When you volunteer for military service, are you volunteering to be sexually assaulted? Far too often, the answer is yes – although few young men and women have that in mind when they imagine putting on the uniform. Adding insult to injury, under current law for the military, our service members can’t take anyone in the military to court for the assault. Congress has an opportunity to change that in this lame-duck session. They must not waste this chance. We all know that sexual assault has long plagued the military. You might remember the Tailhook scandal, or the crimes at the Aberdeen Proving Ground, or the dozens of trainees assaulted by instructors at Lackland Air Force Base, or the horrific murder of Vanessa Guillen by a fellow soldier at Ford Hood. The military’s independent investigation after that killing found a “permissive environment” for sexual assault and sexual harassment at Fort Hood – nearly thirty years after leaders vowed they would root out sexual violence in the military. Every time one of these comes to light, leadership makes some changes — a new hotline, new procedures for prosecuting sex crimes, new data collection approaches. But the assaults continue. The Pentagon estimates that last year, some 20,000 active-duty service members were sexually assaulted out of a total of 1.3 million. The actual number is probably far higher. According to a study by Brown University’s Costs of War project, between 2001 and 2023 – the full span of U.S. involvement in Afghanistan and most of its time in Iraq – 24% of active-duty women and nearly 2% of active-duty men were sexually assaulted. This might all sound familiar. But there’s more. Few people know that the law makes it all but impossible for sexual assault victims in the military to sue their rapists and enablers. Of course, the law has always been used to shield perpetrators when it comes to sexual assault. But for people who are assaulted while serving in the military, a peculiar rule known as the Feres Doctrine blocks nearly any possibility that wrongdoers will be held civilly accountable. This prohibits any lawsuits against the government for injuries that “arise out of or are in the course of activity incident to service,” in the words of the 1950 Supreme Court case that created this rule. You might think this would apply only to the core parts of military service, like injuries sustained in combat or training. Maybe that would make sense. Since then, the court has said repeatedly that the point of this rule is to protect military discipline and effectiveness. Certainly, it could be tough for a commander to send troops into harm’s way knowing they might be sued for doing so. But the Feres Doctrine goes much farther. Under it, service members cannot sue for essentially anything that happens to them in their service. That includes injuries or death because of malpractice at a military hospital, or because of negligence by a civilian FAA employee, or because of an illicit intelligence experiment in which service members were given LSD without their knowledge. Courts have ruled that all these were “incident to service.” And they have ruled the same about sexual assault. With those awful words – “incident to service” – the courts tell us that rape is just something that happens when you’re in the military. Sign up, and your body is no longer your own. Of course, there are exceptions. In one recent, high-profile decision, a California appeals court allowed a U.S. Army officer to proceed with her lawsuit for damages after an alleged assault by a fellow service member. Because of the Feres Doctrine, the court had to rely on details like the fact that the alleged assault happened at a hotel and not a base. In a military that prizes discipline and trust, how can sexual assault be treated as a natural part of service? And in a legal system that rejects sexual violence and values accountability, why should the location of an assault be a deciding factor in whether a person is held responsible? The Military Sexual Trauma Accountability Act would allow service members who are sexually assaulted to recover damages for their injuries —just like a civilian. (Lance Cpl. Rebecca Eller/U.S. Marine Corps) The courts have created this morass. Congress needs to act, since the courts are bound by precedents gone astray. And Congress can act. When Congress resumes next week, it can pass the Military Sexual Trauma Accountability Act, currently pending before the Senate Judiciary Committee. This law would allow service members who are sexually assaulted, or subject to comparable misconduct like sexual harassment and revenge porn, to recover damages for their injuries — just like a civilian. Some people might be comfortable with the fact that the military protects attackers and drives out victims of sexual assault. Indeed, Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth, a man who champions warriors and denigrates defenders, is trying to chip away at some of the protection and accountability measures made by prior administrations. With this law, Congress can undo some of the damage. The Pentagon obviously doesn’t want its internal records exposed in court. And at some point, leaders will tire of paying out judgments or settlements to victim after victim. Why act now? For one thing, sexual assault is bad for military readiness. Impunity encourages law-breaking, which erodes military norms and discipline. What’s more, being sexually assaulted or sexually harassed drives good people out of the service. It’s increasingly hard to recruit people into the military. We should make every effort to keep them in once they have joined. But most importantly, passing the law is just the right thing to do. The U.S. military is built on trust and decency. Protecting sexual assault sabotages this proud tradition. This legislation will tell every American service member that rape is not part of being in the military. We must not let some leaders’ affinity for violence and cruelty erode the rule of law. Without the midterms looming, members of Congress can do some real legislating rather than political posturing. Many have nothing to lose. Compare that to the service members who are willing to lose everything for this country. It’s time for members of Congress to become heroes to our military service members and veterans. Let’s get this passed – and reaffirm the nation’s commitment to those who serve. Saira Mohamed is the Agnes Roddy Robb Chair in Jurisprudence, Ethics, and Social Responsibility at the University of California, Berkeley School of Law. She is the author of “What a Country Owes Its Soldiers.”
Congress, you can declare that sexual assault has no place in the military. Here’s how.
Full Article
Original Source
Read the full article at Militarytimes →KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.