Doctors in the UK who have been referred to the General Medical Council (GMC) for alleged antisemitism and Islamophobia are considering legal action after the regulator leaked sensitive data about them to The Times newspaper, Middle East Eye has learned. The leak occurred following a Freedom of Information request submitted by the Times to the GMC, which asked for the number of doctors who had been complained about, investigated and sanctioned for antisemitism and Islamophobia since October 2023. In its response, the GMC shared the reference numbers of 223 doctors, which allows them to be identified through the regulator’s public-facing database. The GMC also included details of doctors’ ethnicities, which under UK law is a protected characteristic. In a letter sent to doctors' groups this week, Claire Light, the GMC’s head of equality, diversity and inclusion, stated that internal data had been shared with The Times “in error”, and that the regulator had formally requested through their lawyers that the newspaper deletes the confidential data and does not disseminate it. New MEE newsletter: Jerusalem Dispatch Sign up to get the latest insights and analysis on Israel-Palestine, alongside Turkey Unpacked and other MEE newsletters The Times has told the GMC that it will not publish the information but will retain it. The regulator was forced to contact doctors affected to apologise for the disclosure. Some doctors were not previously aware of complaints about them, because the evidence did not meet the threshold for initiating an investigation. Many doctors who have been involved in pro-Palestine advocacy since the start of Israel’s genocidal war on Gaza have been the subject of antisemitism complaints and disciplinary procedures in the UK. Lawyer Tayab Ali, a partner at Bindmans representing dozens of doctors affected by the leak, told MEE exclusively that efforts were under way to pursue criminal charges against the GMC. ‘Malicious intent’ Dr Ghassan Abu Sitta, a British-Palestinian surgeon whose data was disclosed in the leak, told MEE that the GMC’s chief executive Charlie Massey should resign over the incident. “This is not human error - a whole database has been transferred to the Times,” he said. “It is a natural conclusion to the way the GMC has always racialised doctors of colour. For the GMC to knowingly endanger the lives and the privacy of doctors of colour is a natural conclusion to everything it has been doing over the last three years during the genocide. ‘For the GMC to knowingly endanger the lives and the privacy of doctors of colour is a natural conclusion to everything it has been doing over the last three years during the genocide’ - Dr Ghassan Abu Sitta, British-Palestinian surgeon whose data was disclosed “The GMC needs to come clean about what data it has transferred, because I need to know if there is any data out there that endangers my safety or the safety of my family.” Abu Sitta also called for a public inquiry into the conduct of the GMC and what he described as “institutional racism” within it. He was cleared of alleged antisemitism and the glorification of terrorism by the GMC’s tribunal service following a complaint by UK Lawyers For Israel (UKLFI) about his social media posts on Gaza and an opinion piece he had written for a Lebanese newspaper in 2018. However, the GMC is now challenging the decision and the case will go to the High Court later this year. Abu Sitta has previously had confidential data about the case against him leaked. “Before I was informed of the action being taken against me by the GMC, the news was leaked to the Telegraph,” he explained. “Five days before the GMC announced its intention to appeal the decision of its tribunal service, the news was posted on the UKLFI website. “The fact that this leak is coming just before the GMC goes to the High Court to try to take me to trial for a third time highlights the fact that its campaign against doctors who have spoken against the genocide is purely politically motivated.” Abu Sitta told MEE he felt there was some collusion between the GMC and the Times newspaper, because the latter is refusing to delete the information it was sent. “It demonstrates a malicious intent,” he said. Palestinian doctor Ghassan Abu Sittah wins misconduct case Read More » Dr Nadeem Crowe, an emergency doctor in London who was suspended from employment by the Royal Free Hospital in August 2024 following an anonymous complaint about his social media posts about Palestine, told MEE he was disgusted but not surprised that his data had been leaked. “I've gone back to the GMC and asked for exactly what information was shared - is it a complaint I was already aware of, and who requested it,” he said. “I have absolutely no trust in the GMC at all, and although I would like to end my membership now, it would mean they hold us hostage and I wouldn’t be able to work as a doctor.” Doctors in the UK must be registered with the GMC and hold a licence to practise in order to work. Crowe’s hospital lifted his suspension after pressuring him into deleting his social media posts, having threatened him with an investigation if he did not comply. He subsequently launched a legal case against his National Health Service (NHS) employer claiming race discrimination and harassment, and is awaiting a judgement on it. He is now taking legal advice about the disclosure of his data. “I don't accept the GMC’s apology and I cannot fathom how it can be a ‘human error’ that so much of my data has been passed on. Somebody would have had to go through a lot of data to collate this many data points and share them by mistake,” he said. “Had this been the other way round, had this been a human error of me as a doctor leaking information about a patient, I would be suspended right now or probably losing my licence. “There are seniors who need to step down - Charlie Massey being the first. This happened under his watch, and the GMC needs reform, and in fact a body to replace it.” Fears of doxxing and harassment Ali told MEE he was investigating the circumstances of the disclosure of his clients’ data. "This is a very serious data breach. Sending sensitive personal information to a media organisation is one of the worst types of breaches there is," the lawyer said. "It is a huge invasion of privacy and potentially puts individuals at risk. ‘Sending sensitive personal information to a media organisation is one of the worst types of breaches there is. It is a huge invasion of privacy and potentially puts individuals at risk’ - Tayab Ali, lawyer at Bindmans “We don't yet know exactly what has been disclosed, what The Times has done with it, or whether it has been shared further.” Ali added that the GMC could take legal action to recover the data and ensure it is destroyed, and it was their responsibility to put this right. “If anyone knowingly or recklessly disclosed personal data without authority, that is a criminal offence under the Data Protection Act,” he