Russia is now saying that Europe can join the Ukraine peace talks only once it shows what “constructive, substantive contribution” it can make, which in effect means making concessions before it is even allowed to negotiate. The demand shows that Russia’s strategy has failed. Moscow relied on the United States to force Ukraine to give way and has instead helped turn Europe into a power it now has to deal with.JOIN US ON TELEGRAMFollow our coverage of the war on the @Kyivpost_official. On Monday Yuri Ushakov, Vladimir Putin’s foreign policy adviser, said Russia had not agreed to European participation in the next round of talks, even though four days earlier Steve Witkoff, Donald Trump’s envoy, had said after meeting Putin that “the Europeans will join at the next meeting.” Ushakov said “a great deal would have to be done” first, and that Europe must show what constructive contribution it can make. On Thursday, he had said Europe’s actions pointed to war. Moscow objects to Europe’s weapons, its money, its sanctions and its plans to send troops to Ukraine after a ceasefire. To Russia, a constructive contribution means giving these up. Russia would not need anything from Europe if its plan had worked. Moscow expected Washington to put pressure on Kyiv. Instead, Trump cut new US aid to Ukraine and told Europeans to take responsibility for their own security. As a result, Washington lost much of its influence over both Ukraine and Europe. Other Topics of Interest Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin have begun talks in Shenzhen ahead of a historic three-way summit with Donald Trump, raising concerns that the three leaders could discuss Ukraine’s future and reshape global power relations without Kyiv or Europe. European governments now provide most of the money and weapons that keep Ukraine fighting, which makes them the main obstacle to Russia’s aims. Russia’s demand that NATO withdraw its forces to their 1997 positions is alarming, but it comes from this failure. Russia is asking Europe for what it could not win on the battlefield or obtain through Washington. Putin’s gamble on Trump Moscow’s calculation was straightforward. Donald Trump wanted a deal, and Putin saw an opportunity to exploit an accommodating American president to achieve objectives Russia had failed to secure on the battlefield. Trump could pressure Ukraine into surrendering territory, ease economic sanctions and negotiate a new European security order directly with Moscow. Poland’s Centre for Eastern Studies has argued that Russia is seeking to turn Trump into a de facto ally in pressuring European governments to accept arrangements that undermine their security. The strategy has already delivered something important. Washington has agreed to discuss Europe’s security architecture with Russia, opening the door to demands that successive American administrations rejected. But there was a flaw in Moscow’s calculation. By withdrawing direct military and financial support from Ukraine and pressing Europe to assume greater responsibility for its own defense, Trump gave away America’s leverage over the very countries Putin wanted it to pressure. America retreats, Europe steps forward The figures are striking. According to Germany’s Kiel Institute, new American aid allocations to Ukraine fell by 99% in 2025 compared with the annual average for 2022–24. European military allocations, meanwhile, increased by 67%. Yet Ukraine continued resisting. European governments stepped forward to help sustain its armed forces and keep its state functioning. Under Joe Biden, Washington had been the dominant organizer of Western support for Ukraine. It supplied the military muscle, financial assistance and diplomatic leadership that gave America enormous influence over Kyiv. Trump has substantially reduced that commitment while continuing to pursue a settlement on American terms. And this has changed the balance of power. Europe now provides much of the money and military assistance keeping Ukraine in the fight. Its governments have acquired greater influence over the conditions under which Kyiv can continue resisting or agree to peace. America still supplies critical weapons, intelligence and security capabilities. Europe remains dependent on Washington in important respects. But Trump cannot order Brussels to lift European sanctions, commit European troops to security guarantees or make NATO’s European members dismantle their defenses. Russia’s demands give the game away That brings us back to Ushakov and Moscow’s sweeping demands. According to Russian negotiating points obtained by The Washington Post, the Kremlin wants NATO deployments rolled back to their 1997 positions, effectively stripping Poland and other eastern allies of much of the allied military presence established since the end of the Cold War. It also wants a halt to Western weapons supplies to Ukraine, limits on Ukraine’s armed forces and a ban on foreign troops and military facilities on Ukrainian soil. These demands have the appearance of negotiating strength. Moscow is setting the agenda, insisting on sweeping concessions and treating European governments as troublesome outsiders. But their sheer scale also reveals Russia’s predicament. Putin needs decisions from governments whose influence he has spent years trying to undermine. He needs Europeans to abandon military options, relax sanctions and accept a security order that would leave them more vulnerable to Russian pressure. And he needs them to make these concessions while questioning whether they deserve a place at the negotiating table. Ushakov’s demands expose the contradiction at the heart of Russia’s strategy. Moscow is trying to delay Europe’s involvement in the peace talks, even as European weapons, money, sanctions and security guarantees have made it indispensable to any lasting settlement. European support for Ukraine is precisely what is preventing Russia from dictating the terms of peace. That makes Europe a negotiating partner Moscow cannot simply bypass, however much it might prefer to deal exclusively with Trump. The Europe Putin wanted to prevent There is a bigger geopolitical irony here. Russia has long preferred dealing with Washington and individual European capitals, where differences between national interests offer opportunities to divide and pressure governments. Its diplomats have even floated separate bilateral non-aggression agreements with individual NATO countries, potentially weakening their collective position. Yet Trump’s retreat and Russia’s increasingly threatening demands are encouraging Europeans to organize around their common security interests. And Europe is slowly starting to turn into the geopolitical actor that Putin doesn’t want it to be. Last Friday in Dublin, European leaders agreed on a negotiating team bringing together Britain, France, Germany, Italy and Poland, alongside EU institutions. The Coalition of the Willing is preparing potential postwar security guarantees for Ukraine. European governments are increasing defense spending and assuming greater responsibility for their own protection. Europe remains divided and heavily dependent on American military capabilities. Its growing influence does not make it a unified strategic power, and Moscow has already achieved a diplomatic success by persuading Washington to reopen discussions about Europe’s security order. But the direction of change matters. For Poland, whose security rests on the NATO arrangements Russia wants dismantled, that change is particularly consequential. Warsaw now has a place in Europe’s negotiating team, even as Moscow refuses to admit that team to the talks. See the original of this analysis by Stuart Dowel for TVP World here.
EXPLAINER: Putin Wanted to Sideline Europe. He May Have Made It Stronger
Full Article
Original Source
Read the full article at Kyivpost →KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.