There is something about hearing “come ye saints, come ye sinners” that sets off a Pavlovian response in my brain; a physical trigger to sling the (dirty) Diet Coke back and turn the volume up. It means The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives is back, this time with its OC-set spinoff: The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives: Orange County.In the show’s marketing, Hulu leans into the California setting as the clear divide between SLOMW: OC and its Utah predecessor. SLOMW: OC isn’t as ensconced in the shadow of the Mormon church as the Utah show is. Instead, it offers a more laid-back version of Mormonism (they drink! they get tattoos! they’re in throuples!). But in taking the “Mormon” out of the “Mormon Wives,” are we missing out on what makes the show so interesting?It’s a bold choice to greenlight a spinoff about Mormons without actually casting any Mormons. In fact, of the eight new cast members (Jen Affleck is the only familiar face), only four identify as practicing Mormons at all: Mayci Neely’s identical-looking sister McCall DaPron, McCall’s bestie Jordan McClanahan, YouTuber Madison Bontempo, and Ashleigh Pease.Meanwhile, the other half of the cast have either left the church altogether, as is the case with influencers Aspyn Ovard and Salome Andea, or were never religious to begin with like podcasters Avery Woods and Bobbi Althoff. It’s the “Molly Mormons,” or traditional Mormons, vs. the “Black Cats,” the rebels of the group. What connects these women is not so much a shared religion as a shared career path: influencing and podcasting.SLOMW Utah’s strength was its portrayal of the contradictory rules of Mormonism. For example, what do you mean it goes against the church to drink caffeine but it’s totally fine to get high off laughing gas at a Botox appointment?? The rules only got more interesting as the show progressed and the women went from housewives to reality TV megastars overnight. Suddenly they were grappling with bigger religious conundrums: how to be both subordinate in the church and a breadwinner at home.SLOMW: OC takes a different approach by focusing more on influencer mom drama, shifting away from the central tension of the show: women striving for independence and equality while navigating deeply patriarchal relationships. Take Mayci in season 5 when she fends off a fourth pregnancy request from her mother, sister, and husband (keep in mind, she just popped out baby #3!). Or Jessi, whose husband Jordan felt emasculated by the number of zeros in her paycheck.In the Orange County-set spinoff, the men are curiously absent. Madison, Salome, and Aspyn are the only women to feature their romantic partners on screen—and even then it’s only a few moments of the show’s eight-episode run. The absence of the men feels like a strategic response to the DadTok hate that plagued the Utah show. But Hulu may have mistaken our TFP relationship fatigue for not wanting to see messy relationships at all.Instead the show has channeled all that messy relationship tension into the women’s dynamics with each other. Their fights originate from the different ways they interpret feminism, religion, money, and power. Take McCall and Bobbi, for instance. McCall, who sees the group’s religious divide as her “McCalling” to convert, is the clear villain of season 1 because she tries to center Mormonism in the show. It’s Bobbi, hoodie pulled up and strings pulled tight, who brings McCall back down to earth and challenges her to see her faith through different perspectives.“Show me the [bible] verse that says to be a bitch and talk shit on people, please,” Bobbi throws out in episode 4 after learning McCall made a dig about her comedy show and threatened to have another cast member replaced for not piling on Bobbi too. Later in the season, Bobbi confronts McCall over her drama with Aspyn Ovard and urges her to rethink her mean girl internet campaign. She points out that McCall might not agree with all of Aspyn’s life decisions, but Aspyn has a terminally ill child; McCall should be the bigger, more religious woman and show her some grace.If the show wants to lean away from messy marriages, then it needs to lean into the messiness of religion in friendships. What are the boundaries that divide? What are the boundaries that unite? People hate McCall but, sorry, she is very good mess! Watching her try (and fail) to convert Bobbi into wearing pastels and saying a singular nice word about the church is the most fun I’ve had in a while. Without the religious tension, the show becomes hot, rich women fighting in public, and there are stronger contenders in that genre (hello, Real Housewives).Maybe taking the “Mormon” out of “Mormon Wives” will rejuvenate a flailing brand, but the religious tension has to stay a priority regardless of the women’s religious affiliations. Taking the “Mormon” out of “Mormon Wives” is bad for the show—and bad for the mess!
Does It Matter That We’ve Taken the “Mormon” Out of the Mormon Wives?
Full Article
Original Source
Read the full article at Cosmopolitan →KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.