Believing the midterm “blue wave” has given them a popular mandate along with their control of both houses of Congress, Democrats are contemplating how to use their restored power by claiming to reduce consumer costs, particularly in health care. Presumptive incoming House Speaker Hakeem Jeffries, D-N.Y., said, “We have to reverse the Medicaid cuts. We should extend the Affordable Care Act [enhanced premium] tax credits.” Both actions have been described by Democrats as “low hanging fruit,” in contrast to the more problematic action of passing Medicare-for-All, which Bernie Sanders, I-Vt., claims is “now supported by 66 percent of the American people.” Each of these three actions might seem like reasonable responses to the complaints of “unaffordability.” The first two are bad mistakes. Medicare-for-All, a favorite of the radical wing of the party, would be a medical and financial disaster. Medicaid Cuts Covid lockdowns drove millions of Americans out of work. Loss of employment meant loss of both income and employer-sponsored health insurance. With neither job nor money, lockdown victims became eligible for and enrolled in Medicaid. Enrollment went from 71 million in 2020 to nearly 90 million in 2022. Most were able-bodied adults. According to Bureau of Labor Statistics, the U.S. economy regained all the jobs lost during the pandemic and added more. However, many who re-qualified for employer-sponsored health insurance (ESHI) remained on Medicaid because it is free to them, whereas ESHI requires an employee contribution of about 20 percent of the premium (averaging $6,850 last year for family coverage). Most of the Medicaid cuts proposed by the Trump administration and vigorously opposed by Democrats would affect these able-bodied persons whose continued enrollment is inappropriate and diverts resources from medically needy individuals. Enhanced Subsidies Subsidies or advance premium tax credits were part of the original 2010 Affordable Care Act (ACA) legislation and were provided starting in 2014 when the ACA was implemented. Subsidies are paid directly from Treasury to insurance companies to offset premium costs on a sliding scale with contributions decreasing as income increases. There was a cap — no subsidy for those above 400 percent of the poverty line. In response to Covid, the Biden administration passed the American Rescue Plan Act of 2021 (ARPA). As insurance costs continued to rise while millions were out of work and had no income, ARPA “enhanced” ACA subsidies that help pay for insurance obtained through ACA marketplaces. The cap was discontinued, the amount of subsidy was increased, and eligibility standards were relaxed. Initially these enhancements were intended to sunset by 2023 but were extended through December 2025. ARPA also “enhanced” Medicaid enrollment by relaxing eligibility standards. The two enhancements combined cost taxpayers at least $1.9 trillion, which was added to the national debt. Seeking to force Trump to keep the enhancements beyond 2025, Democrats shut down the government from Oct. 1, 2025, to Nov. 12, 2025. The Trump administration did not accede to the coercion and allowed the enhancements to lapse. With insurance costs constantly rising every year, Americans are bitterly complaining about unaffordability. The newly empowered Democrats are likely to seek restoration of the enhancements. This will ease the cost burden on some consumers while providing a windfall to insurance companies. Patients will gain nothing. There will be great political optics. Medicare-for-All is a misnomer — the plan should be called “Medicaid-for-All,” as it functions like Medicaid, not Medicare. However, Medicare-for-All is considered more attractive to the public than the more honest “Medicaid-for-All.” Medicare requires payments from enrollees; Medicaid and Medicare-for-All do not. Medicare includes private insurance and allows patient choice; Medicaid and Medicare-for-All do not. Medicare-for-All (H.R. 1384) is a total federal takeover of healthcare, aka socialized medicine or universal healthcare. All residents — citizens, visa-holders, and illegals — will have government insurance. There will be no private insurance. Fee-for-service is prohibited; Washington will establish a “global budget.” Insurance will cover essentially all medical care, services, and goods, viz., drugs. Medical decision-making will be made by Washington, not by doctors or patients. Several new government agencies and bureaucracies will be created. Massive Costs American workers and their employers have been paying 2.9 percent of taxable wages into Medicare for 60 years. Even so, according to the trustees, the Medicare Trust, which pays for seniors’ inpatient and facility care, will be insolvent (run out of money) by 2036. In 2018, Charles Blahous of the Mercatus Center calculated the cost of the Medicare-for-All proposal as $32.1 trillion over ten years. Shortly thereafter, Bernie Sanders admitted his plan would cost between $30 trillion and $40 trillion. Since 2018, U.S. spending on healthcare has increased more than 30 percent. If the earlier estimates were in present-day dollars, Medicare-for-All might cost $41 trillion to $52 trillion. The entire U.S. national debt stands at $40 trillion. The combined GDP of all nations on earth is currently $128 trillion. Federal law prohibits Medicaid coverage for illegal residents. Despite this, California and Oregon have approved enrollment of more than 1 million illegals, which raised the cost basis of Medicaid. If Democrats were able to pass Medicare-for-All and made an additional 5-10 million illegals eligible, the cost projections above would necessarily be further increased. At least half of all U.S. healthcare spending pays for BURRDEN: bureaucracy, unnecessary rules and regulations, directives, enforcement, noncompliance activities. Infrastructure cost for just the ACA alone was $1.76 trillion. The cost of creating and implementing a new and more complex Medicare-for-All system could easily be ten times that amount. Worse Medical Care The effect on medical care of Medicare-for-All is even more disastrous than the fiscal impact. The plan is a complete take-over of healthcare by the federal government, single payer on steroids. There are huge penalties if patients try to pay doctors directly. Private insurance is banned. A thriving black market will develop for timely, personal care for wealthy individuals as described in Dan Putkowski’s Universal Coverage, a book that was dystrophic fiction when written (2009) but may becoming fact. Single payer systems control their spending by rationing care. The budget dictates — medical needs must accept and adapt. That is why 9 percent of the population in the United Kingdom (6.24 million individuals) are on medical waiting lists with one-third waiting 18 weeks or longer. Cancer studies have shown even a one-month delay in diagnosis is associated with increased mortality. Death-by-queue, a phrase coined for the British single payer system, refers to people dying while waiting in line (a queue) for care. Americans with both Medicaid and Tricare coverage are already experiencing such avoidable death. The necessity to ration care here by Medicare-for-all will create mass death-by-queue. Conclusion Three healthcare changes are under consideration by the new Democrat majority in Congress. Canceling Medicaid cuts would reward able-bodied persons who should not be covered by Medicaid. Keeping them on the rolls would take away services and goods required by medically needy Americans. Extending ACA enhanced subsidies would be income redistribution from taxpayers to insurance coffers with no benefit to patients other than a false and temporary sense of reduced consumer costs. Medicare-for-All would be an extinction event for the U.S. financially and for Americans medically — they will experience mass death-by-queue. Deane Waldman, M.D., MBA, is professor emeritus of pediatrics, pathology, and decision science; former director of the Center for Healthcare Policy at the Texas Public Policy Foundation; former director of the New Mexico Health Insurance Exchange; and author of award-winning “Become an Empowered Patient.” Follow him on X @DrDeaneW or visit the website www.empowerpatients.info. ACACharles Blahousdeath by queueenhanced subsidiesfederal subsidieshealth insurance companiesHealthcareMedicaidMedicaid cutsMedicare-for-allObamacaresingle payer
Democrats’ ‘Medicare-For-All’ Plan Would Bankrupt America And Leave Americans Dead
Full Article
Original Source
Read the full article at Thefederalist →KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.