Delaware unlikely to win back its lost second House seat

Delaware unlikely to win back its lost second House seat

Two Delaware voters made a splash this month when they filed a federal lawsuit seeking a second House seat for the First State, which would raise the lower chamber’s 435-seat cap by one. The problem is that it’s highly unlikely their case will succeed given the historical record on this issue.Constitutional law experts have expressed skepticism about the lawsuit’s future. Michael Dimino, a law professor at Widener University Commonwealth Law School in Pennsylvania, said the plaintiffs have a “close to zero” chance of prevailing because the case has no basis in the Constitution.“The constitutional text says absolutely nothing about this issue that would create any constitutional right for any state to have representation beyond one member of the House,” he told the Washington Examiner, countering the plaintiffs’ argument. “Every state is constitutionally entitled to at least one, but there’s nothing that would give a state an entitlement to anything beyond one.” Delaware has a single at-large congressional district, represented by Rep. Sarah McBride (D-DE) since January 2025. The district has existed since 1789, but the state didn’t always have one House seat.Historical loss of a second seat Between 1813 and 1823, Delaware had a second representative following the 1810 census. But as the populations in other states grew relative to Delaware’s population, the congressional reapportionment process brought Delaware back down to one seat. This has remained the case ever since.Congressional districts are distributed among states based on population counts from the U.S. census every decade. By the time Delaware lost its second seat three years after the 1820 census, the House had 213 total seats.As the nation’s population grew significantly over the next century, the House’s size grew with it. The Permanent Apportionment Act of 1929 set the limit at 435 seats and established an automatic process to redistribute those seats among states after every decennial census.Congress could theoretically lift the seat cap by passing a new federal law, but there’s no indication that members of Congress have an appetite for such a plan. No constitutional amendment is required because the Constitution doesn’t fix the chamber’s size.The allocation of seats is determined by the method of equal proportions, a mathematical formula that has been in use since 1941. It guarantees that each of the 50 states gets at least one House seat, while the remaining 385 seats are allocated based on population size. Dimino explained that a court order in favor of the plaintiffs that grants Delaware a second seat, as unlikely as that outcome is, would come at the expense of other states.“There’s no constitutional imperative to draw a line that would give Delaware what it wants but wouldn’t give whatever the next state is what it wants,” he said. “Every kind of benefit that would go to Delaware would come out of somebody else, and you could expect those states to oppose it.”Current lawsuit The 21-page lawsuit, filed on Nov. 11 in Washington, D.C., urges the court to award Delaware one extra seat while preserving every other state’s representation if Congress fails to redress the alleged violation by a yet-to-be-determined deadline. The plaintiffs argue the 435-seat cap is unconstitutional as it relates to the 2020 apportionment.The complaint points to Montana as a model for why Delaware should get an additional representative. Both states have populations slightly more than 1 million people, but Montana has its population spread across two congressional districts.“A Delaware voter receives 54.8 percent of the representation per person that a Montana voter receives,” the lawsuit states. “Delaware’s population per Representative is 1.826 times Montana’s statewide average, the largest disparity between any two States.”The plaintiffs say they “experience the disparity throughout each congressional term” because “their single Representative serves nearly one million constituents, while Montana’s two Representatives together serve a population only 94,570 larger.”The lawsuit claims Delaware’s population is 990,837, but the U.S. Census Bureau puts the latest estimate at 1,059,952. It also undersells Montana’s population by nearly 60,000.Following the 2020 census, Montana regained its second House seat that was lost in the 1992 elections. Until then, the state’s second seat was in place for 80 years.The court filing also makes comparisons to Wyoming, which has nearly 600,000 people in one district, and Rhode Island, which has two districts with about 1.1 million people.The legal challenge was brought by Dave Redlawsk, a University of Delaware political science professor and a newly elected Delaware state representative, as well as a Delaware voter named Kevin Price. The defendants are listed as Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick, U.S. Census Bureau acting Director George Cook, and House Clerk Kevin McCumber.“A Delaware voter should not have half the representation of a Montana voter in the very chamber our Founders created to ensure equal representation,” Andrew Tutt, one of the attorneys for Redlawsk and Price, said in a statement provided to the Washington Examiner. “At its core, this lawsuit is about upholding that constitutional principle and challenging a 435-seat limit that Congress has left untouched for more than a century.”“We hope this suit will force a long-overdue conversation,” he continued, “both in the courts and across the country, about whether our system of representation is living up to the Constitution’s promise.”While Tutt is confident about his clients’ shot in court, Dimino believes the plaintiffs’ case is inherently flawed because it has no legal basis.“They’re making a political argument rather than a legal argument,” the professor said. “They’re trying to say we should, in some kind of normative sense, have an additional representative. But there’s nothing in the law that gives them a right to it. So their biggest problem is that to succeed on the legal claim, they have to come up with a legal basis for the claim that they don’t have.”Prior court challenges One of the plaintiffs’ primary obstacles is existing legal precedent in a past Supreme Court case.In a 2010 ruling addressing a lawsuit brought by voters in five states, including Delaware, a three-judge federal court in Mississippi ruled that Congress has constitutional authority to determine the House’s size and that the 435-seat limit was constitutionally permissible. In making its decision, the court relied on a 1992 Supreme Court decision.In Department of Commerce v. Montana, the Supreme Court unanimously ruled that the method of equal proportions was constitutionally permissible despite Montana’s challenge to the mathematical model.Regarding the 2010 case, the Supreme Court did not issue a decision resolving the constitutional question about the fixed House size or 435-seat cap.David Schleicher, a professor of property and urban law at Yale Law School, pointed to the 2010 and 1992 cases as evidence that it’s unlikely the active lawsuit will result in a favorable outcome for the plaintiffs.“Unless you’re going to have an infinitely sized House, you have to draw a line somewhere,” Schleicher said, per the Wilmington-based News Journal.2028 question The plaintiffs also face difficulty with how quickly they want the case to move. By the 2028 elections, they hope a second seat will be drawn. Dimino says that’s not enough time.“Any kind of final decision would have to occur not only before November 2028, but it would have to occur far enough before that the districts could be redrawn, primary elections could be had, candidates would have time to decide whether to run and get petition signatures and all the rest,” Dimino said.“So realistically, you’d have to conclude the litigation by maybe January 2028, and you could get a district court decision by then,” he added. “But there’s no way that you’re going to go through the entire circuit of litigation that quickly and win.”If the plaintiffs get their way, the change to Delaware’s representation would be made before the 2030 census. Dimino doesn’t think their case would have a better chance past 2030.DELAWARE VOTERS ASK FEDERAL COURT TO ADD SECOND HOUSE SEAT FOR STATETheir request to the federal court in Washington, D.C., came over a week after Democratic candidates won considerable majorities in both chambers of Congress this past election cycle. Dimino suspects the lawsuit is nothing more than a stunt to boost the number of House Democrats.“Presumably, the political leadership in Delaware would draw the extra district as a way of creating an additional Democratic seat,” Dimino said. “And if so, you’d increase the Democrats’ majority in the new Congress.”

Original Source

Read the full article at Washingtonexaminer →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.