Epstein victims look to Second Circuit to revive BNY Mellon liability suit

Epstein victims look to Second Circuit to revive BNY Mellon liability suit

While victims have won hefty settlements with other banks, the federal appeals court was skeptical that BNY Mellon was close enough to Jeffrey Epstein’s crimes.MANHATTAN (CN) — Amid a broader effort to hold financial institutions accountable for their relationships with Jeffrey Epstein, the Second Circuit on Wednesday grappled with just how far removed a bank can be from the late pedophile financier and still face liability.The case involves The Bank of New York Mellon, which a Jane Doe plaintiff accused in a 2025 class action of processing nearly $380 million in payments to victims of Epstein’s sex-trafficking operation. It’s similar to civil suits brought against Bank of America, JPMorgan Chase and Deutsche Bank — each of which reached settlements with victims totaling hundreds of millions of dollars.But unlike those cases, a lower-court judge dismissed the suit against BNY Mellon on the grounds that it lacked a “sufficient nexus” to Epstein’s scheme.“It is different from the other cases that we had against JP Morgan and Bank of America, where there was a direct banking relationship with Jeffrey Epstein,” Sigrid McCawley, the Boies Schiller Flexner attorney representing Doe, admitted to the Second Circuit on Wednesday. The firm has previously represented numerous other victims of Epstein’s crimes, including Virginia Roberts Giuffre, who died by suicide last year.In this case, BNY Mellon was acting as a correspondent bank, an institution that acts as an intermediary to process certain transactions. Still, McCawley argued that BNY Mellon knew — or should have known — about Epstein’s crimes.“Mr. Epstein, or Epstein’s entities, weren’t their customer,” U.S. Circuit Judge Richard Wesley, a George W. Bush appointee, stated from the bench. “Their customer was a bank that was doing business with Mr. Epstein.”McCawley agreed but added that correspondent banks still have requirements like Know Your Customer that put the onus on BNY Mellon to do its due diligence. Wesley seemed unconvinced, noting that BNY Mellon’s scrutinized transactions were with Deutsche Bank — which had Epstein as a customer — not Epstein himself. Holding BNY Mellon liable here could have “broad-ranging” effects, Wesley said.“I’ve seen this on several terrorism cases,” he said. “Generally, the correspondent bank has to have knowledge of or information about that banking relationship between customer and respondent bank before the correspondent bank somehow is cast into a responsibility to know.”Felicia Ellsworth, the WilmerHale lawyer for BNY Mellon, argued that her client’s “arm’s length banking transactions” weren’t enough to show a true participation in Epstein’s schemes.“This is at least one step, if not two steps removed from the type of direct knowledge that has been found sufficient at [this] stage,” Ellsworth claimed.Rounding out Wednesday’s three-judge panel was U.S. Circuit Judge Jose Cabranes, a Bill Clinton appointee, and U.S. Circuit Judge Beth Robinson, a Joe Biden appointee. The judges didn’t issue a ruling immediately after the half-hour hearing.Doe, now a Florida resident, says she met Epstein in 2011 while living in Russia. She argues Epstein, between 2011 and 2019, sexually abused her at least 100 times and says financial institutions like BNY Mellon, among others, helped perpetuate that abuse by overlooking red flags of his criminality.Specifically, she says BNY Mellon extended a line of credit to MC2 — the sham modeling agency Epstein used to recruit victims of his sex-trafficking venture — and failed to file necessary Suspicious Activity Reports, despite purportedly being aware of Epstein’s crimes.Doe and other victims won big settlements from the other banks on that basis. Earlier this year, a federal judge in Manhattan greenlit a $72.5 million settlement package from Bank of America, which the victims claimed “purposely and deliberately” failed to file reports detailing Epstein’s suspicious banking activities until after his jailhouse death in 2019.BNY Mellon has repeatedly insisted that it had no involvement in Epstein’s schemes.Subscribe to our free newslettersOur weekly newsletter Closing Arguments offers the latest about ongoing trials, major litigation and rulings in courthouses around the U.S. and the world, while the monthly Under the Lights dishes the legal dirt from Hollywood, sports, Big Tech and the arts.Additional Reads

Original Source

Read the full article at Courthousenews →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.