Members of a small Tairāwhiti community are reeling over the prospect of having to leave their land, after a report from the Gisborne District Council (GDC) identified "managed retreat" or "retreat" as the long-term option for them.The report - 5F Storm Independent Review - is the result of a review commissioned by the Gisborne District Council into several neighbouring areas devastated by a storm at the end of January. It was carried out by engineering firm Tonkin + Taylor, and released to affected residents last month.The three "catchments" examined were Wharekahika or Hicks Bay, Onepoto Bay and Punaruku, which includes the settlement of Te Araroa. According to the report, the most recent census data showed 270 people lived in the areas.For all three areas, the report ruled out "structural protection measures" because they were deemed either infeasible or ineffective.It noted the "extreme rainfall" during the 21-22 January storm caused widespread landsliding and flooding in the area. It also stated that climate change was expected to increase the frequency of extreme rainfall events like the January storm.As a result "managed retreat from the most at-risk properties is an option in all catchments, especially Punaruku where there was an acute risk to life". The report also identified that for some areas at risk, the main long-term option is managed retreat.Several residents have rejected the GDC review, and have said the process lacked transparency and consultation.Nina McClutchie runs food caravan 35 Eat street at Te Araroa Holiday Park, and said she and holiday park owner Bill Martin were blindsided by the review report."We knew that there was one being put together, but… it just landed on us. We had no specific date or idea that it was going to be as quick as what it was."[We're] extremely upset, especially around the relocation topic because…a small group of us have been working hard to get the camp cleaned up and to get open, hopefully again for Christmas."So for this relocation topic to come up is quite disturbing because none of us want to go.McClutchie criticised the lack of communication from GDC over the entire process, and the absence of timeframes in the report over potential options."We've asked what does a managed retreat look like, and they weren't able to answer at this stage, and they haven't even given us a guideline of how long it's going to take them to answer us so I'm out on the wind there."I think it's shocking. You really can't come to us and say that without being really transparent right across the board with how this is going to work."Flood damage at Te Araroa Holiday Park.RNZ / Baz MacdonaldSean Deery is an advocate for several affected parties, including McClutchie, and Pikitanga marae in Te Araroa.He believed the GDC-commissioned report needed to be independently reviewed and a more inclusive process where affected residents and whānau were properly involved needed to be implemented. Deery is a project manager and has whakapapa links to the area through his grandmother."They should all be there at the table at the beginning of the process, so everyone understands what is going to happen, how it is going to happen, and there's buy-in from all the stakeholders"If you don't get the buy-in, people don't understand; they get the wrong idea."And this is why I'm saying that the council - in my view - has rushed things... and they've left out the community."Deery also said he was still waiting on information about the review process he asked GDC for five months ago.GDC principal scientist Murray Cave disagreed with comments the review process lacked consultation."We bent over backwards to make sure that we talked to everyone that we needed to talk to."Since the review's come out, we've actually spoken to some of those parties multiple times, where they've sought further clarification, and that process will be ongoing."A peer review into the Tonkin + Taylor report had also been confirmed.Cave also said all scenarios would've been discussed during the review process. He couldn't recall if the words "retreat" or "managed retreat" were used specifically, but said any shock around the scenarios was news to him."Where we have those areas that were raised about managed retreat - which is in some instances relating to specific properties- you've got to realise that a lot of those properties... already had red placards on them, so it would not have been a surprise."Cave also confirmed to Checkpoint that the GDC would not be offering buyout payments, and said any money would need to come from central government."If it was being made available to us from the Crown, we'd clearly consider that as an option. But that is something for the government to consider," he said.In the meantime, Cave said monitoring and alert systems for the area had been improved, and more work was being commissioned around future risk.
East Cape resident says talk of managed retreat 'extremely upsetting' and 'shocking'
Full Article
Original Source
Read the full article at Rnz →KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.