DOJ urges judge in SPLC case to prevent jury nullification

DOJ urges judge in SPLC case to prevent jury nullification

Federal prosecutors want to keep defense lawyers in the April 2027 Southern Poverty Law Center fraud trial from giving arguments that could lead to “jury nullification.”The leftist charity and its codefendant, Heidi Beirich, should not be allowed to tell jurors any narratives that could sway them with sympathy rather than facts, the Justice Department told an Alabama federal court in a Monday motion. The DOJ referred to the potential strategy as jury nullification, the practice of jurors acquitting defendants they believe are guilty because they disagree with the law’s enforcement. Recommended Stories Prosecutors suspect attorneys may defend the SPLC’s undercover informant program, which forms the crux of its alleged crimes, with “irrelevant” points such as the supposed “good intentions” behind the program, the filing said. Grand jurors indicted the SPLC in April and Beirich in August over an alleged scheme to fund racist groups through undercover field sources, nicknamed “Fs,” despite telling donors their money would combat them. The new DOJ motion responded to prior claims that the defendants used the field sources to faithfully provide information to law enforcement on hate groups. “This Court should exclude any evidence or arguments about the SPLC’s work unrelated to the F Program, any evidence or arguments that the SPLC pursued the F Program for good reasons, or any evidence of arguments of any good acts accomplished because of the F program,” the DOJ wrote.The filing added that this evidence could confuse jurors and amount to “good character evidence,” or narratives about a defendant’s overall moral conduct that are irrelevant.SPLC WAS ONCE SUSPECTED OF MORE CRIMES THAN CURRENT CHARGES SHOWBoth defendants have also sought to have their charges dismissed as politically motivated and unconstitutional. Trump-appointed U.S. District Judge Emily Marks denied the SPLC’s motion to dismiss the case in August. Beirich is separately fighting for her motion with documents showing the inner workings of the Trump administration’s SPLC investigation.The records indicated the FBI began looking into the SPLC with suggestions from conservative advocates who resented being included on the watchdog group’s “Hate Map,” the Washington Examiner previously reported.

Original Source

Read the full article at Washingtonexaminer →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.