A federal appeals court appeared skeptical on Wednesday of a lawsuit brought by a coalition of anti-abortion activists seeking to strike down Minnesota’s abortion laws using a novel approach that argues the state laws violate the due process rights and parental rights by separating the pregnant mother from her unborn baby.A three-judge panel on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 8th Circuit heard arguments from lawyers for anti-abortion activists, abortion providers, and Minnesota officials over whether to revive the lawsuit, which a federal district court tossed last year. Harold Cassidy, a lawyer for the anti-abortion activists, argued to the panel that the Minnesota and U.S. constitutions protect against involuntary operations separating a woman from her unborn child but that state laws do not ensure a woman’s choice to terminate her pregnancy is voluntary.“The Minnesota Constitution requires officials of the state to delegate, empower, license, and protect doctors and nurses to terminate a pregnant mother’s existing relationship with her child by killing her child, and forbid the state legislature and the state officials from providing any due process protections to ensure that the mother’s waiver of her rights is actually voluntary, informed, and known,” Cassidy said. “Even deliberatively involuntary terminations and killing of the child is allowed. The prohibition of it is forbidden.” The panel of judges did not appear receptive to the arguments made by Cassidy, questioning what standing the coalition of crisis pregnancy centers and anti-abortion activists have to bring the lawsuit in the first place.“When Dobbs overturned Roe, the [Supreme] Court suggested that while the states were no longer required to legalize abortion, states may do so on their own. Dobbs did not, however, hold or suggest that a state was free to violate a mother’s 14th Amendment rights in the process,” the anti-abortion activists said in their brief to the appeals court.U.S. District Judge Nancy Brasel, an appointee of President Donald Trump, tossed the lawsuit in August 2025, finding that the group lacked standing to bring the lawsuit, but she was also dubious of the legal argument pushed under the 14th Amendment. Margaret Jacot, arguing on behalf of Minnesota officials, similarly urged the panel to toss out the lawsuit, claiming that the anti-abortion activists were trying to have the court strike down a law because they do not like it, not because it is illegal.“You can’t sue the government just because you want new or different laws,” Jacot said. “That’s what the political process is for.”“They’re unhappy because Minnesota hasn’t passed the restrictive abortion laws that other states like South Dakota passed. Rather than pursue the political process and call their legislators or lobby for a constitutional amendment, they came to federal court, but that’s not what our court system is for,” Jacot added.DC CIRCUIT WEIGHS TRUMP’S TAKEOVER OF TWO AGENCIES AFTER SUPREME COURT AGENCY HEAD REMOVAL RULINGThe 8th Circuit panel included U.S. Circuit Judges Steven Colloton, an appointee of former President George W. Bush; Bobby Shepherd, also a Bush appointee; and Jane Kelly, an appointee of former President Barack Obama. The panel did not indicate how or when it would rule.Earlier this week, the 8th Circuit grappled with whether to revive Missouri’s lawsuit against Starbucks’s diversity, equity, and inclusion policies for alleged racial discrimination. That panel of three judges from the appeals court appeared split on whether to allow the lawsuit to proceed.
Eighth Circuit grapples with novel parental rights lawsuit against Minnesota’s abortion laws
Full Article
Original Source
Read the full article at Washingtonexaminer →KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.