said. General Data Protection Regulation places a legal requirement on every organisation that holds personal data to keep it secure and only disclose it where the law allows. Information about ethnicity falls under a special category of data and receives the highest level of protection. “When a breach like this happens, the organisation must report it to the Information Commission within 72 hours and tell the people affected without delay if they are at high risk,” Ali explained. “The regulator can investigate and impose fines of up to £17.5 million, and the individuals affected are entitled to claim compensation, including for distress. “A regulator that holds this kind of information about the profession it oversees should be meeting the highest standard, not falling below the basic one.” Other doctors who have been complained about for alleged antisemitism over pro-Palestine social media posts shared their concerns anonymously with MEE about their data being leaked. “At first I thought it was a hoax, I didn’t believe this could happen. It’s such an extreme thing to accidentally leak personal information to a national newspaper,” one of them said. “The GMC didn’t even offer any meaningful support. They have put the onus on individual doctors to take this further when it’s their mistake. They should be pursuing all legal routes to secure the data they have leaked. “I’m horrified and it’s very distressing, knowing a newspaper has information about you that they’re refusing to delete and could publish makes you feel very vulnerable.” The doctor said they had previously received threatening and abusive messages, including death and rape threats, over their pro-Palestine advocacy online and believed the disclosure had further endangered their safety. 'I was doxxed': UK doctors welcome BMA protections for criticism of Israel Read More » Over the last two years, The Times has published several articles relating to alleged antisemitism in the NHS. A piece published by the newspaper in September made use of GMC data on complaints about doctors for antisemitism and Islamophobia since October 2023. MEE could not establish whether the data leaked by the GMC was used in the September article, as the regulator has not said when the information was shared with The Times. The Times collaborated on the piece with the Campaign Against Antisemitism (CAA), a lobbying group that has been accused of improper political campaigning, anti-Muslim bias and conflating criticism of Israel with antisemitism. Another doctor told MEE they were worried about the possibility of doxxing and harassment. “I’ve complained to the Information Commissioner’s Office and the Times,” they said. “There is a network at play, and we are being observed and silenced.” The doctor said that after inquiring further about the data that was leaked, they learned their full name and details of the allegation about them was disclosed. “I’m worried about the prospect of these cases being reopened and investigated again, which could result in different outcomes,” they said. Amira Nimerawi, co-founder and CEO of the advocacy group Health Workers 4 Palestine, described the disclosure as a “profound betrayal”. “An apology means nothing while this data is still sitting with The Times,” she told MEE. “A regulator that cannot protect its own doctors’ data cannot credibly claim to protect patients. “We want an independent inquiry into how this happened. The Times must delete the data immediately and the GMC’s leadership must face real accountability.” ‘Weaponisation of GMC processes’ The president of the British Islamic Medical Association (Bima), Dr Sahira Dar, said it was supporting several members who had been affected by the disclosure. “We convened an emergency webinar as soon as we found out about it because we knew that it was going to disproportionately affect our membership, and doctors of certain ethnicities and faiths,” Dar told MEE. ‘[…] there is a hierarchy of racism, and the crackdown on Palestine advocacy is part of the wider context of Islamophobia within the NHS’ - Dr Sahira Dar, British Islamic Medical Association (Bima) “The people who joined were very anxious and distressed. We’re living in a climate where it's highly dangerous for this kind of information to be in the public domain because there are bad faith actors who could use it to ruin reputations.” The data leak comes after attempts to crack down on pro-Palestine advocacy within the NHS. Earlier this year, the government endorsed a review by Lord John Mann that would censor pro-Palestine advocacy among healthcare workers - it recommended mandatory antisemitism training for NHS staff members, as well as banning them from displaying political symbols in the workplace and preventing them from attending protests in their uniforms. “That review highlighted that there is a hierarchy of racism, and the crackdown on Palestine advocacy is part of the wider context of Islamophobia within the NHS,” Dar said. “Bima has been raising the alarm about the weaponisation of the GMC’s referral process in relation to this. “The complaints procedure has such a negative impact on the wellbeing of doctors and has created workspaces that are quite toxic - people are feeling targeted and alone.” GMC data on complaints of antisemitism and Islamophobia over the last three years, and how they were handled, show that allegations of anti-Jewish hate outnumbered those of anti-Muslim hate by 30 percent. 'Relentless': How UK Lawyers for Israel targets pro-Palestinian voices Read More » Antisemitism complaints were almost six times more likely to have resulted in a completed investigation than those centred around Islamophobia. Two doctors were erased from the medical register and one was suspended for antisemitism, while no equivalent sanctions were issued for Islamophobia. The GMC told MEE: “We recognise the concern this will cause to both those impacted personally and other registrants and we are very sorry this happened. “We have requested the information sent in error is deleted. We have also reported the incident to the Information Commissioner’s Office.” The British Medical Association, the UK’s largest doctors’ union, told MEE: “While the GMC has said that the Times will not be making the private details public at this stage, the newspaper will not be deleting the data - this is entirely unacceptable and will compound the worry experienced by these doctors. “Doctors who are the subject of complaints are entitled to confidentiality while investigations are ongoing, and after a decision has been made not to progress a complaint. The GMC must take action to ensure such a breach never occurs again.” The Times did not respond to MEE’s request for comment by the time of publication.
Exclusive: UK doctors accused of antisemitism seek legal action against regulator over personal data leak
Full Article
Original Source
Read the full article at Middleeasteye →KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.