A federal judge said the fisheries service improperly limited its review to preliminary surveying, leaving out the mining the leases could eventually allow.HONOLULU (CN) — Three days before the Interior Department planned to put the nation’s first deep-sea mining leases up for sale, a federal judge threw out a finding that had declared the sale wouldn’t likely harm endangered species.U.S. District Judge Jill Otake ruled Monday that the National Marine Fisheries Service violated the Endangered Species Act by reviewing only the sale of the leases and not the mining they could eventually lead to.“As extinction is permanent, caution and foresight before acting are necessary,” she said.The Marine Minerals Administration, formed this summer by merging two offshore energy bureaus, had planned to sell the leases Thursday for two areas of seabed northeast of American Samoa’s Manu‘a Islands covering more than 31 million acres.But the Donald Trump appointee for the District of Hawaii rejected the government’s interpretation of the proposed action, saying it ignored the ultimate purpose of the leases.“Limiting the agency action here to the lease sale and preliminary activities ignores the reality that the purpose of the leases being sold is eventually to conduct deep-sea mining,” she wrote in her 41-page order.The leases would initially allow companies to conduct only preliminary work, such as mapping and sampling the seabed. They could eventually allow companies to collect mineral-rich nodules from the ocean floor.Fa‘asao Amerika Samoa and Conservation Council for Hawaii, represented by Earthjustice, sued the fisheries service and Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick in August. They argued the agency didn’t consider what could happen after the leases were sold.The review covered waters near American Samoa, Hawaii and the West Coast, an area home to several dozen species protected under the Endangered Species Act, Otake said. They include blue, fin, sei and sperm whales, sea turtles and five types of coral.Under the law, an informal review can end with a letter saying a project is unlikely to harm protected species. A formal review requires a more detailed assessment of whether the project could put those species at risk of extinction or damage the habitats they depend on.The Marine Minerals Administration requested the quicker route, and in February the fisheries service agreed. It issued its letter 10 days after determining it had enough information to begin the consultation.Otake called the review “cramped, expedited, informal” and said it looked only at the early survey work. She called the approach “apparently unprecedented” and noted the government effectively conceded at an Oct. 30 hearing that it had no prior example.The government argued the fisheries service only had to review the project as the Marine Minerals Administration described it. Otake disagreed, writing that a consulting agency “may not blindly accept” another agency’s description of what it plans to do. In the oil and gas leasing cases the government cited, she noted, agencies completed formal reviews that considered at least some effects after the sale.The government also argued that deep-sea mining is “in its nascent stages and not yet reasonably certain to occur.” Otake said that uncertainty was no excuse, because the law demands foresight.She added that the process began with an unsolicited request from mining company Impossible Metals Inc. The administration is “not leasing for leasing’s sake,” she said.The government asked Otake to leave the approval in place while the agency fixed its review. She refused, calling the error fundamental.“NMFS needs to do the bulk of its consultation duty for the first time,” she said.Otake didn’t discuss the plaintiffs’ other arguments, including one that the review missed indirect effects of early survey work.Otake’s ruling throws out the fisheries service’s environmental approval but does not order the Interior Department to cancel or delay Thursday’s sale. The order leaves unclear whether the department can proceed without that approval or will take other steps before the auction.A second lease sale, for waters off the Northern Mariana Islands and Guam, is tentatively scheduled in December. The same lawyers are challenging that sale in a separate case.The groups have also filed another lawsuit challenging the administration’s final leasing notice for the American Samoa sale.Representatives for the fisheries service, the Marine Minerals Administration and Earthjustice did not immediately respond to requests for comment.Subscribe to our free newslettersOur weekly newsletter Closing Arguments offers the latest about ongoing trials, major litigation and rulings in courthouses around the U.S. and the world, while the monthly Under the Lights dishes the legal dirt from Hollywood, sports, Big Tech and the arts.Additional Reads
Deep-sea mining sale off American Samoa in flux after wildlife review tossed
Full Article
Original Source
Read the full article at Courthousenews →KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.