Published Nov 18, 2026, 4:08 PM EST Amanda Kay Oaks is a writer and lifelong book nerd. She has been writing about books on the internet for over 10 years, with prior bylines at Book Riot and ComicBook.com. Though she reads across most genres, Amanda Kay is particularly fond of romance, cozy fantasy, and books with strong female characters. Dungeon Crawler Carl fans have been treated to an influx of new behind-the-scenes tidbits thanks to the new Deluxe Edition, which hit shelves on November 17. In its pages, Princess Donut herself interviews series author Matt Dinniman. Like the charismatic royal she is, Donut uncovers some truly shocking information about the author, including his true feelings about Cocker Spaniels. But in the same conversation, Dinniman also reveals that Dungeon Crawler Carl Book 5 almost went in an entirely different direction. The new deluxe edition of Dungeon Crawler Carl isn't just stunning on the outside. It includes some fun bonus content for readers, including new artwork and, most importantly, a new interview with Matt Dinniman. The interview includes commentary from Princess Donut, and like most of the cat's antics, it's a real treat. While there are certainly some "just for fun" tidbits, including Donut's opinion of the author, Dinniman digs into some interesting behind-the-scenes lore that just might surprise readers, as well. The whole thing is well worth a read, giving readers yet another reason to add the Deluxe Edition to their shelves. You can purchase the new Dungeon Crawler Carl: Deluxe Edition here. Dungeon Crawler Carl Book 5 Almost Had a Very Different Story This article contains potential spoilers for The Butcher's Masquerade, Book 5 in the Dungeon Crawler Carl series.As readers who've made it to Book 5 in their Dungeon Crawler Carl journey may recall, The Butcher's Masquerade takes us to the dungeon's sixth floor. This is a highly anticipated moment in Carl and Donut's journey, as it brings them into contact with intergalactic tourists who can hunt down crawlers in the World Dungeon for the first time. But in his conversation with Princess Donut, Dinniman reveals that we almost got a very different Book 5. Donut asked Dinniman, "What scene was the hardest to cut from the Dungeon Crawler Carl series?" In response, he shared a peek behind the curtain of his writing process. And it's every bit as chaotic as you might expect, with the writer affirming that he has, "cut literally thousands of scenes" from the series. Much like Carl, Dinniman makes up the story as he goes, which means plenty of moments don't wind up making the final cut. But one cut scene could very well have changed everything in Book 5. In the original version of The Butcher's Masquerade, Carl would've approached The Hunting Grounds quite differently. As we know, Carl brings his usual explosive tactics to this level, kicking things off by turning the hunters of Zockau into the hunted. In the surprise attack, Carl takes out a massive number of hunters, earning some serious rewards in the process. However, his reign of terror was almost much, much more destructive. In what he calls one of his favorite deleted scenes, Dinniman reveals that Carl originally killed, "every hunter in the city of Zockau except for Vrah." Not only would this have massively changed the entire dynamic of floor six, it likely would've impacted the plot pretty heavily, too. After culling every hunter but Vrah, Carl would've spent the rest of the floor hunting her down. This different take on the attack on Zockau wouldn't just have changed the early chapters, but likely the entire trajectory of Book 5 as we know it. You can purchase The Butcher's Masquerade here. Deleted Dungeon Crawler Carl Scene Could've Robbed Us of Some Major Book 5 Moments Dinniman doesn't elaborate much more on how The Butcher's Masquerade would've differed if Carl had truly eliminated all of the hunters but Vrah so early on. He also doesn't say much about why he opted to go in a different direction, except that he simply changed his mind. However, it's likely that the focus on tracking down Vrah could've come at the expense of some of Book 5's biggest moments. Of course, later encounters with other hunters would've been cut, since they'd already be dead. That alone would massively change some of Book 5's biggest moments, including the reveal that the AI is going rogue. But the implications of this deleted scene would be even bigger. If Book 5 had focused on hunting Vrah, we might've lost a good bit of character development for Mayor Princess Donut. Signet's story could also have played a smaller role, which would've been disappointing after so much buildup to its continuation on floor six. Of course, it's also possible that Dinniman would've retained these key elements even with a greater focus on Vrah over other hunters. At any rate, Dinniman clearly decided that leaving more than just Vrah alive to challenge Carl, Donut, and the party was the better move. We may never know just how different the story would've been without those other hunter encounters, and that's probably for the best. Of course, there could always be more reveals in future Deluxe Edition interviews and beyond. Dungeon Crawler Carl Publisher(s) Penguin Random House Publication Date September 21, 2020 Number of Pages 444 ISBN# 979-8688591507 Author(s) Matt Dinniman
Dungeon Crawler Carl Game-Changing Scene Was Cut From Book 5
Full Article
Original Source
Read the full article at Screenrant →KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.