Employers risk costly dismissal mistakes

Employers risk costly dismissal mistakes

HR professional, Dylan Downes (File photo) Employers who dismiss workers without following proper disciplinary procedures could face significant legal consequences, even when misconduct has been established, a senior human resources professional has warned. Dylan Downes, human resources manager at PVH Group, said employers must distinguish between misconduct that warrants dismissal and offences serious enough to justify immediate termination without notice or notice pay. In an article examining dismissal practices in Barbados, Downes noted that dismissal disputes were a growing concern and that rushing disciplinary proceedings could prove costly, particularly in cases involving summary dismissal. He noted the Caribbean Court of Justice’s (CCJ) 2025 ruling in Massy Stores v Forde, which affirmed that procedural fairness is an implicit term of all employment contracts in Barbados. Under that principle, employers must inform workers of allegations against them, provide a genuine opportunity to respond and hold a disciplinary meeting before reaching a decision. Even where dismissal appears inevitable, the employer must follow a fair process and determine whether immediate termination or a lesser sanction is justified. You Might Be Interested In Downes shared that disciplinary proceedings often begin with paid suspension while allegations are investigated. However, suspension is a precautionary measure rather than a disciplinary sanction. HR professional, Dylan Downes (File photo) Although paying suspended employees may create pressure to conclude investigations quickly, employers should allow sufficient time to establish the facts. Investigations involving multiple witnesses or complex evidence may take days or weeks, and rushing the process could result in a finding of unfair dismissal. Once an investigation is completed, the employee should receive a written invitation to a disciplinary meeting outlining the allegations, possible consequences and the right to be accompanied by a representative. Downes said employees must also be given reasonable time to prepare their responses. Seven days is generally recognised as reasonable, although some circumstances may require a longer period. Employers should reasonably consider legitimate requests for postponement, but repeated or unjustified requests do not have to delay proceedings indefinitely. In appropriate circumstances, a disciplinary hearing may proceed in an employee’s absence if reasonable efforts have been made to allow participation. Downes also warned against treating every breach of company policy as grounds for summary dismissal. Gross misconduct, he said, involves conduct so serious that it fundamentally undermines the trust and confidence necessary for the employment relationship to continue. Examples may include theft, physical assault, deliberate falsification of records and severe harassment. However, serious misconduct does not automatically justify dismissal without notice or notice pay. Under the Employment Rights Act 2012, disciplinary action should generally be progressive where appropriate. Persistent lateness or repeated insubordination, for example, may warrant formal warnings before eventual dismissal. “A breach of company policy does not, by itself, justify summary dismissal,” Downes shared. He said employers must consider the seriousness of the conduct, the circumstances surrounding the incident and whether a lesser sanction would be sufficient. An employee’s length of service, disciplinary record and the consistent application of workplace policies may also influence the assessment. Downes noted that a worker with 30 years of unblemished service might be treated differently from someone with only a year of service, although long service does not exempt an employee from disciplinary rules. He added that employers could still dismiss workers with the required notice or notice pay where termination was justified but the conduct did not meet the threshold for summary dismissal. Misclassifying misconduct as gross misconduct simply to avoid paying notice could expose employers to substantial liability. “The lesson from Barbadian employment law is clear: not every policy breach warrants dismissal, and not every act that warrants dismissal justifies summary dismissal,” he said. Downes encouraged employers dealing with complex disciplinary matters to seek advice from an employment lawyer or the Barbados Employers’ Confederation before taking action. He added: “Ultimately, shortcuts and disproportionate sanctions can leave employers liable for far more than the cost they sought to avoid.” (SM)

Original Source

Read the full article at Barbadostoday →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.