Developer pushes 10th Circuit to reappraise Denver’s affordable housing scheme

Developer pushes 10th Circuit to reappraise Denver’s affordable housing scheme

A Colorado real estate developer challenged the government program, claiming its fees or mandatory cut-rate pricing threaten to drive up costs on “attainably priced” LEED certified homes.DENVER (CN) — A Colorado developer asked the 10th Circuit on Monday to restore its challenge to Denver’s affordable housing program, which requires developers to pay hefty fees or sell 10% of a development at below market rates.“The city of Denver refuses to issue a permit to redT to construct a home until they pay $70,000 in fees,” said Pacific Legal Foundation attorney David Deerson, who represents developer redT.As part of plans to create more affordable housing, the Denver City Council requires real estate developers to pay so-called linkage fees on new construction, ranging from $1.99 to $7.22 per square foot. Developers can avoid the fees if they set aside 10% of a project to be sold at below market rate prices for 99 years.Developer redT says the scheme puts it in a pickle when it comes to constructing “attainably priced,” LEED certified quadruplexes. Under the ordinance, redT must give up some units or pay the fees. For one property, the fees add up to $24,962. Another fourplex’s fees would cost redT $44,917.Imagining the consequences, U.S. Circuit Judge Joel Carson asked whether he would be forced to give away a 10th home to a total stranger, if his goal was to build nine homes for his nine children.“Thankfully I don’t have nine children,” the Donald Trump appointee quipped.Besides losing a 10th home, Deerson said a family building a single-family home would either have to give away their home or build a second home for the affordable housing program to avoid Denver’s linkage fee.Calling the scheme “an unsustainable paradox in land use extractions law,” redT sued the city and county of Denver in May 2025.George W. Bush-appointed U.S. District Judge Philip Brimmer granted Denver’s motion to dismiss in March. redT appealed, arguing the scheme amounts to an unconstitutional taking.City attorney Adam Hernandez defended Denver’s program, characterizing it as a restrictive covenant that does not amount to a government taking.“Think about the bundle of sticks,” said U.S. Circuit Judge Richard Federico. “Property rights are a bundle of sticks, and one of those rights is the right to dispose of property. Can we look at that and say the mandatory affordable housing ordinance allows them to sell a unit, but they can’t do it on the open market and get the highest value possible — doesn’t that deprive them of the right to dispose of property?”In answering the Joe Biden appointee, Hernandez argued the Denver City Council can shorten the covenant or decide against enforcing it.Carson said, “We can talk about changing it, but by the time you change the law, it’s too late. You changing the law five years from now has nothing to do with this case.”U.S. Circuit Judge Harris Hartz, also a George W. Bush appointee, pressed Hernandez to acknowledge the program as a government taking.“Here there’s a restriction that runs with the land. That’s a taking,” he said. “You can defend this with your analysis, you can say it’s necessary and justified, but to say it’s not a taking, I don’t understand how you can do that.”Hernandez stood his ground and asked the court to affirm the lower court’s dismissal.The court did not indicate when or how it would decide the case.Subscribe to our free newslettersOur weekly newsletter Closing Arguments offers the latest about ongoing trials, major litigation and rulings in courthouses around the U.S. and the world, while the monthly Under the Lights dishes the legal dirt from Hollywood, sports, Big Tech and the arts.Additional Reads

Original Source

Read the full article at Courthousenews →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.