and Ukrainian soldiers are equally deserving of empathy. Musk said: “Thousands of kids are sent in to die every day with no change in the borders forever. And I think anyone who supports that is a horrible human being or has not thought through the problem. “ “And you should have empathy not just for the Ukrainian boys who are dying, but also for the Russian ones because they’re conscripted and forced to go to that line. Nobody voluntarily goes to a line just to die in a drone attack. “And now those sons are never going to see their parents again. Some of the kids of those men are never going to see their father again. Imagine if that was your son or your dad. “And I think there’s been too much of this Ukraine good, Russia bad.” Details: Ukraine’s armed forces are made up of volunteers and mobilized reservists, along with a small annual intake of young conscripts who by law may not be sent to frontline combat. (The rule is somewhat academic because Russia attacks Ukrainian military targets, including ones containing new draftees across Ukraine – including those housing new conscripts – wherever it can, often hundreds of kilometers behind the front.) Ukrainian law enforcement actively searches for deserters and for men of mobilization age, usually reservists, who are dodging service. However, according to Ukrainian recruiters, the predominant majority of new troops are volunteers. Also, Musk’s contention that thousands of Ukrainian youths are being sent to their death in frontline battles against drones is also wrong. First, the average Ukrainian soldier is not a “boy,” but a middle-aged man. Second, Ukraine’s armed forces hold front lines with a minimal cordon shell of soldiers, conduct human-led offensive operations rarely, and overwhelmingly fight Russian forces with drones. Ukrainian casualties are real and continuous, but daily losses are not in the thousands, but in the low dozens, independent researchers say. On the Russian side, the law likewise bans the deployment of draftees to combat operations outside the country. For the most part, Russian recruiters rely on what are, by Russian standards, massive financial incentives in promised salaries and signing bonuses to attract new soldiers into the ranks. Besides tempting volunteers with money, Russian law enforcers nationwide use the threat or fact of imprisonment on a civilian to convince him to “volunteer” for military service. As a result, a significant proportion of many Russian fighting units are men who don’t want to be there, but who are nonetheless volunteers from difficult personal circumstances: felons, divorcees behind on alimony payments, debtors or chronically unemployed arrested as vagrants. As in the Ukrainian military, only a minority are “boys,” and the majority are middle-aged or older. Regarding daily casualties, Musk in terms of Russian soldier losses is generally correct: On a given day of combat, between 1,500-2,000 Russian soldiers are killed or seriously injured, according to AFU and independent observer counts. The current Russian army tactic of making attacks by sending unsupported infantry troops over open ground dominated by Ukrainian drone swarms is widely criticized within the Russian ranks; so, Musk’s contention that Russian soldiers don’t want to die from a drone attack is certainly true. However, practically no Russian soldier serving in an assault unit is an innocent sent without options to the slaughter; at minimum, each had the option of going to prison or deserting, rather than putting on a Russian army uniform and participating in a military invasion of Ukraine. It’s not clear whether Musk is concerned about “thousands of kids sent to die every day” because they are heavily Russian, not Ukrainian, or because he is unaware of how much lower Ukrainian combat losses are. 5. Musk said that Ukraine’s Revolution of Dignity – throwing out a corrupt and abusive pro-Moscow government that had reneged on promises to bring Ukraine closer with Europe, not Russia, was the result of a US government action – not popular Ukrainian hostility to a pro-Russia government. Reality: Musk is repeating a long-debunked Kremlin narrative about the emergence of a democratic government in Ukraine, almost chapter and verse, implying that Ukraine moved away from Moscow because of the actions of Western secret agents, not the will of its people. Musk also argued that SpaceX’s intense launch rate, which has taken away business from Russian launch providers, proves he is no supporter of Russia. Musk said: “It’s true that from an invasion standpoint, Russia is the aggressor, but it is also true that we Americans staged a coup to overthrow the democratically elected pro-Russian president of Ukraine..” “That is an offensive action. And without US State Department and other agency help, this would not have happened. That is obviously an offensive action. I mean, the full answer would take too long. Maybe I should just write this up and articulate it. There were some, and it sounds like I’m making excuses for Russia here, but I’m not.” “I mean, if you look at what my actions have done, SpaceX, for example, has resulted in two-thirds of the Russian reduction of the Russian space activities by two-thirds because we took away their Soyuz launches, we took away their commercial rocket launches, and reduced the Russian aerospace industry by a factor of three. “I’m not exactly someone who has aided Russia. We have no business in Russia. We have nothing in Russia.” Details: Musk’s comments ignore the basic facts of Ukraine’s 2013-14 Revolution of Dignity (also known as the Maidan), during which hundreds of thousands of Ukrainians repeatedly protested the government’s sudden switch from a pro-European to pro-Moscow foreign policy, and equally, the gross and obvious Ukrainian state-sponsored corruption, often benefiting Russian big business. Those protests expanded in size and anger, and in February 2014 – after the pro-Kremlin Ukrainian government of Viktor Yanukovych ordered riot police and snipers to open fire on protesters, killing more than 100 and wounding more than 1,000. Ukraine’s Verkhovna Rada, most government ministries, the judiciary, and much of the police sided with the protesters and condemned the killings. The next day, Yanukovych and his allies fled the country, possibly to avoid prosecution. Within days, Russia launched its first invasion of Ukraine, seizing Crimea, and two months later began its military operations in the Donbas. Musk leaves aside all that, instead arguing, as the Kremlin has since 2014, that the US State Department and other US agencies manipulated Ukrainian public opinion to replace a pro-Russia government with a pro-Western one, and implying strongly that Ukrainian civil society had nothing to do with the Revolution of Dignity. As for SpaceX’s competition with Roscosmos and other Russian aerospace companies, Musk and his companies probably won in that business rivalry not because of any deep-seated conviction that Russia should be weakened, but because the less Russian space agencies were capable of placing commercial satellites in orbit and performing other space services, the more business and income for Musk’s companies.
FACT-CHECKED: Elon Musk’s Latest Claims on Starlink, Ukraine and Russia
Full Article
Original Source
Read the full article at Kyivpost →KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.