EXCLUSIVE — Government officials and air traffic control employees in the Federal Aviation Administration are concerned about inconsistencies surrounding the Trump administration’s explanation of last Friday’s nationwide ground stop.Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy and FAA Administrator Bryan Bedford have explained the five-hour halt on all aircraft departures as the result of a telecommunications issue caused following the installation of a single router.However, dozens of FAA employees nationwide who spoke by phone or text message with the Washington Examiner since Nov. 13 have alleged the claim does not add up for a number of reasons. FAA employees shared information on the condition of anonymity because they are not permitted to speak with the press.They questioned the need for shutting down the entire national airspace, a move that has only happened one other time since 9/11; how a routine telecommunications upgrade that has been done countless times at other facilities could have affected facilities across the country; and why the upgrade was allowed given the FAA’s general protocol of making changes at times of the week when there is no air traffic.The company behind a new artificial intelligence dashboard for managing flights came under scrutiny amid speculation that AI could be behind the meltdown, given that the dashboard was expanded nationwide last week. The company, ASI, posted a statement on X that said the ground stop “is not based on or a result of the SMART system, any product of ASI or our integration with FAA and ATC.”Many observers were not convinced, particularly given that just last month, congressional Democrats contacted the Government Accountability Office and asked the federal office to audit the new system due to concerns about safety and guardrails.In a lengthy statement issued two days after the incident, the FAA said contractor L3Harris had been doing work Friday afternoon at a radar site in Amarillo, Texas, and a radio communications site in El Dorado, Arkansas, when the existing equipment “began flooding” its telecommunications network, trying to connect to it thousands of times per minute. It “disrupted the system and created instability with aircraft communications and radar feeds,” the FAA said.However, the disruption only affected a certain type of FAA facility, known as Air Route Traffic Control Centers. These “centers” manage all aircraft at an altitude of 1,200 feet to 60,000 feet, according to the FAA. Five of the 22 centers maintained full communications with aircraft.One controller who commented via text message said the center facilities deal with communications issues “EVERY single day,” adding that never in his career “has a comm issue in [Chicago] or [New York] led to issues in [Dallas].”The FAA disclosed on Sunday that not all radio and radar communications with aircraft went down, meaning that planes and controllers were still able to make contact. Air traffic controllers at affected facilities still had either secondary and one additional backup system to communicate with pilots if the primary system was down.“This was not a full outage. Some frequencies and radar feeds remained reliable,” the FAA website says. “Americans’ safety is always our top priority. Out of an abundance of caution, the FAA implemented a nationwide ground stop to ensure aircraft could continue to operate safely.”The more than 290 other FAA air traffic control facilities, such as airport towers and Terminal Radar Approach Control, also maintained full communications. To prevent planes on the ground from running into trouble communicating midair, the FAA imposed a ground stop on departures, but allowed those mid-flight to continue to their destination if they had an adequate connection to controllers.“It just seems very questionable how a system that has backups and redundancies had this happen,” one controller wrote in a text message. “Even with the antiquated equipment we have like everyone says … we do have backups and redundancies. Because safety is the whole nature of the job.”Others pointed out that since the beginning of the year, the FAA has been implementing more than 10,000 changes before President Donald Trump leaves office. Some FAA employees were skeptical that a routine upgrade would have such a significant impact given how many similar changes have been made this year without causing problems.The FAA is in the middle of a $12.5 billion modernization effort funded through the One Big Beautiful Bill Act. Numerous upgrades have started this year, and sources say the agency is rushing the process because contractors are under pressure to get things done in time, and it’s creating problems.The flight tracking system is so outdated that air traffic controllers track individual flights on pieces of paper known as flight strips. As of August, 20 of the 89 control towers that use the antiquated paper strips have swapped them for electronic displays that give controllers real-time information.More than 60% of the nation’s legacy copper telecommunications lines have been replaced with high-speed fiber-optic and wireless infrastructure. Manual buttons and analog patch boards are being replaced with digital communications and switches.As of late August, the FAA had replaced 44% of its 220 surface awareness initiatives; converted 380 of 1,581 radio sites; transferred 166 of 450 voice switches to IP voice switches; and deployed nine of 612 new radar systems nationwide.FAA LIFTS NATIONWIDE GROUND STOP FOLLOWING HISTORIC HALT ON AIR TRAVELThe rush could also be why contractors opted to upgrade a small piece of equipment on a Friday afternoon rather than wait until a more optimal time. Normally, they explained, maintenance is done during the middle of the night on weekdays when there is no air traffic in the area.“Maintenance at major air traffic control facilities is typically conducted at night, when there’s less traffic. This disruption was a result of a routine replacement at a remote facility, which has regularly been done for decades, without any impacts to the systems at these times,” the FAA said. “However, based on what happened Friday, we will reevaluate when we do replacement/maintenance work.”
FAA ground stop explanation leaves storm of unanswered questions
Full Article
Original Source
Read the full article at Washingtonexaminer →KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.