Every 2026 Game of the Year Nominee, Ranked

Every 2026 Game of the Year Nominee, Ranked

Patrick Gibson as James Bond in the video game '007 First Light' Published Nov 19, 2026, 3:33 PM EST Lucas Kloberdanz-Dyck is a writer for Collider. He grew up creating lists, stories, and worlds, which led to his love of anime and video games. He attended Sheridan College where he earned an Honours Bachelor of Game Design. Lucas and his group won 1st place for technical innovation at LevelUp Toronto 2023, and he was also an intern for the Oakville Film Festival of Arts. Sign in to your Collider account 2026 has been a wonderful year for video games, with plenty of original titles like Mina the Hollower, games that are part of a franchise, such as Fire Emblem: Fortune’s Weave, and remarkable adaptations like Cyberpunk: Edgerunners Season 2. However, now that November is halfway through, fans can focus their sights on the largest video game award event, the Game Awards. Every year, Geoff Keighley takes the stage to announce the prestigious awards, along with plenty of upcoming titles for the year ahead. While there are plenty of anticipated awards, the one on everyone's mind is Game of the Year, and they just revealed the six nominees. This list is instantly controversial, with some notable absences and a couple of noteworthy inclusions, stirring debate among online communities. But like it or not, these are the nominees, and one of them will win the ultimate award come December. This list will rank every Game of the Year nominee based on gameplay, design, narrative, visuals, originality, fan opinion, critical acclaim, and overall quality. 6 ‘Phantom Blade Zero’ (2026) Image via Steam A lot of the best games of the year came out later, and one of the lucky latecomers was Phantom Blade Zero, which instantly impressed critics and fans to secure itself a nomination for Game of the Year. Set in the Phantom World, gamers play as Soul, an assassin who serves a mysterious organization known as the Order. However, when they are framed for the Order's leader, they barely escape alive, only surviving because of an unknown cure. But now they must go on a journey to uncover the truth and save himself before the cure runs out. This year had so many games, and plenty of titles that deserved to be here, but unfortunately, only six could earn a spot, and Phantom Blade Zero was one of them. This isn't necessarily a controversial choice, since it is regarded as a great game, but compared to the rest, it is last place. For soulslike fans, this is probably their Game of the Year, but as the genre becomes a bit stale, it doesn't hold up to other entries, which is mainly why it is last here. Still, it earned a nomination for a reason: Phantom Blade Zero is a fast-paced thrill ride with high-velocity combat, epic choreography and plenty of replayability. 5 ‘007: First Light’ (2026) Image via IOI 2026 has been a good year for James Bond fans, not only because they got the recent announcement that Robert Pattinson will be their new leading man, but also because of the video game 007: First Light. This origin story follows Bond's early years, where he was a young, reckless recruit on a mission to earn his 00 status. With a reluctant mentor, Bond is thrown into a globe-trotting adventure to uncover an international arms-dealing ring that poses a great threat to British national security. As fans predicted the nominees prior to the actual announcement, most probably got the majority of selections correct. However, 007: First Light has the most fans stumped, with many not including it in their personal lists. Yet, this title is easily one of the best action video games of the year, oozing with charming style and epic action that has made it such an exhilarating playthrough. It is one of the best Bond experiences in general, with a magnificent blend of blockbuster-style action and reserved spycraft. 007 First Light is a masterful game and a perfect entry into an established franchise, earning its spot through sheer gameplay and exhilaration. 4 ‘Control Resonant’ (2026) Image via Remedy Entertainment Remedy Entertainment is no stranger to the Game Awards, with a handful of nominations, and Control Resonant is their latest achievement. This list has a nice blend of sequels, new titles, and remakes, with one of the most anticipated follow-ups being this one. Dylan Faden is the gifted brother of the protagonist of the first game, with this sequel following him and his adventure to find her. By navigating a surreal version of Manhattan, he unravels the deep mysteries of his and his sister's origins as well as the Bureau's secrets, all while fighting against extradimensional entities. This was a competitive year for gaming, with the majority of the nominees earning between 87 and 89 on Metacritic. However, the one lower outlier is Control Resonant, which only has an 83. This isn't a Game of the Year-type score, but the blame is mostly on the reviewers, as this absolutely deserved a higher score. This game could have gone in the safe direction, but it took a risk, and it paid off, transforming it into a melee-focused action RPG. Some didn't appreciate this change in direction, but the mind-bending level design was truly marvellous, and the art direction continues to stand out. Control Resonant is a unique video game that stands out through its sheer commitment to bold originality. 