Prosecutors say Huawei’s top brass encouraged employees to rip proprietary information from competitors to build one of the world’s largest telecommunications businesses in a 20-year racketeering scheme.BROOKLYN (CN) — After more than two months of trial, jurors will soon begin deliberating the criminal case against Chinese telecommunications giant Huawei, which prosecutors accuse of stealing technology from American companies and violating U.S. sanctions by lying to banks about its business dealings in Iran.Prosecutors say Huawei’s top brass encouraged employees to rip proprietary information from competitors to build one of the world’s largest telecommunications businesses in a 20-year racketeering scheme.Assistant U.S. Attorney Meredith Arfa told jurors in her closing argument Monday, which lasted about five hours, that Huawei built its empire on “theft, lies and cover-ups,” signaling to its employees, “You can lie and steal and cheat as long as you’re doing it for the benefit of Huawei.”Prosecutors say the directive went to the top, accusing Huawei founder Ren Zhengfei of brushing off concerns about intellectual property theft and officials of offering employees bonuses for passing along confidential information from competing businesses.Jurors saw evidence of incidents involving the U.S. companies including T-Mobile, Cisco Systems and Quintel. But in his own closing on Tuesday, defense attorney Brian Heberlig said the government cherry-picked isolated incidents involving low-level employees who were fired for their misconduct — and the company, in turn, responded by implementing new policies to make clear that employees who steal will be disciplined.The government, Heberlig argued, “didn’t start with the evidence and ask where it led. They decided it was a criminal enterprise and tried to make everything fit.”Prosecutors also said Huawei concealed from HSBC and other banks the nature of its business in Iran, including calling its subsidiary Skycom a business partner, and claiming it had only limited operations in Iran. In fact, the government says, the company worked on networks that were used by the Iranian government to spy on citizens, including during 2009 demonstrations in Tehran.At the heart of that charge is a 2021 deferred prosecution agreement signed by Huawei CFO Meng Wanzhou, Ren’s daughter, who also goes by Kathy Meng. Following her 2018 arrest in Vancouver, Canada, which strained relations between the U.S., its North American neighbor and China, Meng signed the agreement admitting to misleading HSBC executives about the company’s dealings in Iran.“Meng admitted that she, meaning Huawei, [repeatedly] lied to HSBC,” Arfa said Monday. “This is indisputable evidence of a conspiracy to defraud Huawei’s banks, carried out by one of Huawei’s most senior executives.”Heberlig on Tuesday made the case that the banks were well aware of Huawei’s work in Iran and the relationship between it and Skycom, and said it wasn’t an issue for the financial institutions since Iran-based dealings made up only a small fraction of their overall business.The Steptoe LLP attorney also asked jurors to focus on the specific language of Meng’s agreement with the government, arguing that Meng had learned her statements to HSBC were misrepresentations during the government’s investigation, but wasn’t aware at the time.“The agreement is no shortcut to a guilty verdict,” Heberlig said, describing it as “characterizing facts without establishing Ms. Meng’s criminal intent.”In addition to racketeering conspiracy, Huawei and three of its subsidiaries are charged with conspiracy to steal trade secrets, wire and bank fraud, conspiracy to defraud the U.S., International Emergency Economic Powers Act violations and conspiracies to launder money and obstruct justice.At trial, jurors saw a video of a Huawei employee, who had gained access to T-Mobile’s secure lab, snapping off a piece of a phone-testing robot called “Tappy,” which can simulate a human finger to use a touch screen device, and slipping it into his backpack. Prosecutors also sought to prove that Huawei employees stole internet router technology from another American tech conglomerate, Cisco, and used it in routers that Huawei then sold in the U.S.Huawei doesn’t dispute those incidents but says the company took steps to clean up its act in the aftermath: The Tappy-stealing employee was fired, and Huawei recalled the routers and offered to replace them with Cisco routers, free of charge.“Can any compliance program guarantee perfection? Of course not,” Heberlig said. “There’s just no way to prevent [every] violation.”U.S. District Judge Ann Donnelly, a Barack Obama appointee, is expected to charge the jury on Wednesday before deliberations begin.Huawei does business in more than 170 countries and holds more than 165,000 active patents for telecommunications, cloud, AI and device technology.Subscribe to our free newslettersOur weekly newsletter Closing Arguments offers the latest about ongoing trials, major litigation and rulings in courthouses around the U.S. and the world, while the monthly Under the Lights dishes the legal dirt from Hollywood, sports, Big Tech and the arts.Additional Reads
Corporate cleanup or criminal cover-up? Huawei trial closes in Brooklyn
Full Article
Original Source
Read the full article at Courthousenews →KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.