3 ‘The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time’ (2026) Nintendo is one of the Big Three in the gaming industry, so the Game Awards aren't anything new for them, and this year their nomination went to the remake of The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time. This game is by far the most controversial since it isn't a new effort but a near 1:1 remake. When Link gets a vision of a dark future, he must travel back and forth between time in order to conquer dungeons and awaken the sages. With Ganondorf capturing Princess Zelda and possessing two-thirds of the Triforce, Link is Hyrule's only hope. Nintendo had three potential options for this award, including Fire Emblem: Fortune's Weave and Pokémon Pokopia. This is where the controversy lies, with many believing a safe remake such as this is undeserving of the nomination, especially when there are two other perfect and surprisingly original games (for their respective franchises, anyway). But like it or not, Ocarina of Time is a polished version of the greatest video game of all time, essentially making it an obvious nominee. The timeless gameplay, dungeons, enemies, narrative, and music are alive and well, but the fresh coat of paint, gorgeous art direction, and fluid controls make it even better than the original. Ocarina of Time is the second-highest-rated game of the year so far (can you guess number one?), and deservedly so, since it made a timeless experience even better. 2 ‘Resident Evil Requiem’ (2026) Image via CAPCOM Resident Evil is celebrating its 30th anniversary in 2026, and it has been a big one, from Zach Cregger's critically acclaimed film adaptation to the new game Resident Evil Requiem, and the cherry on top would be a Game of the Year win. Set three decades after the destruction of Raccoon City, Grace Ashcroft is an FBI investigator who looks into a string of deaths at an abandoned hotel, where her mother was murdered. Her path intersects with Leon S. Kennedy, with the duo trying to uncover the conspiracy tied to the Umbrella's lingering legacy. Resident Evil Requiem was one of the first games to come out this year, and as soon as it launched, everyone knew it was a shoo-in for Game of the Year. The dual-protagonist gameplay gave players the best of both worlds, with one side focusing on the claustrophobic horror vibe with stealth and puzzle-solving, and the other side emphasizing high-octane combat. This freshened-up gameplay works perfectly alongside the remarkable audio, which made the atmosphere even more terrifying. Indeed, Resident Evil Requiem is a near-perfect video game that could have taken the ultimate award, if not for the last-minute release of the most anticipated video game of all time. 1 ‘Grand Theft Auto VI’ (2026) Image via Rockstar Games Let's be real, as soon as the Game Awards confirmed its eligibility, Grand Theft Auto VI instantly became the favorite to win Game of the Year. Rockstar is one of the most influential video game studios, and gamers have been waiting 13 years for the next Grand Theft Auto game, easily making it a cultural event that will slow the world down. Returning to the sun-soaked streets of Vice City, this game will follow Lucia and Jason, two lovers who maneuver the crime-filled world to rise from small-time smugglers to underworld kingpins. However, nothing seems to go as planned in a world as chaotic as this one. No one is denying that Grand Theft Auto VI could be the best video game of all time, but the controversy comes from the fact that the game wasn't even out at the time of the nominations. Some gamers aren't happy that a game not readily available at the time of the announcement received a nomination, but journalists have been playing it for a good while. Yet, the reviews were as good as anyone hoped, tying the original Ocarina of Time as the highest-rated title on Metacritic, becoming the only 21st-century title to receive a 99 score. Grand Theft Auto VI will be the biggest video game ever, and the eventual announcement of it winning Game of the Year won't be a shock to players.

Original Source

Read the full article at Collider →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.